Volkswagen Tiguan 2.0 TDI

8 Feb, 2010 12:07pm Dan Strong

Final report: After 12 months on fleet, our compact SUV’s record makes for good reading

For: 
For a compact SUV, the Tiguan is an incredibly economical choice. It doesn’t shout about its green credentials, but fuel consumption of nearly 40mpg, and relatively low emissions for a 4x4, will make it a popular choice with private and company buyers alike.
Against: 
The engine’s propensity to stall when pulling away from a standstill takes awhile to get used to. It’s simply not what we’ve come to expect from torquey modern turbodiesel vehicles.

Even before I took the keys to our long-term Volkswagen Tiguan, I felt I knew it intimately.

The compact SUV has had a succession of road test appearances, as well as long-term reports carried out by its previous custodians, road tester Lesley Harris and art director Darren Wilson. So I was well versed in the little off-roader’s quirks and qualities. In fact, I’d done more reading about the Tiguan than driving.

The Volkswagen has just departed our fleet, but in recent weeks it has provided practical transport for the Strong family – and made light of this winter’s severe weather, with a daily commute of around 60 miles.

As Lesley had reported previously, the Tiguan is refined at cruising speed, and has a slick gearchange. I was also impressed by its return at the pumps. Despite its bluff nose and tall driving position, I easily recorded 43.2mpg on one run.

And, like Darren, I found the VW stalled very easily – especially when driving around town. Its heavy all-wheel-drive transmission and punchy 2.0-litre TDI engine are not a great combination. The diesel lacks the low-down urge needed to get the wheels turning, and you have to dial in quite a few revs to pull away from junctions smoothly.

Now, with more than 15,000 miles on the clock, that characteristic has taken its toll on the clutch, which, despite being self adjusting, feels pretty worn. In addition, the drivetrain shunts noisily when you take your foot off the throttle.

The rear door handles and the Tiguan’s security-focused central locking system also proved a real headache. To unlock the car completely, you need to press the remote key fob twice in quick succession. If you don’t, only the driver’s door unlocks.

This can be doubly frustrating if you are trying to load your children into the cabin – often leaving you tugging at the handle of a locked rear door.

It’s possible to reprogramme the central locking to open all the doors with a single press, but the factory set-up is incredibly irritating. I can’t help but feel it may have led to damage on the rear door handles, too. Now, when they’re open, they stay jammed in a raised position, meaning it’s difficult to shut the door. Treating them with a fine lubricant didn’t seem to resolve the problem, either.

Despite these negatives, there have been few other question marks over our car’s build quality, and in all other respects, the VW has sailed through its long-term test.

It still feels every bit as well screwed together as the day it arrived. If only everything in life was a reliable as a Volkswagen? Well, nearly…

Extra Info

I've been really impressed by the Tiguan. It rides smoothly over rough roads, and is surprisingly practical.

It’s also very compact – ideal for negotiating crowded city streets. The VW’s tall driving position means plotting a route through gridlocked traffic is a breeze.

The self-parking system is effective, and its group test victory against a pair of eco SUVs shows it can take on a variety of roles.

Ross Pinnock
Road test editor

Disqus - noscript

I would suggest that rather than suffering from lack of low down torque - this is after all a diesel, that it is too highly geared in first.

First gear on the Tiguan is actually very low - presumably to give it some low speed off road ability. I my opinion there is a serious problem with the low speed fuelling on this car, one which I am surprised VW haven't yet fixed with a software update.

Pressing the remote twice quickly in succession to open all the doors on a VW has been a good feature of VW for over ten years.
The method of opening the doors is explained in the users Manuel, and regular drivers quickly find that it is second nature, and no hardship.
I can imagine some numpties do not read the user Manuel first and then try heaving and pulling the rear doors, which obviously causes damage to the door mechanism.
If the writer of this article were conversant with VW cars, it would have quickly dawned that there was a good and simple reason why the other three doors would not open.
Although the writer is correct in stating that VW’s are not as well built as they once were, and the recycled plastics used in VW's are abysmal, and easily damaged, especially on the Touran.

Well, I have now done 46000 miles in my 2008 Tiguan 2.0Tdi SE, and other than a problem with a faulty engine management sensor it has been great. Very handy in town or on the lanes, good fuel economy (mid 40s) and good in the snow too. Niggles with pulling away in first - I still stall now and then - and small wing mirrors, but I'm still not tempted to swap for any of the opposition.

Key specs

  • On fleet since: February 2009
  • Price when new: £22,840
  • Mileage: 15,683/ 39.4mpg
  • Engine / Power: 2.0-litre/ 138bhp
  • Trade-in value now: £18,600
  • Insurance Group / Quote: 15/ £399
  • Costs: None
  • Any problems?: Sticking rear door handles
  • Equipment: Vienna leather trim (£1,345), convenience pack (£145), Park Assist system (£417), metallic paint (£366)
For more breaking car news and reviews, subscribe to Auto Express - available as a weekly magazine and on your iPad. We'll give you 6 issues for £1 and a free gift!

Sponsored Links