Search Car Reviews:



SEAT Ibiza 1.6TDI CR Sport

It costs pennies to run, but is new diesel-engined Ibiza better than the Ecomotive model?

SEAT Ibiza 1.6TDI CR Sport

Text: Jack Carfrae / Photos: Otis Clay

November 2009

  • Rating:

SEAT’S Ibiza just got more frugal! The Spanish firm has brought its supermini bang up-to-date with the addition of the Volkswagen Group’s 1.6-litre common rail diesel engine.

Although it’s not quite as eco-friendly as the super economical Ibiza Ecomotive, the latest model packs more punch than the Ecomotive version and offers a better blend of performance and economy, without compromising rock bottom running costs.

With 104bhp and 250Nm of torque on tap, the TDI CR certainly has more punch than the 79bhp Ecomotive model, but it still doesn’t feel particularly fast. While it’s comfortable at town speeds and happy to cruise on the motorway, you’ll find yourself hanging onto the gears much longer than usual in order to make progress.

What’s more, the cabin becomes noisy at speed. The baby SEAT’s soundproofing is a little lacklustre, as there’s an abnormal amount of roar from the wind and tyres at anything above urban speeds.
The sports suspension keeps the Ibiza in check through the bends. There’s a little more body roll than usual, but for the most part, the car feels safe and planted.

But the Ibiza begins to make up for its shortcomings with excellent build quality. As is typical with VW group models, the SEAT’s interior is superbly built, with tough, soft-touch plastics, so it puts pricier hatchbacks to shame. The silver-look dash panels on our test car might not appeal to everyone, though – they seem a little garish from the drivers’ seat, but more conventional dark plastics are available. Outside, the supermini looks just as sharp as ever, with its angular headlamps and distinct, knife-edged bodywork.

At £12,985, it won’t break the bank and the spec list is generous, too. However, the Ibiza’s real trump card is its miniscule running costs – it sits in insurance group four and averages a penny-pinching 67.3mpg. Road tax is also cheap – low emissions of 109g/km mean that your annual disc will cost only £35 per year. SEAT claims to have one of the youngest target audiences in the UK, and with figures like those, it’s not hard to see why.

2 Comments

Performance

I have just bought the above over the fiesta as it is better priced, better equipped, more economical and much faster.

I think three stars is an unfair grading for this car when the fiesta keeps getting five stars. Please explain to us readers why Fords are so much preffered to all the other manufactures.

Do you work on commission?

The below is from an article about a similar fiesta which is two seconds slower to 60, i don't read anything about holding on to gears longer to make the same progress?

At the track, the Ford covered 0-60mph in 12.5 seconds, which makes it two-tenths of a second faster than its rival here. The message is rammed home with the in-gear figures, because the run from 30-70mph took 1.7 seconds longer in the Corsa.

By gaffer1986 on 11 December, 2009, 9:15am

I reached the same conclusion as Gaffer - on paper the Seat beats the Fiesta hands down and I couldn't quite work out why the Fiesta was so much more expensive than its opposition and yet selling by the bucket load.On taking the Seat for a test drive we did question whether we could live with the road and wind noise but in reality it is not an issue.What is an issue is the fuel consumption - frugal it is not! The mpg is a fraction - and I mean a fraction - of the promised figures. I have yet to find out whether it is just my car or whether there is a wider problem with this new CR Diesel engine? The dealer is remaining very tight lipped about it which raises my suspicions.....
Great little car but if i had known about the mpg I would not have bought it - where is that Ford catalogue...... I know it is about here somewhere..............

By Hermann on 13 December, 2009, 4:36pm

You need to register to post comments. Existing members can log in below to comment, otherwise click here to join.



Sponsored Results

Social Bookmarks
  • facebook
  • digg
  • delicious
  • furl
  • stumbleupon
- Advertisement -

Sponsored Results

Free Brochures and Test Drives

FIRST OPINION

    THE addition of the VW group’s latest common rail diesel unit has brought the Ibiza bang up-to-date with its competitors. It’s a competent, affordable all-rounder, but it’s not perfect – it feels underpowered and there’s a lot of wind noise at speed. What’s more, the super frugal Ecomotive model is road tax exempt, has better fuel economy and costs £195 less. It might have less power, but at this level, the Ecomotive seems the more sensible option.

 

AT A GLANCE

    Price: £12,985
    Engine: 1.6-litre 4cyl
    Power: 104bhp
    Torque: 250Nm
    0-62mph: 10.7 seconds
    Top speed: 116mph
    Economy: 67.3mpg
    CO2: 109g/km
    Standard equipment: 16-inch alloy wheels, sports suspension and seats, leather steering wheel and gearknob, air-con, CD/mp3 stereo
    On sale: Now

     
    - Advertisement -