Men vs women: who are the best drivers?

Battle of the sexes
13 Apr, 2014 8:00am Kevin Hughes

It's men vs women behind the wheel, as we crunch the numbers to find out who are the best drivers in the battle of the sexes

It’s an argument that has raged for years and, with the number of female drivers on the rise, is destined to continue for many, many more.

In the US, the number of women motorists outstripped males for the first time in 2010, and the UK is expected to follow the same trend in the future. So, are female drivers better than males? Perhaps it’s time to stop asking the question – it’s getting too close to call.

Women drivers are increasing in number

An in-depth report by the RAC Foundation showed women drivers are increasing in number, and at a faster rate than men. Between 1995 and 2010, the number of women with a full driving licence grew by 23 per cent – up 2.6m to 13.8m. In the same 15-year period, the number of men holding licences increased by 1.4m, or just nine per cent, to 16.3m.

Parking errors

Last May, a Freedom of Information request suggested twice as many reverse parking errors were made by female motorists on driving tests, in comparison to their male counterparts – 3,367 mistakes against 1,652.

Practical driving test pass rates

Research from insurance comparison website Confused.com – based on data from the Driving Standards Agency on practical driving test pass rates from 2011 to 2013 – revealed nearly half of male motorists (48 per cent) passed their test first time, with 44 per cent of female drivers passing at the first attempt. The same research also found women take an average of eight months to pass their practical driving test – two months more than men, who qualified after six.

History of the driving test

Women have fewer crashes

Challenging the notion that men are kings of the road, dealer giant the Jennings Motor Group compiled data from various sources to suggest that the fairer sex is more skilled at the wheel.

It found that 57 per cent of male drivers have been involved in a crash, compared to 44 per cent of women; 46 per cent of men had what was described as a ‘close call’ with a cyclist or pedestrian, compared to 35 per cent of women; and 68 per cent of UK women have a clean driving licence, against 64 per cent of men.

UK's worst drivers named and shamed

More statistics show men in a poorer light when it comes to losing concentration behind the wheel by adjusting their stereo or using their mobile phone, or speeding and verbally abusing other drivers, plus their involvement in traffic collisions or crashes with animals.

Higher fees for driving lessons

Last year, a Spanish judge sparked controversy when he ruled that a driving school in Zaragoza had been entitled, in 2011, to charge women drivers more for lessons than men.

Male drivers were billed 665 Euros for unlimited lessons until they passed, while for females it was 850 Euros.

Gamers likely to pass test first time, and then crash

The school was initially fined for discrimination, but Judge Javier Albar overturned the ruling, citing information from Spain’s Directorate of Traffic that he believed proved men displayed better open road skills than women.

Women in motorsport

In the world of motorsport, the balance of men and women is becoming more even than ever.

Danica Patrick has led the way in the US IndyCar and NASCAR series. She became only the fourth woman ever to race in the Indy 500 in 2005, and even led for 19 laps before finishing fourth. This was a record for a female driver, but she broke it by coming third in 2009. “I was brought up to be the fastest driver, not the fastest girl,” she once said, and Patrick now races for JR Motorsports in NASCAR.

Over in F1, a woman will hit the track during a grand prix weekend for the first time in 22 years this summer. Scot Susie Wolff, 31, will drive for Williams in two free practice sessions at the British and German GPs.

Wolff won’t displace regular drivers Felipe Massa and Valtteri Bottas, but has an active role as team development driver. Her sights are set on one day making the starting grid.

Elsewhere in F1, Sauber has signed former IndyCar star Simona de Silvestro, 25, as an affiliated driver with a view to her competing on track – possibly as early as next year.

Women less likely to speed than men

Insurance company Wunelli studied data from black box recorders in the vehicles of 19,000 motorists, and found women drivers were 12 per cent less likely to exceed speed limits than men, and 11 per cent less likely to brake hard – which marked them out as smoother and more safety conscious.

Police stop over 5,000 drivers for lane hogging and tailgating

Disqus - noscript

When talking about the number of accidents involving men compared to those involving women, you need to adjust the numbers so that it actually counts the number of accidents per mile driven. Otherwise, if you have one set spending twice as much time on the road compared to the other set then the figures are skewed.

However, I haven't read the article, it's another frivolous waste of time. Insurance companies say women (who do less miles - see above).

The best drivers are the ones that maintain the maximum margin between themselves and danger without inconveniencing other road users. On that basis the males are handicapped by younger drivers and those that think being a good driver is getting in front of other drivers. Car control skills are well down the list of assets you need to be a good road driver. Self control is far more important.

Every one knows that Men are by far better drivers, it is a fact.

Don't you mean "Who are the better drivers"?

I think you also need to take in the fact that the average man spends more time driving, thus more likely to have an accident or incident

AEX 1337
For more breaking car news and reviews, subscribe to Auto Express - available as a weekly magazine and on your iPad. We'll give you 6 issues for £1 and a free gift!

Sponsored Links