Michelin Primacy 4 review
A surprise result for Michelin, which had shrugged off its good-on-fuel, poor-in-wet reputation
Michelin is leading the campaign to get tyres used safely right down to their 1.6mm legal minimum. There are strong environmental reasons for this, and the latest stage in the drive is to get EU wet-grip testing done when the tyre is worn – a real-world assessment – rather than brand-new, as is the case currently.
At the launch of the Primacy 4 in 2017 Michelin claimed it delivered a high level of performance from new to the limit. We can only think that it had to give up some performance when new to get that worn-tyre ability because it had by far the worst results across all our wet tests. It’s almost like Michelin has turned the clock back to when it was at the top of the rolling-resistance test but struggled in the wet.
The Primacy 4 had much less grip than the best, seeming to skate over the wet surface, needing lower corner-entry speeds and more steering lock in turns. It did better in deep-water aquaplaning tests, but the overall result was not good.
There was a similar lack of grip in the dry, particularly through long turns, where we had to lift off earlier than with the best rivals to maintain the car’s line. It also felt quite soft, but others had similar problems and joined it at the bottom of the table.
The high point for Michelin was fuel economy, where it was close to the winning Continental and clear of the chasing pack.
"This has been a popular tyre amongst customers since its launch in 2017. It has gained an average customer rating of 4.7/5 from over 1,000 reviews"
|Michelin Primacy 4|
- 1IntroductionWhat are the best tyres for your car? We test eight different SUV specific tyres to match their rising popularity to see which is best
- 21. Nokian PowerproofWell deserved win for Nokian, with a balanced performance across wet and dry tests
- 32. Falken Azenis FK510 SUVImpressive all-round result from Falken which performed well and, importantly, felt good to drive.
- 4=3. Dunlop Sport Maxx RT 2 SUVDecent all-round performance makes this a good option for SUV owners
- 5=3. Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5Promising test debut, with good performance in the wet, but less good at the pumps
- 65. Continental PremiumContact 6A winner at the pumps and easy on the wallet, but you pay a price in the wet
- 76. Hankook Ventus S1 evo2 SUVQuiet and very safe in poor conditions,although dry grip needs work
- 8=7. Cooper Zeon 4XS SportThe Zeon 4XS Sport is showing its age when it comes to fuel consumption
- 9=7. Michelin Primacy 4 - currently readingA surprise result for Michelin, which had shrugged off its good-on-fuel, poor-in-wet reputation
- 10Results by categoryFocus on SUVs brings in new victor