Skip advert
Advertisement

Watchdog: Clutch failure after four months

What good is Hyundai’s five-year warranty if owners have to pay for a replacement clutch after just 3,500 miles?

Hyundai i20 clutch failure

New car warranties don’t cover wear and tear components. Parts such as wiper blades, brake pads and tyres are classed as consumables and the owner has to pay when they need replacing. But what is ‘fair’ wear and tear?

Cathy Brown, from Helston, Cornwall, certainly didn’t think it was fair that Hyundai wouldn’t cover a fix on her i20 under warranty. The replacement part wasn’t anything so minor as wiper blades – it was the clutch. And the car was only four months old, with 3,500 miles on the clock.

Advertisement - Article continues below

“I’ve driven for over 40 years and never had clutch problems before,” Cathy said. “The one on my previous car lasted 11 years!”

A clutch is a wear and tear item – and it would be unfair to expect companies to replace them when they wear out on older vehicles.

But surely no company would consider it ‘fair’ for a customer to foot the bill for a replacement clutch on a four-month-old vehicle? Hyundai did. Its customer service centre manager wrote to Cathy saying that it agreed with the result of an investigation carried out by her dealer.

“There was no evidence to suggest any manufacturing defect,” wrote the customer service manager. “The cause of the concern with the clutch was down to wear and therefore is not covered under the terms of the warranty.” The manager added insult to injury by suggesting that the clutch failure may have been down to Cathy’s driving style.

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement - Article continues below

Funnily enough, the technician who carried out an independent inspection on Cathy’s car came to a different conclusion. He said it looked like the i20 had done 100,000 miles, not 3,500. “With no disrespect,” he added, “even a bad driver would not have worn a clutch to this extent in that short time.” He concluded by saying the clutch was not of sufficient quality for the vehicle.

We confronted Hyundai with these findings, and asked it to reconsider Cathy’s warranty claim. It agreed to send its own engineer to inspect the part. “Once we’ve received the findings of this report, we will come to a final conclusion,” a spokesman said.

Cathy's case: At a glance

The problemA clutch can last the lifetime of the car, but the one on Cathy Brown’s Hyundai i20 went after only four months. She was reluctant to pay for another.

Hyundai's responseHyundai refused to replace the clutch under warranty. It said it is “fair wear and tear”, and suggested the problem could be down to her driving style.

Legal adviceYou’re within your rights to get a second opinion. Ensure the dealer keeps all the parts it has removed, then have a qualified vehicle inspector examine them to see if they agree with the initial verdict.

Our verdictA worn-out clutch on a four-month-old car should have set alarm bells ringing at Hyundai. And it should not have taken our intervention to finally get the company to agree to inspect it.

Do you have a motoring problem that needs investigating? We're here to help… E-mail mail@autoexpress.co.uk or Tweet us @AutoExpress.

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement

Recommended

New Hyundai i20 facelift 2023 review: subtle updates for an already stylish supermini
Hyundai i20 - front tracking
Road tests

New Hyundai i20 facelift 2023 review: subtle updates for an already stylish supermini

Hyundai has given the i20 a series of mid-life updates, but you might struggle to notice some of them
5 Dec 2023

Most Popular

“MG is easily outselling Jaguar, Land Rover and Bentley combined”
Opinion - MG4
Opinion

“MG is easily outselling Jaguar, Land Rover and Bentley combined”

The wave of Chinese cars has arrived in the UK, and Mike Rutherford thinks it’s not about to stop any time soon
17 Mar 2024
Car Deal of the Day: breathtaking Lotus Emira V6 for £45k and an I.O.U.
Lotus Emira - driving
News

Car Deal of the Day: breathtaking Lotus Emira V6 for £45k and an I.O.U.

Our Deal of the Day for 15 March is a half-now, half-later plan for the last-ever petrol-powered Lotus sports car
15 Mar 2024
New Audi A5 Sportback and Avant: prices, specs and info on sleek new compact execs
New Audi A5 Avant - exclusive image
News

New Audi A5 Sportback and Avant: prices, specs and info on sleek new compact execs

The new ICE and hybrid Audi A5 is due by year’s end in hatchback and estate forms
15 Mar 2024