It was a close-run thing between this and Halfords' other product. Although it's simple to hook on and off, the clip could have been a little stronger on this kit, but the protection for your phone provided by the six neat, little pads in the cradle is excellent. What's more, the cradle itself could be adjusted quickly to suit our range of mobiles. Vent-mounting is the easier option, because the bracket is more fiddly to sort out.