Audi A3 review

Our Rating: 
4
4.0/5.0
2016 model
By Auto Express Test TeamComments

Audi’s premium family hatch offers strong efficiency, a decent drive and interior that's a class above the BMW 1 Series

For: 
Fantastic interior quality, range of efficient engines, comfortable ride
Against: 
Expensive, VW Golf more practical, not as fun to drive as a BMW 1 Series

Sponsored Links

Audi's A3 practically invented the premium hatch segment 20 years ago, but now it's been joined by a host of rivals from BMW, Mercedes and Volvo. Thankfully for Audi, the latest generation is still one of the best of the breed, and the 2016 facelift only adds to that.

The Audi A3 sits above the A1 supermini in the firm's extensive range, and remains a shining sales success. With a classy (if understated) exterior, a well crafted interior and the latest safety and efficiency technology, the A3 is the car to beat in its class.

Maintaining a premium look and feel inside and out has never been an issue for the A3. The latest model has the best interior in the segment, with superb fit and finish and an attractive design that not even Mercedes can match with the A-Class. 

The A3 is based on the advanced MQB platform used widely within the VW Group, but Audi has tuned the chassis specifically to deliver a sportier feel than any other hatchback in the family. However, it still can’t match the level of driving engagement and composure offered by the best cars in the class – namely the sharp and involving BMW 1 Series.

Even so, the engine range is strong and extensive – and increasingly fuel-efficient. With so much choice on offer, there should be an Audi A3 to suit anyone’s needs.

Our Choice: 
Audi A3 Sport 1.6 TDI

The Audi A3 offers some of the most comprehensive range variety of any car on sale. It's available with a wide variety of engines, plenty of trim levels, and most importantly four bodystyles - the three-door hatch, a five-door Sportback, four-door Saloon and a Cabriolet. There are also two performance models: the powerful S3 is available in all four guises, but the ultimate evolution of the A3 is the 362bhp RS3, which comes as a Sportback only.

Trim levels will be familiar from other Audi line-ups, but they are not universal across all A3 bodystyles. The hatch and Sportback specifications are SE, Sport and S line. The S3 and RS3 come with their own, high-end specifications to match their performance, although sat-nav remains an expensive optional extra on both.

Engine options are varied. In the regular A3 range there are both petrols and diesels, split into a variety of outputs. The 1.0-litre TFSI is the entry-level choice, or there’s a 1.4 TFSI with 148bhp or a new 2.0-litre petrol with 187bhp. The S3s use a high-performance derivative of the four-cylinder unit found in many Volkswagen Group performance cars, including the Volkswagen Golf GTI and Golf R, SEAT Leon Cupra and Skoda Octavia vRS. Meanwhile, the RS3 uses a 2.5-litre five-cylinder turbo in honour of Audi’s rally heritage, making it one of the quickest hot hatches in the world.

All A3s get the option of a 1.6-litre TDI diesel engine, delivering 108bhp, which can also be specced with all-wheel drive on the A3 Sportback and Saloon. The 2.0 TDI makes either 148bhp or 181bhp and is available across the range.

A six-speed manual gearbox is standard on almost all engines, with an S tronic dual-clutch automatic available as an option. The auto is a seven-speed set-up on the 1.0 TFSI, 1.4 TFSI, 2.0 TFSI and 1.6 TDI, and on the RS3 – where it’s the only gearbox available – while the six-speed S tronic is offered on the 2.0 TDI and S3. The six-speed auto is the only option on the S3 Cabriolet.

Most A3s are front-wheel drive, but Audi's trademark quattro part-time four-wheel drive system can be specified on some Sport models upwards, usually linked to an S tronic gearbox. The odd A3s out here are the 1.6 TDI quattro and the 148bhp 2.0 TDI quattro - both manuals. 

Audi also offers an impressive A3 e-tron plug-in hybrid. This is available in the Sportback bodystyle only, uses a 1.4 TFSI engine supplemented by an electric motor and has a one-off specification that closely resembles an A3 Sport. The e-tron is designed to challenge the BMW i3 electric car (which is available with a range-extending petrol engine), but doesn't feel quite as revolutionary – although the Audi is more conventional and easier to live with.

