Kia Sportage vs Nissan Qashqai

Kia Sportage vs. Qashqai
Credits: Pete Gibson
20 Aug, 2010 1:04pm

Kia hopes its new Sportage will be the class of the crossover field. We see how it fares against Nissan's top-selling Qashqai

Kia is hoping to make hay with the latest addition to its range! The new Sportage slots beneath the Sorento SUV as the firm’s family-sized crossover, and aims to add a dash of style to the market.

With renowned ex-Audi stylist Peter Schreyer responsible for the newcomer, the Sportage is like nothing else on the market. But it has substance, too, as it comes with a large and versatile cabin, plus a huge list of standard kit.

Video: watch CarBuyer's video review of the Kia Sportage

For now, the Sportage is available only with a 2.0-litre diesel engine and in First Edition four-wheel-drive trim, although a wider line-up including two-wheel-drive variants arrives later this year.

Yet it won’t have everything its own way, as the Nissan Qashqai is one of our favourite crossovers, as well as one of the UK’s best-selling cars. Its revamped 2.0-litre diesel brings impressive eco credentials, and in n-tec trim it’s well equipped.

Both models offer a big dose of style, performance and economy, plus car-like handling – but only one can be our pick of the crop...

Verdict

THE Qashqai has been a huge hit since it blew the family 4x4 market wide open, but it tastes defeat here. The Kia Sportage is arguably the firm’s best effort yet, mixing exciting looks, decent ride comfort and tidy handling. It also has a larger and more classy cabin than its rival, and solid build quality.

Most appealing of all is the Korean car’s price. For £2,718 less than its rival, the four-wheel-drive First Edition is better equipped and greener than the Qashai, and it comes with Kia’s trailblazing seven-year warranty.

The Nissan isn’t disgraced, though. It’s still great to drive and recent revisions have made it more eco-friendly and better looking than ever. But it can’t match the all-round brilliance of its sharp-suited competitor. The Sportage’s low price and generous kit count seal the deal for a maiden road test victory.

1. Kia Sportage 2.0 CRDi First Edition
EVEN without its price advantage, the Sportage would be a deserving winner. And with its seven-year warranty, economical engine and low CO2 output, it makes a great ownership proposition. We hope the forthcoming two-wheel-drive
model is as good – it could be fighting for top honours in the burgeoning crossover sector.

2. Nissan Qashqai 2.0 dCi N-TEC
THE revised Qashqai is the best yet, with a neat design, cleaner engine and impressive standard specification. It’s also great to drive and boasts a practical cabin. Still, despite its recent improvements, it can’t match what’s on offer from the excellent Sportage.

Disqus - noscript

The Kia Car Company seem to be selling a car package, rather than a car sold on it’s own merits, the established motor companies are now trying to match the package with so called lifelong guarantees free insurance and servicing etc, etc, and that is a good thing, as it shows how competition can work for the consumer.
While Kia cars now look very stylish they do seem to be blatant copies of several other cars rolled into one.
I would like to know if the engine technology at Kia is still old technology passed down from other motor companies, or are Kia designing and building their own modern engines?
If not, then one could say that an all round care package would be a necessity, and regular servicing would be needed to keep the vehicle within manufacturers tolerances, and in a comparison test the freebies in the service package, should not be taken into account.

AEX 1,339
For more breaking car news and reviews, subscribe to Auto Express - available as a weekly magazine and on your iPad. We'll give you 6 issues for £1 and a free gift!

Sponsored Links