Search Car Reviews



See all makes



New Mazda 5 vs rivals

Latest MPVs offer more for the money than ever – but can Mazda’s new 5 beat seven-seat rivals from Ford and Toyota?

New Mazda 5 vs. rivals

Photos: Otis Clay February 2011

Family motorists will be in seventh heaven if the latest wave of new metal to hit dealers is anything to go by. People carriers with seven seats are enjoying a resurgence – and the Mazda 5 is the latest to enter the fray.

The newcomer is a heavily revised version of the outgoing car, but a distinctive fresh look and versatile cabin mark it out as a force to be reckoned with. We try the new 113bhp 1.6-litre diesel in Sport trim, and at £21,950 it’s the most expensive model on show here. Yet the Mazda isn’t the only Japanese machine with its sights set on family buyers.

Video: watch CarBuyer's video review of the Mazda 5

 

We have never tested the Toyota Verso in oil-burning guise, so does the 125bhp 2.0 D-4D put the car back on the people carrier map? It is the only model in our trio not to feature sliding rear doors, but in TR trim it’s the most affordable choice. 

Creeping up on the inside is our current class leader. The Ford Grand C-MAX seized the compact MPV crown in Issue 1,144, and its winning blend of practicality, price and driving fun will be hard to beat. The 113bhp 1.6-litre diesel variant is here to defend its honour, in high-spec Titanium trim. It splits its Far Eastern rivals on price. Does it leave them trailing on the road?

What Next

For more breaking car news and reviews, subscribe to Auto Express magazine. We'll give you 6 issues for £1 and a free gift!

< Previous   Next >

Sponsored Results

3 Comments

7 Seaters

I looked at the Mazda and found that the following were not available according to the dealer. Dab radio, Sat nav, and Folding mirrors a requirment in the lanes of rural Kent. Reviewers seem not to take account of the Dab Radio requirment in 2015 its no good buying a car with a built in radio if in 2015 it will not work and that you are unable to pick up traffic reports. I have placed an order for the new Ford and that comes with many bells and whistles and a Dab Radio as standard.

By gregtheegg1 on 15 February, 2011, 11:01am

7 Seaters

I looked at the Mazda and found that the following were not available according to the dealer. Dab radio, Sat nav, and Folding mirrors a requirment in the lanes of rural Kent. Reviewers seem not to take account of the Dab Radio requirment in 2015 its no good buying a car with a built in radio if in 2015 it will not work and that you are unable to pick up traffic reports. I have placed an order for the new Ford and that comes with many bells and whistles and a Dab Radio as standard.

By gregtheegg1 on 15 February, 2011, 11:14am

Excellent point Greg The Egg..... Autoexpress and other auto magazines take note!

By sirsidneyruffdiamond on 18 February, 2011, 3:46pm

You need to register to post comments. Existing members can log in below to comment, otherwise click here to join.



Sponsored Results

Social Bookmarks

Full Car Reviews

Ford Grand C-MAX cornering

1st Ford Grand C-MAX

Our favourite choice in this sector is a very strong proposition
Mazda 5 side

2nd Mazda 5

Can dramatic new look help put sliding doors star back in class contention?
Toyota Verso cornering

3rd Toyota Verso

Cheapest car in this test scores on flexibility
- Advertisement -

Sponsored Results

Facts and Figures

Verdict

Compact MPVs now account for nearly six per cent of UK car sales, which is why so many manufacturers are vying for honours. But which of our contenders looks set to reign in this lucrative market?

It didn’t take us long to establish that the Ford and Mazda would be fighting it out for victory. For all its practicality and affordability, the bland Toyota finishes last here. In isolation it doesn’t put a foot wrong, but after a stint in the other cars it simply feels very ordinary.

Second place goes to the new 5. We’re not convinced by the fresh look, although the core strengths of the old model remain, and the new 1.6-litre diesel is a welcome addition. 

The Mazda is also brilliant value, but not quite good enough to knock the Ford off its perch.

While the new Grand C-MAX isn’t exactly attractive, the upmarket cabin and polished driving experience make it an enormously appealing choice. Neither of its competitors can match the feelgood factor you get simply from sitting behind the wheel – and that’s before you even drive it anywhere...
 
Find Used Cars

Find your Mazda 5 with our used car search.

Find Used Cars
- Advertisement -