Three Auto Express staffers have taken to the wheel and delivered different verdicts - the question is, who won the argument? The first driver to grab the keys is a luxury car enthusiast, and he simply couldn't get on with the flagship Smart's incredibly firm suspension, and still thinks the Roadster line-up is overpriced. Next up was a performance fan, who found the uncompromising design of this 101bhp sportster to be spot on.
Finally, a Roadster aficionado was left cold by the modifications which he thought added very little except a hefty £2,482 to the price. We all agreed the Brabus bodykit gave welcome muscle to the Smart's cheeky shape, and the tuned powerplant brought impressive performance. At £16,995, this is an expensive little car, but given its extra trim, it is only £575 more than a similarly specced standard Roadster-Coupe.
Tell us about your car in our Driver Power survey.
For more breaking car news and reviews, subscribe to Auto Express magazine. We'll give you 6 issues for £1 and a free gift!