Search Car Reviews



See all makes

VW Golf GTD

Meet the office hottie! No, not our road test editor, but VW’s superb hatch, which has wooed nearly everyone...

VW Golf GTD

By Ross Pinnock

October 2010

OUR VW Golf has established itself as the office hottie at Auto Express. I can see why it attracts admiring glances wherever it goes, but this is one workplace relationship fuelled by hard graft rather than water-cooler gossip. And that’s because our Golf GTD isn’t simply good to look at.

Admittedly, our test car’s optional Vancouver alloys (£410) do wonders for its appearance – I actually prefer them to the distinctive telephone-dial style rims fitted to the GTI. But the VW is earning plaudits for what it does, rather than how it looks.

And you don’t just have to take my word for it, as my colleagues are only too keen to tell me about its talents. I’ve never experienced such a positive response to any car on the Auto Express fleet.

So what makes the GTD such a hit?

Well, it’s hard to pin down to one single element. Chief sub- editor Stuart Morton was most impressed by its in-gear pace. “Bumble along in sixth gear behind someone in the outside lane of the motorway, and the GTD responds supremely when they get out of the way – there’s no need to change down,” he said. “Also, the toys are brilliant. The reversing camera is fantastic and the iPhone integration magic.”

Editor in chief David Johns also emerged from a weekend behind the wheel raving about its abilities. “A car that well and truly debunks the ‘petrol-only’ hot hatch mantra,” he wrote in the logbook.

“Everything that’s great about a Golf GTI – fast, comfortable, super to drive, practical, flexible, fun – but with much better fuel economy. In fact, I reckon it’s actually better than the GTI. Didn’t want to hand the keys back – it’s that good.” Even recent additions to the Auto Express fold have been won over by the Golf’s charms. New motoring writer Paul Bond said: “Every time you get behind the wheel, you’re instantly reminded that you’re in something special. The build quality wouldn’t look out of place on a car twice its price, and the GTD’s potent blend of performance and economy makes it an effortless all-rounder.”

I can’t say I disagree with any of the above. Back in April, the Golf GTD lost a twin test to our long-term SEAT Leon FR TDI, largely because its VW Group cousin is significantly cheaper. But the more I drive the Golf, the more I think it’s worth every penny. So I’ll let road tester Graeme Lambert have the last word. “Best car on the current fleet. No question,” is his entry in the VW’s logbook. And his long- termer? The SEAT Leon FR…

What Next

Sponsored Results

5 Comments

GTD V Leon FR TDi

Glad you changed the Cupra R misprint in the mag to FR TDi here!!!

The thing is the GTD has the active dampers if SEAT were allowed to use them the ride/handling would be alot closer if not the same!!! I still think the Leon FR is the nicer looking car and in Silver with 17" alloys looks quite handsome with a much better ride than optional 18"s. The factory fit bluetooth in Leon I think is much better intergrated system than the accessories add on that your GTD has never mind £110 cheaper. GTD has the much better made interior no doubt but with the electrically and mechanically the same FR TDi and residuals being pretty much the same in the real world 5K is a large gap price wise.

FR still has the edge in my mind though. Cheaper options and cheaper to buy for a little more exterior style but not quite so well made interior and after test driving both we went for the Leon. As 5K is allot of money for an extra 2% handling/driving wise that you only really feel on the limit and for a more tactile but dull interior. On standard suspension the GTD and FR TDi are very close indeed......

By JezyG on 11 October, 2010, 2:46pm

Hmmmm

I have just moved from the ownership of many VW's over a period of years to a BMW 123d MSport and wouldn't go back to VW now. As much as I always thought VW were good, and they are, BMW are much better engineered and have a quality feel to them that I feel VW have lost. I had a test drive in the GTD as I considered purchasing one, being the then owner of a '55 plate 2.0 litre GT TDI which I adored owning. The GTD was very very good, but nowhere near as 'pointy squirty' and impressive as my 123d. I also feel that some of the VW dealerships need to get their acts together to recover some of the customer service concerns, which I now feel BMW have addressed. Love VWs but doubt I'll go back now!

By privatepaul5 on 13 October, 2010, 5:32pm

gloomy gloomy gloomy

What a thoroughly depressing, monotone and gloomy interior.
It may be well built, but with the ever increasing time spent in queued traffic you are going to need something far more interesting to look at.
The only time a golf interior looks good is at night with that lovely blue, but good grief aren't we grey enough in this country already? Look at the concrete and clouds!

By hopsa2305 on 14 October, 2010, 10:39am

Might be good - but expensive

You keep raving on about the Golf GTD and how good it is -- but its not the cheapest to buy and like all VWs when you start to add things the cost really rockets. I have a Mazda 3 185 Sport, when you start to spec up a GTD to match what is standard on the Mazda you are looking at probably £8,000 more, I don't think the Golf is worth it and the Mazda's performance is better!!!

By kelvmaz on 19 November, 2010, 1:53am

spot on review

Took delivery of 2011 model with DSG and the optional ACC (chassis control) in late october and I have to say that it is a joy to behold. It is subtle, understated and quietly classy, and incredibly comfortable. There is an honest, integral beauty to this car which as the reviewer says, is hard to pin down to any one single aspect. Not cheap, yes, but it's a car which delivers complete satisfaction, mixing fun and seriousness in equal measure, together wtih extraordinary economy. I couldn't commend it highly enough.

By rosetta77 on 14 December, 2010, 2:56pm

You need to register to post comments. Existing members can log in below to comment, otherwise click here to join.



Sponsored Results

- Advertisement -

Pictures

VW Golf GTD
VW Golf GTD
VW Golf GTD
VW Golf GTD
VW Golf GTD

Sponsored Results

Other Reports

REPORT

[+]
CABIN quality is first rate, but the steering wheel deserves special mention. It’s one of the few parts of the car you make constant contact with as a driver and the tactile leather, attractive design and sculpted shape make it great to hold.
[-]
THE parcel shelf that covers the boot is our biggest gripe. The assembly feels flimsy and its locating lugs at either side slip out of their clips. One of the straps that attaches it to the tailgate has also broken, but it’s a simple fix.
On fleet since:February 2010
Price when new:£24,230
Mileage:13,580
Engine / Power:2.0-litre 4cyl, 168bhp
Options Fitted:DCC (£765), 18- inch alloys (£410), cruise control (£225), bi-xenons (£1,100), Bluetooth (£410), front and rear parking sensors plus rear camera (£580), touchscreen sat-nav (£1,700)
Trade-in Value Now:£22,050
Insurance Group / Quote:30/ £486
Costs:None so far
Any Problems?:Stone chips on bonnet, broken parcel shelf strap
- Advertisement -