The A3 fits into the Audi line-up above the A1 and below the A4, with its natural rivals being the BMW 1 Series, Mercedes A-Class, Volvo V40 and Lexus CT. However, it’s worth considering any other VW Group product built on the MQB platform, such as the Volkswagen Golf, Skoda Octavia and SEAT Leon, as most will be cheaper than the premium A3 spec-for-spec.

Audi has been building the A3 since 1996 and this is the third-generation model, introduced in 2012 and facelifted in 2016. There have always been three and five-door versions, but this is the first generation with a saloon.

Engines, performance and drive

4
Lots of choice on offer for the pragmatic buyer, but there are also some serious performance versions of the A3.

This latest A3 bucks the Audi trend of using hard suspension to improve the handling – which ultimately compromised ride comfort in the previous generation, as well as other models from the company. The suspension on the current A3 is a vast improvement over the old car's, with only a dab of firmness present. Yet even though the car is generally good to drive, the handling is still somewhat uninvolving compared 

This is particularly true on the RS3. Although it serves up ballistic pace and secure quattro four-wheel-drive grip, it’s ultimately found wanting in the fun department. The S3 is better, possibly because your expectations are set lower to begin with, but it can do 90 per cent of what the RS3 can do for significantly less cash. We'd still opt for a VW Golf R, however. 

All versions of the Audi A3 get a standard suspension setting, but on Sport and S line models buyers can opt for sportier, stiffer suspension at no extra cost. Just beware that with this set-up, the ride is significantly firmer, and road noise is increased enough to make it quite a bit less refined. We'd avoid it unless cornering is an absolute priority.

In terms of engine, we’d choose either the 1.6-litre TDI diesel or 1.0-litre TFSI petrol for a good mix of economy, cost and performance. Go for the 2.0-litre petrol if you need speed at the expense of economy, or the 2.0-litre TDI for great power and efficiency but an extra price premium.

Engines

All engines in the Audi A3 range are four-cylinder turbocharged units, with the exception of the superb 2.5-litre five-cylinder engine in the RS3. The 1.0-litre TFSI makes 113bhp 200Nm of torque, while the 1.4 delivers 148bhp and the 2.0-litre petrol gets 187bhp.

The diesels make more financial sense, though, and while the 2.0 TDI has the best power and torque figures, plus reasonable refinement, it’s not as frugal as the 1.6-litre TDI. This makes 108bhp at 3,200-4,000rpm and 250Nm of torque from 1,500-3,000rpm. The 2.0 delivers its power and torque figures across 3,500-4,000rpm and 1,750-3,000rpm respectively, although on the more powerful engine the peak torque hangs on to 3,250rpm. The headline stats are 148bhp and 340Nm, or 181bhp and 380Nm.

The 2.0-litre TFSI engine in the S3 has figures to match the Volkswagen Golf R, with 306bhp and 400Nm of torque. But the RS3’s 2.5-litre five-cylinder leaves even that in the shade. It serves up 362bhp from 5,550-6,800rpm and a huge 465Nm from 1,625-5,550rpm. While the S3’s four-cylinder sounds good, the RS3 has the edge for aural appeal thanks to trick exhausts and that fabled five-cylinder warble.

Performance is strong across the range, with only a handful of models, mainly 1.6 TDIs, unable to complete the 0-62mph sprint in less than 10 seconds. Plus, all A3s are capable of at least 120mph. With the twin-clutch automatic gearbox, the S3 hatchback can do 0-62mph in under 5 seconds, which isn’t far off the bombastic RS3’s time of 4.3 seconds.

MPG, CO2 and running costs

4
Audi offers plug-in hybrid A3s to keep costs down, but watch out for expensive insurance on some models

An A3 diesel is the most sensible choice if efficiency is your main priority. The 148bhp 2.0-litre TDI claims 68.9mpg fuel economy and CO2 emissions of only 108g/km. The 181bhp version isn’t far behind, with 67.3mpg and 112g/km.

Petrol engines are usually a lot less frugal, but the 1.0-litre unit is nearly as economical as the lower-powered diesel and is nicer to drive, too. Plus, the clever 148bhp 1.4 TFSI petrol with cylinder deactivation can return 60.1mpg and emit only 109g/km of CO2.

