Prices: (2002 to 2006)
Car-like handling and smart looks make the Toyota a judges’ favourite, but it can’t quite topple the more able Nissan. It still comes highly commended, though, and the second-generation model has never been cheaper. The 2.0 VVT petrol can hit 38mpg, too, so you may not have to stump up the £1,000 premium for the 46mpg D-4D oil-burner.