Search Car Reviews



See all makes



Seat Ibiza ST vs. Skoda Fabia Scout

Is SEAT’s new Ibiza ST the best supermini estate on sale? We try it out against Skoda’s Fabia Scout.

Seat Ibiza ST vs. Skoda Fabia Scout

Photos: Otis Clay October 2010

Small on the outside and big on space – the latest generation of supermini estates promises the best of both worlds. And SEAT is aiming to add a healthy shot of desirability to this formula with its new Ibiza ST. 

Gone are the days when load-carriers adhered to the form-follows-function mantra, because today’s estates need to look good, too. The Ibiza has a head start here, as the regular hatch is one of the sector’s most distinctive choices.

We test the new ST flagship in the shape of the 1.6-litre TDI Sport. It produces 104bhp, and is effectively the same unit as is found beneath the bonnet of its rival here. That’s because competition comes from fellow VW Group brand Skoda. 

Unlike the SEAT, the Fabia is available with two 1.6-litre diesel options, and to match the Ibiza on price we’ve got the 89bhp version. Why the difference? Because we’ve chosen the Scout variant, with its rough-and-tough body mouldings giving it a crossover look.

Only £20 separates our competitors on price, but which of these head-turning supermini estates is the better buy – the sleek and sporty SEAT or the purposeful Skoda?

For an alternative review of the latest SEAT Ibiza visit our sister site carbuyer.co.uk

What Next

For more breaking car news and reviews, subscribe to Auto Express magazine. We'll give you 6 issues for £1 and a free gift!

< Previous   Next >

Sponsored Results

2 Comments

Pointless!

This test is pointless! You are testing a car which is aimed at a driver who enjoys sporty handling and doesn't mind a firmer ride, against one that is clearly aimed at a driver who prefers a more mainstream car. OK, both are based on the same platform, and both are from the VW stable, and both are small estates, but why compare them? I doubt many buyers who are interested in the Ibiza would even look at the Fabia, or vice versa. The Ibiza is a sporty small car that has been given a little extra space in the back and you wouldn't buy one if you were looking for a true estate car.

Of the two I would not entertain the Skoda, simply as its looks do not appeal. The Ibiza would win hands down, irrespective of the smaller luggage area.

Oh, incidentally, my frequent experience driving a 1.6CRDi Ibiza is that the engine is anything but noisy even when starting from cold. Have you really driven the car or are you just basing the report on previous encounters with the older diesel engines?

Overall, no suprise that the Ibiza comes last as when did you ever put a SEAT first? Boring and predictable, as usual!

By Debbie312 on 23 October, 2010, 5:52pm

No brainer really - for different reasons

I'd have the Skoda - better make, better looking, will probably be more reliable and cheaper to run.
The Seat is ugly to me - they've got suckered into copying those awful Bangle BMW designs that look ridiculous - all creases and awkward lines.
I'd have the Skoda Scout, but if I was up for a more sporty estate, I'd have a Skoda VRS estate!

By gavsmit on 7 November, 2010, 8:57pm

You need to register to post comments. Existing members can log in below to comment, otherwise click here to join.



Sponsored Results

Social Bookmarks

Full Car Reviews

Skoda Fabia Scout fc

1st Skoda Fabia Scout 1.6 TDI

The Skoda is less powerful than the SEAT, but can tough looks, lots of space and a comfortable drive help it win this test against its VW group rival?
Seat Ibiza ST fc

2nd Seat Ibiza ST 1.6 TDI Sport

Spanish flier aims to give sportiness and practicality equal billing. Does it succeed?
- Advertisement -

Sponsored Results

Facts and Figures

Verdict

Despite sharing the same ingredients, these two estates have very different flavours. The new Ibiza ST hits the spot as a small-but-stylish family car – yet we don’t think range-topping Sport trim shows it in the best light. 


Our contenders are priced virtually identically and the SEAT promises more power and sharper responses – but the Skoda is just as fast in real-world conditions and its more comfortable set-up is better suited to family life.


Scout trim also gives the plain Fabia Estate a welcome shot in the arm. And as a load-carrier the Skoda is the clear favourite. Not only is it more spacious than the SEAT, it also comes with more user-friendly features and stability control safety kit is fitted as standard. 

Skoda’s unrivalled reputation for service adds to the Fabia’s appeal, so it wins here. Just ensure you specify the optional spare wheel.


1. Skoda Fabia Scout
What the Skoda lacks in style it makes up for with practicality. The Fabia has more space for both passengers and luggage than its rival, while its less powerful engine is an impressive performer – especially at the pumps. The Scout’s tough-looking body mouldings heighten its appeal and set it apart from ordinary versions.


2. SEAT Ibiza ST
Space is clearly a priority here – why else would you consider buying an estate when the five-door hatch is cheaper and more attractive? And the Ibiza is hampered by its small boot and less roomy back seats. It’s the class-leader for style, but lacks the all-round polish of the Skoda.
 
Find Used Cars

Find your SEAT Ibiza with our used car search.

Find Used Cars
- Advertisement -