Of course, the real eco-champion (in terms of official numbers in any case) is the A3 e-tron. Its petrol-electric hybrid drivetrain returns 176.6mpg and emits 37g/km when the car is running on 17-inch wheels; specify 18-inch rims, and it claims 166.2mpg and 39g/km. The e-tron has a fully electric range of 31 miles at a limited top speed of 81mph, takes a minimum of two-and-a-quarter hours to recharge and can go 550 miles on petrol power alone. However, at £35,340, it’s not cheap, and even with the Government’s £5,000 plug-in car grant helping out, buyers will still pay in excess of £30,000.

Our real-world choice, therefore, is the 1.6 TDI, which claims 70.6mpg and 105g/km. It's less refined than the 1.0-litre petrol, but for many the economy figures alone will be enough to make the difference.

Insurance groups

An equivalent BMW 1 Series or VW Golf will be cheaper to insure, as the Audi A3 falls into at least insurance group 16. Surprisingly, though, the RS3 doesn’t sit in the highest insurance group in the A3 range; that dubious honour goes to the S3 Cabriolet (group 42). The RS3 sits in insurance group 40.

Whether you go for one of the performance models or a lower-spec diesel, Audi offers a wealth of electronic safety assist systems and quattro all-wheel drive on the A3, much of which will help lower insurance premiums.

Depreciation

The Audi A3 is quite a bit more expensive to buy than a Ford Focus or Volkswagen Golf, but decent standard equipment, the brand’s perceived quality and strong residual values help to counter the higher initial outlay.

Interior, design and technology

4
The exterior design of the A3 is stylish, if conservative, while the interior is class-leading in terms of quality

The A3 carries some familiar Audi trademarks, with the style of the lights and the large grille found on everything from the A1 to the A8. However, it’s an attractive design with a quality look, but it's more conservative than the likes of the Mercedes A-Class and Volvo V40.

For us, the most visually appealing model in the range is the Saloon model, which has the sharpest looks of any A3 and is one of the neatest three-box designs in the entire Audi range. The second-generation Cabriolet is based on the Saloon’s underpinnings, which ensures it appears a classier soft-top than its dumpy looking predecessor.

A3 SE and Sport models look fairly restrained on the outside, but range-topping A3 S line models stand out more with their 18-inch alloys and sporty bodykit. The S3 is set apart by its quad exhausts, plus silver detailing and badging, while the RS3 has flared wheelarches, two big oval tailpipes and its own logos.

The RS3 is available in a choice of eight colours – six are shared with the S3, while Nardo Grey (standard) and Catalunya Red metallic are exclusive to the performance flagship.

Audi exclusive allows buyers to choose from any of the firm’s paints or 100 exclusive shades, while the customised option lets you pick whatever colour you want.

What the A3 lacks in exterior excitement it makes up for on the inside, with a stylish and simple dashboard design and impressively high-quality materials throughout.

Entry-level SE-spec cars get 16-inch alloy wheels, stop/start, air-conditioning and Bluetooth as standard, with the higher trims adding significant luxury equipment from there.

Sat-nav, stereo and infotainment

Every A3 gets a slick, 5.8-inch infotainment screen that pops out from the top of the dash. This is controlled by a rotary wheel on the centre console – which is an excellent feature to find on entry level models.

There is a tech pack that you can add, however, that includes Audi's virtual cockpit system - it's a brilliant upgrade that lets you display anything from the screen in front of you, in between the digital dials. It's easy to use, looks great and makes it safer to glance at the sat-nav, too.

Practicality, comfort and boot space

4
The A3 is a useable choice, with more space inside than the previous car and a decent boot on all models

The latest Audi A3 hatchback is the same length as the previous-generation car. However, thanks to a stretched wheelbase, the interior is more accommodating for passengers than before. The wider track in the new model also gives occupants more elbow room.

One downside is that the rear can be a bit cramped for taller adults, but getting in and out of the three-door shouldn’t be much trouble, thanks to the long doors.

