Search Car Reviews:





Noise

Which tyres are the loudest?

Tyre noise

 
a lot of drivers would prefer a tyre that’s quiet to one which improves their vehicle’s handling.
The noise a tyre makes is a key part of comfort. But it’s impossible to detect tyre roar until you have
actually fitted the rubber.

This is a vital test, because with many cars spending most of their lives on motorways, a lot of drivers would prefer a tyre that’s quiet to one which improves their vehicle’s handling.

To achieve the fairest result, we’ve looked at what you’d experience in day-to-day driving. Our assessment should not to be confused with those tests required by law; the latter are carried out from the roadside with specially sealed cars to prevent the engine or transmission affecting the outcome.

The human ear can detect a change of three decibels, so the difference in noise between our best and worst performers would be just about noticeable from behind the wheel.

Our winner was the Kumho by a healthy margin of half-a-decibel. Fellow Korean Hankook tied with Fulda for second, with Maxxis close behind. Surprisingly, the big-name tyres were well outside the top five – remarkable given the development that goes into the premium brands.

Dunlop was seventh, followed by Yokohama, BFGoodrich, Continental and Goodyear. Bridgestone, Pirelli, Michelin and Toyo all have work to do.

Vredestein’s wet weather prowess ultimately worked against it in this part of our assessment. With its big water channels trapping a substantial amount of air, the Sportrac3 is a noisy tyre – and so it found itself a fair way off the pace in last place.

How we did it…

You might never reach the limit when cornering or braking, but
a noisy tyre is with you all the time – which is why we include this assessment in our test.

Our Passat was driven twice over specially prepared rough NVH (noise, vibration and harshness) tarmac at 37mph.

A microphone was positioned by the driver’s ear, close to
the door, in order to provide a real world assessment. We took an average noise figure over two 10-second runs.

Advertisement
Results (decibels)
Kumo 69.0 Hankook 69.5
Fulda 69.5 Maxxis 69.6
Matador 70.0 Uniroyal 70.0
Dunlop 70.5 Yokohama 70.5
BF Goodrich 70.6 Continental 70.7
Goodyear 70.7 Bridgestone 71.0
Pirelli 71.0 Michelin 71.1
Toyo 71.3 Vredestein 71.7
Rolling Resistance
Michelin 100 Hankook 93.9
Yokohama 89.8 Bridgestone 88.3
Matador 86.2 Kumho 86.0
Dunlop 85.6 Goodyear 83.4
Fulda 83.0 Continental 83.0
Uniroyal 82.8 Vredestein 82.7
Toyo 82.7 BFGoodrich 81.3
Maxxis 77.4 Pirelli 73.7