If you were to write a compact MPV wishlist, it might read like this: sliding rear doors, versatile seats that don't have to be removed from the car, good visibility and road manners, a big boot, low running costs and a cheap asking price. 
All in all, Mazda has stolen a march on the class's more established contenders with a car which is intelligently designed and great to own. 
The one car in the sector that ticks every box is Mazda's 5. It doesn't sell as well as the Vauxhall Zafira or have such a wide range as the Renault Scenic, but if you're in the market for one of the conventional class leaders, we'd urge you to test drive the Mazda before you sign on the dotted line.
With prices starting at less than £15,000 and even the top-of-the-range 2.0-litre 143bhp diesel variant coming in at under £20,000, the 5 undercuts most rivals by around £1,500. Yet it's just as well equipped, and has even lower running costs.
Then there's the interior layout. The large sliding doors provide much better access to the rear compartment than the usual front-hinged items, and the innovative 6+1 seating layout works very well. All in all, Mazda has stolen a march on the class's more established contenders with a car which is intelligently designed and great to own.
Built on the same platform as the new Galaxy, the S-MAX came close to scoring a memorable win. As it is, the seven-seater beat Vauxhall's Zafira in a twin test (Issue 910), thanks to its polished ride and handling and superior cabin layout, with all the seats folding into the floor. Ford has belatedly proved it can build a compact MPV to rival the best.
We may have criticised Vauxhall for not updating the Flex7 seating layout when developing the latest Zafira, but its excellence in other areas isn't in dispute. Sharp looks, good roadholding and an improved dash design mean owners will be happy, while their children will enjoy the space and new features, such as the overhead lockers.
Champ for the last two years, the Scenic still sets the standard in a number of ways. No rival has more family-friendly features, and the innovative driving environment is a breath of fresh air. But you can tell the extra seats in the Grand version were an afterthought, and while it has a great safety record and smooth diesel engines, you pay for the privilege.