Search Car Reviews



See all makes



Audi A1 vs MINI Cooper vs Citroen DS3

We pit Audi's new A1 against its two biggest premium rivals in this exclusive group test - which of these stylish supeminis comes out on top?

Audi A1 vs MINI Cooper vs Citroen DS3

Photos: Matt Vosper November 2010

Audi is on a learning curve with its new supermini. Arriving fashionably late to any party is a risky strategy – as it could all be over before you’ve even got there! So has the firm timed the launch of its eagerly awaited A1 to perfection? 

MINI single-handedly established the sector nearly a decade ago, but has now been joined by a whole host of premium supermini rivals. The most convincing of these is the Citroen DS3, which hit dealers earlier this year and has already notched up a group test victory.

The A1 is set to stir things up again, as it comes with one of the most desirable badges on the road, as well as a proven engine line-up that includes the 1.4 TFSI tested here. In mid-range Sport trim, it’s competitively priced, too, undercutting the MINI Cooper it’s up against.

The baby Brit is fitted with the Chili Pack and a 1.6-litre unit that matches the A1 for power. The DS3 is the joker in the 
pack as it sits between its rivals on price, yet features a more potent version of the MINI’s 1.6-litre engine.

Will it ruin the A1’s road test debut?

What Next

For more breaking car news and reviews, subscribe to Auto Express magazine. We'll give you 6 issues for £1 and a free gift!

< Previous   Next >

Sponsored Results

4 Comments

MiTo

I still prefer the MiTo to any of these. It has the fun and drivability, better thatn the Citroen, and that means you don't have to buy an ugly car (DS3) to have a bit of fun.

By danielbez on 16 November, 2010, 7:04am

Where's the Merc

Why do mags never include the A1's obviously closest rival, the Merc A Class in these group tests? Is it because the Merc's rubbish and they don't want to embarass an important advertiser? And while I have a lot of respect for Citroen's innovative designs, since when has it been a 'premium' brand?

By RogerWillis3 on 16 November, 2010, 9:16am

MINI/A1/DS3

What is your aversion to the MINI? (apart from the usual space one). And since when has Citroen been a premium brand? I have recently driven a new C3 - which I assume is the DS not in drag and the experience is nothing like a MINI. Could the ranking in this test possibly be directly correlated to the advetising space taken by the manufacturers in your publication?

By simonsyddall on 16 November, 2010, 2:06pm

SIMONSYDDAL AND DANIELBEX STOP TALKING CRAP

An alfa falls pieces and depreciates heavily and won't out handle the DS3. Also simonsyddal you obviously don't know the history of Citroen so before criticising the mark read a book on the history of the marque. The DS3 is a well made car and is up there with the German brands. People these days are obviously like sheep and follow the crowd. Citroen interiors have improved drastically over the last decade and so have their designs. The DS3 is a different car to the new C3 as it drives better and the interior superior in every way.

By THREEPOINTEDSTAR on 17 November, 2010, 11:14pm

You need to register to post comments. Existing members can log in below to comment, otherwise click here to join.



Sponsored Results

Social Bookmarks

Full Car Reviews

Citroen DS3 DSport

1st Citroen DS3 DSport

French flier mixes serious performance and cosseting ride comfort to dazzling effect - but is that enough to edge out its more premium competition?
Audi A1 TSFI

2nd Audi A1 1.4 TFSI

The eagerly anticipated Audi A1 has finally landed in the U.K. - but it faces stiff competition from the established MINI and current favourite the Citroen DS3, can its premium badge help it win this test?
MINI Cooper Chili Pack

3rd MINI Cooper Chili Pack

MINI might have kickstarted the trend for good looking superminis with a serious fun factor, but is the recently updated original still strong enough to fend off these fresh new rivals?
- Advertisement -

Sponsored Results

Facts and Figures

Verdict

When we sat down to compile our verdict, the A1 was in pole position. But the more we tried to justify first place, the more we realised it was our winner for the wrong reasons. Cars in the premium supermini sector should be fun and full of character – and that’s where it comes up short.

The Audi has a beautifully built cabin, a great engine and highly desirable badge. And if you’re an accountant, the more attractive prices, lower emissions and strong resale values make it the number one choice. There’s no doubt it’s the wisest investment, but you’ll never take the A1 out 
for a spin for the hell of it.

So it takes the runners-up spot behind the brilliant Citroen. With sharp looks, genuinely impressive performance and a spacious cabin, the DS3 DSport is the best all-rounder of our trio. It’s sure to put a smile on your face, yet demands fewest sacrifices in terms of comfort or practicality.

That leaves the MINI Cooper in last. Despite the recent changes, its single-minded focus on driving pleasure and retro appeal can’t compensate for the lacklustre performance of its 1.6-litre engine and cramped cabin.

1. Citroen DS3 DSport
The DSport provides hot hatch pace, livewire handling and quirky looks – all laced with a healthy dose of practicality. It’s not the most prestigious choice, and it doesn’t have the lowest running costs, but the Citroen is the best all-rounder in this trio.

2. Audi A1 1.4 TFSI Sport
It brings a slice of big car luxury and refinement to the supermini class, but the understated styling and uninspiring dynamics count against the A1. If all you want is a premium badge and a sensible investment, this is the number one – but it lacks personality.

3. MINI Cooper Chili Pack
From its exterior styling to its retro interior and lively driving dynamics, the MINI can’t be mistaken for anything else. But the fun Citroen is faster and more comfortable, while the A1 is cheaper and roomier.
 
- Advertisement -