BMW 1 Series review

Our Rating:
5
5.0/5.0
By Auto Express Test TeamComments

The BMW 1 Series is fun to drive, with a quality interior and efficient engines to rival the VW Golf

For: 
Good to drive, economical engines, quality interior
Against: 
High price, not as spacious as a Golf, awkward styling

Sponsored Links

The entry point to the BMW range is the 1 Series hatchback - and the latest version is packed with more gadgetry than ever, including new engines, lots of 'big car' equipment, and greater scope for personalisation. The Volkswagen Golf and Audi A3 rival is still only available with rear-wheel drive and is just as fun to drive, but the introduction of a new 100bhp 114i engine makes the cost of BMW ownership more affordable than ever before. There’s a great range of fast and efficient petrol and diesel engines, while a flagship M135i offers supercar-rivalling performance.

Our choice: 118d Sport

Styling

3.8

Love it or hate it, the BMW 1 Series has always stood out – and the latest model is no less controversial. The edgy ‘flame surfacing’ design language has been replaced by a smoother look, which has been influenced by the latest 5 Series and 6 Series. However, the front features prominent kidney grilles and large headlights. The wider stance and flared wheelarches make it seem lower and sportier, too, and in terms of dimensions it's longer and narower than a VW Golf. The last 1 Series cut corners on the inside – not so the new one. The interior certainly ticks the quality box. All the controls are chunky, the dashboard is trimmed in soft-touch plastics and there’s a generous amount of leather and metal finishes. The driving position is really good, too, with plenty of adjustment and decent visibility. All versions come fitted with climate control, alloy wheels and a leather-trimmed steering wheel as standard, and DAB digital radio will become standard this year.

Driving

4.8

The 1 Series has always had a great range of petrol and diesel engines, and this hasn't changed with the latest model. Buyers can choose from a 1.6-litre petrol turbo with 136bhp in the 116i or 170bhp in the 118i. The three-door model is available with 100bhp 114i, which costs less than a 116i but takes 11.2 seconds to reach 0-60mph. At the top of the range sits the bonkers M135i, which offers supercar rivalling performance and a 0-60mph time of just 4.9 seconds. As for diesels, there's a 2.0-litre 116d, 118d and 120d, while the 116d EfficientDynamics gets a 1.6-litre diesel. Thanks to wider front and rear tracks and the new Drive Performance Control button, it doesn't matter which engine you go for - all 1 Series models corner without much body roll and show impressive rear-drive agility, while the ride is more comfortable than the equivalent Audi A3 and Mercedes A-Class.

Reliability

4.4

The new car features a wide variety of new engines but BMW has a solid and well earned history of building very reliable mechanical parts both inside and out. This generation of 1 Series also feels like a big step up in interior quality so it should wear better over time as well. The 1 Series gets a very impressive five star crash test rating from Euro NCAP and only the Volvo V40 scores higher for adult protection. BMW uses a five stage traction control system called 'DSC' which is progressive but ensures you keep on the straight and narrow when the road conditions get too slippery for the rear-driven chassis. Making its first appearance in the Driver Power Survey, it placed 54, with a rating of 86.14 per cent. Not bad for a first appearnce, but there's room for improvement. 

Practicality

4

The new car has been lengthened by 85mm, with 30mm added to the wheelbase. But despite its bigger dimensions, the interior of the 1 Series is still a bit cramped in the rear compared to the VW Golf. It is more spacious than before, though, and the boot capacity has been increased by 30 litres to a total of 360 litres, which increases to 1,200 litres with the rear seats folded. This slightly less than the Mk7 VW Golf (which manages 380 and 1,270 litres respectively) but considerably more than the new Audi A3, which offers 365 litres with the seats up and only 1,100 litres with them folded. The boot is a very handy shape and there's no shortage of cubbies around the cabin, either.

Running Costs

4.6

With new engines, a 30kg lighter body and stop-start fitted as standard, as well as other EfficientDynamics tweaks, the new 1 Series is very economical. The 118i engine is capable of returning around 48mpg and emitting 137g/km of CO2, which is very impressive given its performance. The most economical diesel is the 116d EfficientDynamics, which returns 74.3mpg and emits a tax-busting 99g/km. This version falls into insurance group 15, which will mean premiums will be more expensive than for the equivalent Mk7 Golf. All 1 Series models get ECO PRO mode, which encourages more economical driving by reducing throttle response and the amount of load taken from the engine by equipment such as air-con.  Although the price of buying a 1 Series is higher than many of its alternatives, it should hold its value well. If you’re worried about service costs, BMW offers a range of really cost-effective pre-paid servicing deals, while models range from insurance group 12 to 39.

Disqus - noscript

I was naturally wary about the ed milage claims, but sure enough its showing 74mpg average, and hit the claimed 84mpg on a run.

There's no attribute this vehicle could possibly have that could compensate for it's "give me a bucket, I'm going to be sick" pig ugly looks. Surely it is one of the most ugly pieces of machinery ever to have been created by man. Was the designer having a joke? In any case, either a Golf or an A3 would be a far better choice.

This car seems to get uglier after every facelift.
Great car for the Bride of Wildenstein.

probably looks like you steve

The truth hurts doesn't it. Best thing is just to sell it, if you can!! ..."civic", AKA "1 series"! LOL!!

Looks of a car are subjective, those who are taking the mick probably could not afford one anyway!
Each to their own! For the record I do not own a 1 Series either... But they are good cars!

No way are these expensive cars - they start at £17k (although they are over priced - it's competitors...a Focus or a Seat are much better buys for a couple of grand less)... the 1 series is a family hatch, and a poor one at that. A quick look down the for sale ads will show you that they are very easily affordable... many go very cheap and if you want a new one they are not particularly expensive either (and that's before the massive discount that comes with most BMs). Most BMs on the road aren't worth very much, although the owners like to pretend that they are. Unfortunately they're just snobs - no more, no less. I'd totally agree with the comments on the looks, it has a face that only a mother could love.

the irony of a bmw hater with the name "petrolhead"... ugly or not - It's the best to drive in its class - and thats all that should matter as a 'petrol head'

best to drive in its class... nuff said

Last updated: 19 Dec, 2012
Auto Express Issue 1,273
For more breaking car news and reviews, subscribe to Auto Express - available as a weekly magazine and on your iPad. We'll give you 6 issues for £1 and a free gift!

Sponsored Links