Car hunter: Interesting first cars

11 Oct, 2012 11:00am Chris Ebbs

Our reader has £3,000 to spend on a distinctive first car

Dear Chris,
After passing my driving test, I’m now shopping for my first car. I have £3,000 to spend, but want something a little different. Can you help?
Debbie Marks, E-mail 

If you'd like help choosing your next car, contact chris_ebbs@dennis.co.uk.

The best buys:

Great warranty: Kia Pro_cee'd

Kia pro_cee'd front cornering

For: Sleek styling, remains of warranty
Against: Few examples, rear access

The Pro_cee’d is the sleeker three-door version of the five-door Kia Cee’d, and the lack of rear doors isn’t the only difference.

The Pro_cee’d sits lower than the five-door, giving it a sportier feel. This does mean the suspension can seem a little firm, however, so it’s not the most comfortable option to choose.

As it’s a Kia, you get the balance of a seven-year 100,000-mile warranty, along with excellent build quality, which should help give peace of mind for a first car.

The Pro_cee’d was only launched in 2008, and can be hard to come by at this budget, although prices are set to fall as an all-new car starred at the Paris Motor Show. We found a 90,000-mile 2008 1.6-litre diesel for £3,050.

Running costs are also reasonable, with a low group 17 insurance rating, which will be important for a first car.

Best equipment: SEAT Ibiza

SEAT Ibiza front tracking

For: Low price, lots of choice, cheap
Against: Awkward styling, reliability

Its more popular Volkswagen Polo cousin may get all the attention, but the Ibiza is certainly worthy of consideration as a first car. It’s less desirable than the VW, so prices are lower for newer examples, and there are plenty to choose from.

For your budget, you can even opt for one of the higher-spec Sport models – we found a 1.4-litre petrol three-door on an 06-plate for £2,995. Just be wary, as the Ibiza doesn’t share the same strong reliability as the VW – it placed a rather poor 86th in the 2008 Auto Express Driver Power owner survey.

Watch out for lower-spec models, as these can be stingy on spec, particularly compared to the Kia. The looks aren’t quite up to those of the Pro_cee’d, either, with rather dumpy styling, especially at the front end.

The stylish choice: Fiat Grande Punto

Fiat Grande Punto front tracking

For: Residuals, fuel-efficient diesels
Against: Poor quality, performance

Fiat is often overlooked by those in the market for a first car, in favour of the likes of the Ford Fiesta and Vauxhall Corsa. This is a shame, because the Grande Punto is a good-looking and affordable option for those who have just passed their test.

The engine range is a little disappointing, and the petrol cars in particular are short on power. All models, including diesels, have a poor gearshift and don’t feel overly engaging on the open road, either.

Still, there’s a good choice of three or five-door versions to pick from. We found a 1.9-litre Multijet diesel Sporting with 94,500 miles on an 07-plate for bang on £3,000.

Running costs are comparable with the SEAT and Kia, but interior quality lets it down, and isn’t up to the standard of the other two models here.

Disqus - noscript

Has to be the Pro_cee'd, then, no? The other two both seem to have significant drawbacks. What about a Mazda2?

High spec and diesels are usually good to go for when advising most car buyers, but why not something with low insurance, which seems to be the biggest obstacle to most first time drivers?

£3k is a good lot to spend on a first car, but some insurance quotes might match that!!

Citroen C1, Fiat Panda, Vauxhall Corsa and VW Fox can all be had for insurance group 1, while group 2 brings in the last C3, previous Fabia, Aygo and Yaris.

One problem with this article. Where on earth can you get a Pro Ceed for £3k?!!! They start at £4300 on Autotrader and most are £5k plus.

£750 on a 99 Honda Accord coupe, the £2250 can go towards the insurance

Distinctive? None of these are. Perhaps it is impossible to get "distinctive" for £3,000.

Smart Forfour? It's certainly distinctive

What coincidence! I have exactly the same car! One of the hidden gems in bangernomics. It cost me twice that to buy but the insurance is 10% of your quote!

How about a Skoda Fabia 1.2? Great reliability and proven quality. I have had a few now and they are great fun to drive, as well as being cheap to insure.

low insurance group cars doesnt mean they are cheap to insure. a 1.2 corsa is dearer to insure than my fabia vrs and i got that nearly 2 years ago when i was 18

Issue 1346
For more breaking car news and reviews, subscribe to Auto Express - available as a weekly magazine and on your iPad. We'll give you 6 issues for £1 and a free gift!

Sponsored Links