Mercedes G-Class vs Twisted Defender

11 Feb, 2013 10:30am

The Mercedes G-Class goes head-to-head with the Land Rover Defender

The Mercedes G-Class, or G-Wagen as it was called until 1994, isn’t a normal Merc. Its name is short for Gelandewagen (cross-country vehicle) and it was launched in 1979 with the sole aim of delivering rugged off-road ability.

Yet despite its boxy shape and body-on-frame construction, it has inexplicably morphed into a luxury vehicle. Today, you’re as likely to see a G-Class outside a casino in Monaco as you are parked in an African army camp.

However, it’s not the only workhorse loved across the globe. The Land Rover Defender is a master in its field, and Yorkshire-based Twisted builds bespoke luxury versions that give the Mercedes a run for its money. We put the two cars head-to-head on a snowy cross-country trek.

Verdict

Compared to modern 4x4s, both of the cars in this test are hopelessly outdated. But they have to be judged in context: what are considered flaws by the majority are revered as interesting character traits by fans of cars like the G-Class and Defender.

We still wear wind-up watches, sit in front of open fires and use fountain pens in the knowledge that they’ve been surpassed by superior technology, but that doesn’t make them pointless. It’s the same with the G-Class and Defender – but if you want to be different, surely it’s better to go the whole way?

The Mercedes is brought into line with the rest of the brand’s range by its modern interior, engine and gearbox, but it’s cramped inside and the on-road dynamics are poor. Meanwhile, the Land Rover’s handling is still agricultural by modern standards, but Twisted has heavily re-engineered it under the skin. And the luxury interior means you’re getting a pretty special one-off vehicle for your money.

Our test model was powered by the standard 2.2-litre four-cylinder engine, but you can get closer to the G350’s performance by upgrading to a 3.2-litre five-cylinder. However, that’s only the start of the tailor-made options on offer, and it’s this level of personalisation that gives the distinctive Twisted Defender victory over the more off-the-peg G-Class.

Disqus - noscript

I hoped in this review I'll read some serious comparo on what these vehicles are built for, the off-road abilities. All I learn are interior details irrelevant for anybody but offroad posers. I guess AE is the wrong forum for serious tests.

completely agree what a rubbish article, complete waste of time to get these two legends together, or is this a made up article and the test has never actually tookplace...to be told that landrover wins becasue it can be personalised to a grteater degree..actually merc offer unlimited personalisation also through its designo range of personalisation. Obviously no research was done for this article. Expected to see a reveiw of on/oiff road performnace etc.. not a winner based on how much customisation can be achieved. Surely that type of test is left to kit car and custom car forums, where perfomance and ability take back seat

What a waste of time, utter rubbish!

Dont you guys feel ashamed of write-ups like this?

Pathetic! Employ some proper journalists and do some proper tests.

Where is the article? THAT'S an article? What an insult to such cars, let alone to our time! You're better off sticking to those stupid videos about luring girls to get laid!

Auto Express 1,349
For more breaking car news and reviews, subscribe to Auto Express - available as a weekly magazine and on your iPad. We'll give you 6 issues for £1 and a free gift!

Sponsored Links