Kia Optima review

Our Rating: 
3
3.0/5.0
2012 model
By Auto Express Test TeamComments

The Kia Optima is a stylish saloon that offers plenty of kit and a good drive, too

For: 
Stylish looks, loads of equipment, low running costs
Against: 
Not as fun to drive as a Mondeo, no eco special, awkward boot

Sponsored Links

The Kia Optima family saloon is a sister model of the Hyundai i40. It's positioned as a rival to big-selling models such as the Ford Mondeo, Skoda Superb and Vauxhall Insignia, promising a blend of smart design and reasonable running costs. All versions of the Optima are well equipped, with 16-inch alloy wheels and Bluetooth connectivity fitted as standard across the range. And like all Kias, you get the reassurance of a seven-year, 100,000-mile warranty.

Best family cars on the market 

The Optima was introduced in 2011, with a recent mid-life update seeing some tweaks to the exterior design and cabin trim. The trims available in the Optima consist of simple 1, 2 and 3, with only one powerplant available - a 1.7 CRDi diesel. Both manual and automatic transmissions are available. 

Our choice: Optima 1.7 CRDi 2 Tech

Styling

4.5

There’s no doubt that the Kia Optima is an attractive car - it really stands out from the crowd. It benefits from Kia’s bold design philosophy, and it’s long, wide and low, so looks suitably sporty.

Up front, there’s a distinctive nose with Kia’s trademark grille design and LED running lights, while the sweeping roofline features silver trim that follows the line of the doors back to the shallow rear windscreen. The small side windows and slab-sided bodywork give the Optima the look of a coupé, while at the rear, the large LED tail-lights are reminiscent of the Ford Mondeo’s.

Climb inside, and the Kia’s design-led looks continue. The sculpted dashboard is angled towards the driver, while the instruments feature a large, high-resolution TFT display for the trip computer. The multifunction steering wheel is easy to get along with, although the standard paddleshifters feel cheap and flimsy. 

Elsewhere, wood trim on the centre console and doors seems on higher-spec models at odds with the car’s dynamic design, but leather is standard on Optima 2 models and up and the seats are comfortable. Overall build quality is as good as a VW Jetta's, and everything feels well put together. There’s a lot of black plastic, but the gloss sections and smattering of chrome trim helps to give the cabin a lift.

Driving

3.3

Fire up the Kia’s 1.7 CRDi diesel, and it sounds pretty rattly from both inside and outside the car. The Kia is let down by a rather flat power delivery, as it only really gets into its stride above 3,500rpm. When you get up to speed, the Optima's large wheels on higher-spec models create noticeable road noise in the cabin. 


Kia Optima 2014 rear

In corners, the Optima is surprisingly agile, considering its heavy kerbweight. It’s no sports car, but the chassis has plenty of grip and doesn’t tie itself in knots with quick direction changes. And while the steering lacks feedback, the Optima is marginally more engaging to drive than a VW Jetta.

The Optima is most at home being a comfortable cruiser. Whether in town or on the motorway, the soft suspension soaks up bumps well, even on 18-inch wheels. The cabin is a quiet place to spend time. 

Reliability

4.4

Korean car makers have gained a reputation for building reliable cars, so buying an Optima should be trouble-free. It shares its platform with the Hyundai i40, while the 1.7 CRDi diesel is found in a variety of other models, so its running gear should be reliable.

The Optima gets a seven-year, 100,000-mile warranty, and the company’s dealers came 10th in our Driver Power 2014 satisfaction survey. The Optima hasn’t been tested by Euro NCAP, but its sister car, the Hyundai i40 has, and that model achieved five stars. 

All Optimas get six airbags, stability control, Isofix and ABS with brakeforce distribution, but if you want blindspot detection and lane keeping, opt for the higher spec 3 model.

Practicality

4.2

The Kia’s large dimensions translate into a spacious interior. Its boot measures 505 litres although it’s finished rather disappointingly, with lots of exposed metal and a poor-quality carpet. There’s a full-size alloy wheel underneath, though, while the back seats fold 60:40 with the pull of two levers in the boot. The load lip is quite high, though. 

The Optima is reasonably practical, but it loses out to its sister model the Hyundai i40 (525 litres) and rival the Skoda Superb (565 litres) for outright carrying capacity.

Kia Optima 2014 interior

The rear seats fold down with one touch, but the bulkhead between the boot and cabin is awkwardly shaped and the boot itself isn't high enough to carry unusually shaped items. A longer wheelbase than the i40 gives the Optima plenty of rear-seat legroom, while a higher seating position gives the driver better visibility.

There's no shortage of interior storage space, either: you get a chilled glovebox, large bottle holders and a handy lidded compartment in the centre console for odds and ends.

Running Costs

4

A standard stop-start system helps the diesel Optima return average fuel consumption of 57.6mpg and emit 128g/km of CO2. Aside from the environmental benefits, these figures also mean a low tax bill for both private and company car drivers. However, compared with more recent rivals such as the Mazda 3 Fastback and Audi A3 Saloon, the Optima trails behind. 

Be aware that choosing an automatic gearbox will have a significant impact on running costs, too. Figures for this transmission are 47.1mpg combined economy and 158g/km of CO2 emissions.

Disqus - noscript

Shame you don't get the 2.4 ltr petrol with 18"alloys. A fine car indeed and well worth owning.

This test finds that the Optima it's not as much fun to drive as the class best, it rides a bit harshly and is less refined at motorway speeds. But somehow the cars is awarded just over four stars out of five for driving? How come?

Really why bother when the refreshed Optima is about to launch - which should improve in those areas.

Limited engine range but the car is a bit of a looker (going by these pictures).
Not bad at all for what I assume is the replacement for Magentis.
Since it's a Kia it will be crammed full with equipment and the yet unparalleled warranty.

What is autoexpress on about ? we are not offered the 2.0 petrol or the petrol/hybrid model ? never was ! unlike asia/aus/usa where they even have a 2.4, we in UK get nothing! lol only the 1.7 diesel, bit small for car this size, not something i buy ! shame, its good looking car !

We went to check out a Sportage for the Mrs this weekend and had a good look around one while there. Firstly, its a fantastic looking beast. Makes the usual mob of 3 Series, VAG, Mondeo etc look incredibly dull. Next was the amount of equipment for the money, it had everything and I mean everything for about £5k less than the Mondeo equivalent. We are going back this weekend to re-test the sportage, might try and get a cheeky drive of this too.

We did wonder about this, but the guy from Kia we spoke to said that other engine choices are on the way.

How do you define 'fun to drive' my experience of Ford Modeos is that the steering is vague, if that makes it fun to drive, I'd rather have positive steering and no fun.

nah, fork the looks, i still prefer a mondeo or better still honda accord.

ugly

Last updated: 5 Feb, 2015
Auto Express 1,376
For more breaking car news and reviews, subscribe to Auto Express - available as a weekly magazine and on your iPad. We'll give you 6 issues for £1 and a free gift!

Sponsored Links