Because of its improved dimensions, the Audi A3 gets more room in the boot than before. Space is now extended to 365 litres with the rear seats in place, and this grows to 1,100 litres when they’re folded. This compares with the BMW 1 Series, which offers 360 litres and 1,200 litres, and the Volkswagen Golf, which serves up 380 litres and 1,270 litres.

Size

Although broadly similar in most dimensions, the Sportback is more than just a three-door A3 with two extra doors grafted in at the back. While the cars have the same front-end styling, the Sportback gets its own rear light clusters and is longer than the three-door A3, at 4,310mm compared to 4,237mm. It also has a longer wheelbase and is slightly higher.

The Saloon is longer again, at 4,456mm, but its wheelbase is the same as the Sportback’s, while the Cabriolet is marginally shorter than the four-door it is based on, at 4,421mm.

Leg room, head room & passenger space

Front head room is a metre and more in all models, rising from 1,000mm in the Cabriolet to 1,021mm in the Sportback. However, the Saloon and Cabriolet have more limited rear head room, at slightly more than 920mm each instead of 950mm-plus in the hatchback and Sportback models.

Elbow room is at its widest in the front of the Cabriolet, with 1,468mm on offer, but this version’s cabin is by far the narrowest in the rear of all four models – its 1,203mm is a long way behind the next smallest version, the three-door A3, which provides 1,411mm. This means the A3 Cabriolet is a strict four-seater, where the other A3s should be able to take five average-sized adults.

Boot

Bizarrely, the A3 Saloon has the biggest boot of all models in the Audi A3 range with the rear seats up, at 425 litres. The Sportback manages 380 litres, the hatch 365 litres and the Cabriolet 320 litres, although the hatch and Sportback have the largest cargo area with the rear bench folded down, at 1,100 and 1,220 litres respectively. The Saloon manages 880 litres and the Cabriolet 678 litres on this score.

As a side note, specifying quattro all-wheel drive eats into boot space, by around 35 litres on the Saloon/Cabriolet and 40 litres on the hatch/Sportback. The RS3 and e-tron models have the smallest ‘regular’ boots of all, losing 100 litres over other Sportbacks – the RS3 due to the sporty chassis and exhaust back box, and the e-tron thanks to its lithium-ion battery pack. Both cars record 280 litres with the seats up and 1,120 litres when the seats are down.

Reliability and Safety

4.3
A3 has a five-star Euro NCAP rating, a wide range of electronic safety systems and competitive warranty offers.

The A3 is an impressively safe car, having scored the maximum five stars in Euro NCAP’s crash tests. Of particular note is its result of 95 per cent in the adult occupant protection category.

Audi has stocked the A3 with impressive levels of big-car safety kit, too. These include optional radar-controlled cruise control that maintains a set distance to the car in front, lane-keep assist, hill-hold assist and a pre-sense system to prepare the car in the event of an accident. Another optional safety feature is a self-park system that will help you get into a tight parking space.

The A3 also put in a decent performance in the Auto Express Driver Power 2016 survey, coming 47th out of 150 cars, with a high score for build quality in particular.

Warranty

Audi’s standard warranty is three years and 60,000 miles, which is unlimited mileage for years one and two, with the 60,000-mile cap coming into effect in the third year. For either £245 or £545, that can be extended to four years and 75,000 miles (years three and four mileage limited) or five years and 90,000 miles (years three to five are mileage limited).

The battery on the e-tron model is covered by a separate, eight-year/100,000-mile warranty, but Audi says that a reduction in battery power capacity of between 10 and 30 per cent in the warranty period is normal degradation and thus not a claimable item.

Servicing

The service schedule ranges from 9,000 miles for minor checks to 19,000 miles for a full service. Audi offers a range of fixed-price deals, including Audi Complete, so maintenance shouldn’t prove too costly.

Whether your car qualifies for a fixed or flexible schedule of servicing depends on your annual mileage, with Audi stating that any car that covers more than 10,000 miles per year should have flexible maintenance patterns.

Bear in mind that the A3 e-tron plug-in hybrid can only be sold from and maintained by a network of just 34 Audi specialist centres in the country, so it is not available from every dealership.

Last updated: 2 Jun, 2016