Search Car Reviews



See all makes



Alfa 159 vs SEAT Exeo

Alfa Romeo has fitted a powerful yet efficient new diesel to its gorgeous 159. Is it a better executive car choice than SEAT’s Exeo?

Alfa 159 vs SEAT Exeo

December 2009

German brands dominate the compact executive car market – but if you want to stand out from the crowd, there’s an obvious alternative. The Alfa Romeo 159 is one of the world’s most beautiful models.

The lure of its magical badge reels in enthusiasts, while its gorgeous styling never fails to turn heads. And in a minor shake-up of the range, Alfa has introduced a pair of new engines to give the saloon even more appeal.

Although the company’s new 200bhp 1750i petrol powerplant will fire the imagination, the latest 170bhp 2.0-litre JTDm diesel makes the most sense. It slots into the range between the existing 1.9 and 2.4-litre oil-burners, and is sure to be a very popular choice.

But the pretty 159 isn’t the only option for buyers wanting a blend of Latin style and a proven diesel engine. The SEAT Exeo is based on the previous-generation Audi A4 – so it’s built on solid foundations. Competitive prices make it even more tempting, while the VW Group’s latest 2.0-litre common-rail engine is the icing on the cake.

So, if you want to sidestep the obvious German compact executive models, which of these cars is the better choice? We pitch them head-to-head to find out.

For an alternative review of the latest Alfa Romeo 159 visit our sister site carbuyer.co.uk

What Next

For more breaking car news and reviews, subscribe to Auto Express magazine. We'll give you 6 issues for £1 and a free gift!

< Previous   Next >

Sponsored Results

2 Comments

Alfa Romeo 159 TB or JTD ?

Your article makes life difficult for a sworn Alfistta like me. I own an Alfa 156 1,8 TS, but compared to the speedy old Giulietta 1,8, it lacks on acceleration. If the 156 had a 200 PS TB motor it would be my car. Still the Alfa 159 TB doesn't look bad. Now you mentioned the Alfa 159 JDT and all the benefits coming from its motor!
Thank you very much for this comparison, which places the 159 in a new perspective. But does it provide a good accelerating potential ?
An Alfa Romeo which cannot .. "ascape" ... from a ... pressing Ford Kooga is not a real Alfa !

By nikism on 3 December, 2009, 10:52am

Puzzled

Thanks for the review, very interesting. Although you got me puzzled. You mention several times the Exeo looks dated since it is based on the previous A4, the one revised in 2005, same year Alfa presented the 159 and BMW the new 3 series. On another review here dated 2007, you present the 3 series vs C class vs Audi A4 (B7) vs Alfa 159. All of them (including the A4 B7) came on top of the Alfa 159 back then. Now, this Exeo seems to be an improved version of that A4 B7, with a common rail engine, and cheaper, and now it comes under the Alfa Romeo.

So here are my questions: 1. How come the Alfa was the worst back then and now against an "A4" with a more advanced engine it is better? 2. Why an interior (Exeo/A4 B7) that was fantastic two years ago now it's so dated?

Is it the rings? no matter what, if it's got 4 rings (or it is German) it is better than any Alfa Romeo, if not, then we'll do a proper test. Sorry pal, but looks like it.

http://www.autoexpress.co.uk/carreviews/grouptests/209026/compact_executives.html

By BetaRomeo on 3 December, 2009, 9:57pm

You need to register to post comments. Existing members can log in below to comment, otherwise click here to join.



Sponsored Results

Social Bookmarks

Full Car Reviews

SEAT Exeo Sport

SEAT Exeo Sport

Great new engine makes Italian charmer even harder to resist.
Alfa Romeo 159 Lusso

Alfa Romeo 159 Lusso

Premium feel and proven mechanicals stand saloon in good stead.
- Advertisement -

Sponsored Results

Facts and Figures

Verdict

The SEAT Exeo is a car of contrasts. There’s no hiding its previous-generation Audi A4 roots – and that works for and against it. Despite attempts to liven up the styling, it looks dated inside. Yet this ancestry also means rock-solid quality and strong mechanicals.

The new common-rail diesel engine is much more modern, and combines strong performance with great economy. However hard you try, though, you can’t ignore the SEAT’s lack of charisma, when compared to the Alfa.

The 159 is more than just a pretty face, too – its cabin is atmospheric and sharp responses make for a fun drive.

Most importantly, the new 2.0-litre JTDm engine has the pace to match the Exeo’s TDI, and is cleaner and smoother, too. The Alfa is more expensive, but better residuals and a high kit count help make it our choice.

Ranking
1st:
Alfa Romeo
The 159 trades on its looks, yet should not be judged on appearance alone. The refined new JTDm engine makes this a car you can choose with your head and your heart. Sharp handling and stylish cabin design help to seal the victory.

2nd:
SEAT Exeo
There's no denying the Exeo is excellent value for money. Well built, generously equipped and fitted with VW Group’s latest 2.0-litre TDI engine, it’s an appealing choice. But it can’t match the Alfa’s style, character or fun.

 
- Advertisement -