Car group tests

Honda Accord vs Alfa 159

13 May, 2011 2:51pm

Honda and Alfa Romeo have added new tax-busting diesels to their sporty family saloons. Which is better?

In previous years, this test would have pitted Honda VTEC power against Alfa Romeo’s Twin Spark for petrol glory – but how times change!

Both firms are famous for their charismatic engines, yet today’s legislation has made diesel the current fuel of choice. With the promise of lower emissions and impressive economy, it appeals to private and business buyers alike.

Video: watch CarBuyer's video review of the Honda Accord

The latter now account for half of new car sales, and any potential customer will want their executive oil-burner to have the lowest CO2 emissions possible to save tax.

Until now, the Honda Accord has suffered because of its high CO2 output, so the introduction of a cleaner 2.2-litre i-DTEC diesel is big news. Its arrival in July coincides with a mild facelift and some tweaks to the chassis, all designed to keep the Honda on the pace.

Meeting this challenge is the Alfa Romeo 159. Its 136bhp 2.0-litre JTDm replaces the old 1.9-litre unit, which didn’t meet the latest emissions regulations. Revised trim levels and more kit also boost the 159, but which saloon is the better option?

Verdict

The Honda Accord and Alfa Romeo 159 are both unusual choices that cost little more than top-of-the-range mainstream models – but which one should buyers turn to if they are on the lookout for something different?

Both are now sufficiently eco-friendly to find their way on to company car lists, but the beautiful Alfa Romeo remains the selfish pick. It is the more engaging driver’s car and has bags of charm.

Yet the latest changes can’t disguise its dated underpinnings or lack of cabin space.

The Honda is less charismatic, but ultimately more capable. In the end, the impressive build quality, characterful i-DTEC engine and surprising economy of the Accord win out in this test. The Japanese machine feels like a more polished product. The brand’s solid reputation and well regarded dealer network seal a thoroughly deserved victory.

Disqus - noscript

Submitted by lucasworld on Wed, 2011-05-18 02:56.

Honda is best in all ways!
1. Build Quality - miles better than the Alfa and more soft touches around the car, even though not the most exciting interior
2. Reliability & Running Costs - Honda's are miles better than Alfa's because they are built to last and running costs are minimal in the long run
3. Servicing - Quality of a Honda service is bettered by only Skoda and Lexus. Something that Alfa, to be frank, lacks prioritising their customers' first.

Submitted by clintrodge on Sun, 2011-05-22 15:23.

In Australia Accord IS mainstream and 159 commands a 25 percent premium. Unfortunately still for my local Honda dealer, an Alfa dealer is next door. Who would want to buy an Accord after sitting in a 159? Alfa is about style and driving excitement - Honda is more about arcade style excitement with 1,390,332 buttons on the steering wheel and multicoloured graphics. Comes down to do you want to drive a car or just play Gran Turismo on PS3...

Submitted by FloatingVoter on Wed, 2011-05-25 22:38.

Yep, got your attention.

Ask yourself the question, if the Accord and 159 were women, which one would you want to have sex with?

Then ask yourself, which one would you want to marry?

Hmmm.

Submitted by driver_skp1 on Tue, 2011-06-14 22:52.

Those MPG figures are diabolical if these are meant to be modern cars that are bought for economy reasons.

My 1993 2.2 litre petrol Mercedes can match those figures in the real world and only marginally worse with a heavy right foot.

For an alternative review of the latest Honda Accord Saloon visit our sister site carbuyer.co.uk

Next: 1st Honda Accord 2.2 i-DTEC ES GT