Search Car Reviews



See all makes

Audi A5 Sportback

We have a score to settle with Sportback’s unruly nose!

Audi A5 Sportback header

By James Disdale

March 2011

Our A5 and I have come to blows in recent weeks. You see, whenever I get behind the wheel of the sleek Audi, it can be like entering the ring with a heavyweight boxing champion.

The problem is the steering, which is becoming increasingly unruly. On anything other than smooth, straight roads, the Sportback’s front wheels have a mind of their own. Bumps and cambers cause the nose to wander alarmingly and without warning, while the leather-bound rim bucks and writhes in your hands. This means that heading down a narrow back road can be unsettling and tiring, as every dab of the brakes or prod of the accelerator can cause the car to suddenly veer towards the hedge.

At first I thought I was imagining this wayward tendency, as colleagues didn’t detect anything remotely untoward after short stints behind the wheel. However, one by one they took the A5 for longer journeys, and returned with tales of torque steer and tramlining.

In the car’s defence, the problem has got worse as the front tyres have worn – the Bridgestone rubber is nearly down to its wear bars and needs changing. Yet the issue has been evident since the Sportback joined our fleet with only a few miles on the clock. I suspect the steamroller-wide optional 18-inch alloys are the culprit – I reckon a version on 17-inch rims would be a model of good behaviour.

It’s a shame that this shadow has been cast over the Audi, because in every other respect it is performing faultlessly as swift and stylish family transport. 

The rakish shape still turns heads, more than a year after the model hit UK showrooms. Only the other day, the attendant at a London petrol station remarked on what a lovely car it was. And the Sportback isn’t only a pretty face – it’s practical, too.

While the four-seater layout still irritates, the cavernous 480-litre boot swallows my 10-month-old daughter’s pram and assorted bags with ease. But it’s the quality, comfort and refinement of the cabin that really stand out.

Very few cars on our fleet can match the A5’s abilities as a long-distance express. The dash is perfectly laid out, noise is kept to a minimum and the £485 optional sports seats leave me ache free, even after a long stint behind the wheel. 

Better still, the 2.0-litre TDI is well and truly run in now, and serves up the sort of effortless pace and refinement you’d normally associate with a bigger six-cylinder unit. The only clue to the unit’s entry-level status is the 42.2mpg return at the pumps.

This mix of motorway-munching ability, great economy and desirable looks means the A5 has barely had a rest in the past 10 months. As a result, the service warning light has illuminated, 
so a trip to the dealer is on the cards. While it’s there, I’ll get the technicians to look at the tracking and fit new tyres. With luck, this fettling will restore the Audi’s composure, meaning I can once again enjoy it without worrying about any knock-out punches.

What Next

Sponsored Results

7 Comments

I thought it was me.

Interesting - my A5 Cabriolet impressed with its accurate steering when new but now with only 8500 miles on the clock it wanders noticeably and I feel less confident along roads that used to be huge fun. My problem is not as severe as yours but disappointing none the less. It's also a 2.0 TDi on 18" rubber which still has 4.5 - 5mm tread left. I would get the tracking checked but Audi charges getting on for £200 for that so I'll just put up with it. Any one else have this experience?

By MarkSalmon on 31 March, 2011, 9:47am

same problem

Had the same problem on New A4 Avant Sline with 18" Bridgestones and when tread got low, changed to conti sport3's problem dissappeared, rides much better, a lot quieter and much more secure steering feel, no torque steer, tramlining etc.

By swiftsure3 on 31 March, 2011, 10:31am

And Me!

I'm glad someone else has mentioned this. I've got a A4 Avant 2.0TFsi with 19" wheels. Even with new tyres, if I try to put my foot down on a non-smooth road its always had a tendency to head straight for the hedge . Even the white lines on the road can make overtaking a little hair-raising! You have to make sure you have a tight hold on the wheel. Not something I expected from such an expensive car.

By RichEaton on 31 March, 2011, 10:36am

And Me!

I'm glad someone else has mentioned this. I've got a A4 Avant 2.0TFsi with 19" wheels. Even with new tyres, if I try to put my foot down on a non-smooth road its always had a tendency to head straight for the hedge . Even the white lines on the road can make overtaking a little hair-raising! You have to make sure you have a tight hold on the wheel. Not something I expected from such an expensive car.

By RichEaton on 31 March, 2011, 10:39am

phil-kent

glade this problem has been highlighted , as i am/was seriously considering buying an A5 but not untill Audi have commented on this problem so over to you Audi

By 38lucilla on 31 March, 2011, 11:21am

me too!

Don't worry chaps, my 3 series BMW does it and I'm only on 17's! Interestingly I'm on Bridgstones too, but didn't know what to change them for. Will now try some Continentals. n.b BMW charges a fortune for wheel alignment also!!

By hsbcgeoff on 31 March, 2011, 12:00pm

Tyres

Bridgestone tyres are notorious for highlighting torque steer and tram-lining on Audis due to their relatively hard compound. The larger the wheels the more prominent this effect becomes on any car. It is also the low profile and large width of tyre that is responsible for the tyre slip causing a 'skipping' sensation when on full lock when manoeuvring. This will always occur when cars are specified with large wheels, especially considering the state of British roads.
Having a four wheel alignment carried out will not change this and you will be wasting your money, the wheel alignment should be perfect as from factory unless the wheels have been kerbed or hit major pot holes.

The best way to reduce this torque steer and tram lining is to change to a softer tyre when the time comes to change and make sure all four wheels are fitted with the same make and model of tyre and the tread difference between them varys no more than 3mm front to rear and 2mm across the axle. Michelin tyres are comparatively softer but it is best to get a recommendation from the dealer at the time. Also frequently checking the tyre pressures will help. Do not over-inflate the tyres as this will make the symptoms worse.

By jwavdigital on 4 April, 2011, 11:30pm

You need to register to post comments. Existing members can log in below to comment, otherwise click here to join.



Sponsored Results

- Advertisement -

Pictures

Audi A5 Sportback header
Audi A5 Sportback interior
Audi A5 Sportback gearstick
Audi A5 Sportback tyres

Sponsored Results

Find New Cars

Find your new Audi A5 Sportback with our new car search:

Find New Cars

Second Opinion

“You can bet your mortgage on the fact that anybody who takes the A5 keys will come back moaning about its steering. This is a real shame because, as a car for tackling long journeys, the rest of the package is brilliant.”
Ross Pinnock, Road test editor

Other Reports

REPORT

[+]
Cabin is a masterclass in design and build quality. Highlights include the excellent, centre console-mounted MMI control for the stereo and satellite navigation. It’s perfectly sited, meaning you are quickly and easily able to access all the A5’s many functions – without having to take your eyes off the road.
[-]
While the Sportback’s optional 18-inch alloys look fantastic, they adversely affect the dynamics. They wear wide, low-profile rubber and cause wayward handling characteristics on the UK’s bumpy roads. We would save the £665 cost and stick with the standard 17-inch rims.
On fleet since:
- Advertisement -