Skip advert
Advertisement

Volkswagen Golf vs Mazda 3

All-new Mazda 3 faces class-leading Volkswagen Golf in our family hatchback test

Welcome to our family hatchback shoot-out, where we pitch one of the hottest new models in the class against the established favourite in a bruising twin test. Click on the links below to read our full review of each car, then read on for our twin test verdict.

• Mazda 3 review

Advertisement - Article continues below

• Volkswagen Golf review

First up is the all-new Mazda 3, which aims to build on the award-winning success of the brand’s talented and fashionable CX-5 crossover and sleek 6 saloon.

The rakish 3 hatchback promises real premium appeal, featuring head-turning looks and an upmarket interior. It also aims to be as fun to drive as Mazda’s legendary MX-5 roadster. On top of this, it’s lighter than its predecessor and packed with the company’s efficiency boosting SkyActiv technology, so it should cost less to run than before.

As with other models in the Mazda line-up, the newcomer is available in three trim levels: SE, SE-L and Sport. And in the 3’s road test debut, we run the rule over the fast and frugal 2.2D SE-L, which costs £20,745.

Going head-to-head with the Mazda is one of the most desirable five-door hatchbacks money can buy: the VW Golf. Now in its seventh generation, the car oozes class and quality, is practical and doesn’t cost much to run. Plus, in 2.0-litre TDI guise, it’s fast and fun to drive.

Head-to-head

Going green

Both these cars wear eco badges, and buyers will be familiar with the Golf’s BlueMotion logo. It graces VWs with the latest fuel-saving kit, including stop-start and regenerative braking.

Advertisement - Article continues below
Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement - Article continues below

Used - available now

Golf

2022 Volkswagen

Golf

37,100 milesManualDiesel2.0L

Cash £19,295
View Golf
Golf

2020 Volkswagen

Golf

88,380 milesAutomaticPetrol1.5L

Cash £10,995
View Golf
Golf

2018 Volkswagen

Golf

59,650 milesAutomaticPetrol1.4L

Cash £11,795
View Golf
Golf

2024 Volkswagen

Golf

20,815 milesAutomaticDiesel2.0L

Cash £20,199
View Golf

Mazda’s SkyActiv models mix efficient engine tech with lightweight construction. But the highlight is the brand’s i-eloop stop-start. It converts wasted energy into electricity, stores it in a capacitor, then uses it instead of the main battery to restart the engine.

Practical touches

Mazda’s boot is smaller than VW’s, and less well thought out. There’s no 12V power supply and no shopping bag hooks, plus the Golf has an extra underfloor cubby. Still, the interior is packed with useful storage spaces.

Refinement

Engineers have worked to give the new 3 class-leading refinement – and they’ve largely succeeded. At idle, the smooth, free-revving 2.2-litre diesel is barely audible, registering 44dB on our sound meter. By comparison, the clattery Golf recorded a relatively high 48dB.

But on the move, the Mazda’s advantage is eroded. While engine noise and wind noise are well suppressed, there’s a lot of tyre roar. As a result, it showed exactly the same readings at 30mph and 70mph as the refined Golf.

Verdict

Volkswagen Golf hatchback 2013 front static

1st place: Volkswagen Golf

This was one of our closest road test verdicts of the year, but ultimately the Golf does just enough to take the win. Although it’s the more expensive choice here, it’s as cheap to run and has stronger residuals. It’s also more practical, boasts a softer ride and is very nearly as good to drive.

The VW trails on standard kit, but it gets all the essentials, such as a DAB radio. Plus, while it can’t match the Mazda’s official economy claims, the Golf was more frugal on test, returning a strong 46.5mpg. You’ll shell out less on routine maintenance for the VW too, thanks to a top-value £299 servicing pack. This covers the car for three years and 30,000 miles.

2nd place: Mazda 3

The new Mazda 3 is great value, fun to drive and surprisingly cost-effective to run. It’s also fast, impressively refined and extremely well put together. Trouble is, it can’t match the best in the class in terms of practicality, while the infotainment system is a little frustrating.

Mazda has ignored the trend for turbo petrol engines. Even so, the entry-level 99bhp 1.5 and 118bhp 2.0-litre petrol versions of the new 3 emit just 119g/km of CO2. There’s also a 163bhp 2.0-litre that puts out 135g/km.

Unlike many rivals, the Mazda is also available as a four-door saloon. It has a 419-litre boot – bigger than the five-door’s – plus is more aerodynamic, with a drag coefficient of 0.26. There are no plans to launch a 3 estate, though.

Skip advert
Advertisement

New & used car deals

Volkswagen Golf

Volkswagen Golf

RRP £24,625Avg. savings £3,068 off RRP*Used from £12,089
Audi A3

Audi A3

RRP £26,295Avg. savings £3,576 off RRP*Used from £11,895
Seat Leon

Seat Leon

RRP £24,125Avg. savings £8,055 off RRP*Used from £7,795
Cupra Leon

Cupra Leon

RRP £31,415Avg. savings £9,166 off RRP*Used from £17,495
* Average savings are calculated daily based on the best dealer prices on Auto Express vs manufacturer RRP
Skip advert
Advertisement

Have you considered?

New Peugeot E-408 2025 review: Peugeot's best EV yet
New Peugeot E-408 2025 - front tracking

New Peugeot E-408 2025 review: Peugeot's best EV yet

Road tests
28 Aug 2025
Cupra Born review
Cupra Born - main image

Cupra Born review

In-depth reviews
19 Aug 2025
Used Skoda Fabia (Mk4, 2021-date) buyer’s guide: great value, comfy and spacious
Used Skoda Fabia - front

Used Skoda Fabia (Mk4, 2021-date) buyer’s guide: great value, comfy and spacious

Used car tests
22 May 2025

Most Popular

MG Cyber X will morph into a mini-Mercedes within two years
MG Cyber X design render - front

MG Cyber X will morph into a mini-Mercedes within two years

Boxy small SUV is gearing up for production, and our exclusive images show how the model might look
News
30 Aug 2025
Car Deal of the Day: Ford Puma Gen-E granted ultra-low £132 monthly lease
Ford Puma Gen-E - front action

Car Deal of the Day: Ford Puma Gen-E granted ultra-low £132 monthly lease

The EV grant has made the Ford Puma Gen-E a lot cheaper, and lease customers can cash-in with today’s Deal of the Day
News
29 Aug 2025
Car Deal of the Day: Racy and retro Renault 5 for only £188 a month
Renault 5 - front full width

Car Deal of the Day: Racy and retro Renault 5 for only £188 a month

The Renault 5 is taking the market by storm – and at this price it’s easy to see why. It’s our Deal of the Day for August 30
News
30 Aug 2025