Land Rover Discovery review

Our Rating: 
4
4.0/5.0
2009 model
By Auto Express Test TeamComments

Luxurious Land Rover Discovery is fantastic all-rounder that's big, bold and brilliant to drive on and off-road

For: 
Very capable off-roader, soothing ride, high quality
Against: 
High running costs, noisy at high speeds, repair bills

Sponsored Links

The Land Rover Discovery is a firm favourite of ours, having taken numerous class victories in our New Car Awards over the years. It balances refinement and luxury with go-anywhere ability.

It’s clear that the Land Rover Discovery sticks to a tried-and-tested formula. The current car can trace its roots back to the Discovery 3, which was launched in 2004, but constant development has kept the 7-seater at the top of its game. The 2014 model dropped the '4' from its name (it was called the Land Rover Discovery 4) and got a series of minor tweaks to its appearance in a bid to keep it at the front of the full-size SUV class.

Overall, the Discovery’s design hasn’t changed for 2015 – instead, Land Rover has turned its attention to the interior, upgrading the specification. The in-car tech isn’t as clever as the XC90’s, but the brand’s new £350 InControl option allows you to use apps on your Apple or Android smartphone via the in-car screen. On the mid-range SE Tech model there’s also sat-nav, parking sensors, cruise control, DAB and Bluetooth. 

The fourth-generation Land Rover Discovery may well be the ultimate all-rounder. It mixes a relaxing driving experience with a pair of punchy diesel engines and a cabin that boasts luxury car quality with lots of space and seven seats.

Oh, and it's also one of the most capable off-roaders on the planet. It isn't cheap and not sporty to drive like a BMW X5, plus there are doubts over reliability, but this is the Swiss Army knife of cars.

Our choice: Discovery 4 3.0 SDV6 XS

Styling

4.2

Constant evolution has kept the Land Rover Discovery looking fresh, although it’s helped no end by the distinctive, simple lines that give it a timeless appearance.

The tall bonnet, big headlight clusters and bright silver grille mean you’ll definitely see this SUV coming in your rear view mirror, and together with the expansive glass windows, chunky arch extensions and sills, plus massive 20-inch wheels, the Discovery looks imposing.

There are lots of traditional Land Rover design features, such as the clamshell bonnet and split tailgate, that add some extra visual impact and practicality, but overall, the look is more biased towards its off-road roots, hinting at this car’s considerable go-anywhere ability.

Like the exterior design, the Discovery’s cabin is more utilitarian than the rival Volvo XC90’s, but all of the gadgets are nicely integrated nonetheless. The infotainment screen is smaller and the graphics have a lower resolution – it takes longer to respond to your inputs than the Volvo’s tablet as well, but the familiarity of the system means it’s easy to use.

Leather trim comes as standard, and adds an upmarket air, but the Land Rover’s build quality still feels robust and up to anything you can throw at it, mixing refinement and sturdiness nicely.

The car feels more upmarket than the Toyota Land Cruiser and has a more modern design, while the fit and finish are first-class. There’s a premium feel to all of the switchgear and comfortable seats in all three rows.

Driving

4.2

The Land Rover Discovery has a single 3.0-litre V6 twin-turbodiesel on offer, with a healthy 252bhp on tap. This makes the Discovery good for 0-60mph in just 8.8 seconds. 

The standard eight-speed auto is a big help to the car's on-road performance. Shift paddles allow you to take manual control of the box, but these seem surplus to requirements as the electronics do a good job of keeping you in the right ratio most of the time.

The soft chassis set-up on the air-suspension model makes for incredible long-distance comfort, but the Disco’s weight and height mean the body rolls heavily in corners, even at moderate speeds. There's quite a bit of wind noise, though.

Venture off the beaten track, and the Discovery demonstrates another level of ability; it’s fantastic. Simply raise the air-suspension to off-road mode and switch the Terrain Response system to the relevant conditions, and the electronics optimise the 4WD system to suit the terrain. There are centre and rear diff locks, low-range gears and plenty of hi-tech electronics designed to keep you going. You’re likely to lose your nerve before the Discovery gets stuck.

If you do head off-tarmac, then there are some options available that are designed to help you on your way. Wade Sensing checks the depth of water you’re fording, while the surround camera system relays images from four cameras, whether you’re on or off the road.

Reliability

3.6

Land Rover is a perennially poor performer in our Driver Power satisfaction surveys, and its 2015 result proved no different. It ranked as the 29th brand out of 32, while its dealer network’s performance was consistent with this, finishing 28th in our most recent poll. As the Discovery has been on sale for more than 10 years now, most problems should have been ironed out – the Mk4 model tested here was voted the 68th best car to live with in our Driver Power 2015 top 200. Owners praised its ride quality and practicality. However, the results also show reliability can be patchy.

With one more airbag than the XC90, the Land Rover should be safe. As it’s basically unchanged from the Mk3 model, the last Euro NCAP crash test was back in 2006, where it received four stars overall. Bear in mind the assessment has changed a lot since then, but safety kit has been upgraded to include more airbags, as well as ESP, blind spot warning and reverse traffic alert. So although the Discovery can’t match the Volvo’s long list of hi-tech features, it should be reassuring.

Practicality

4.8

You get a fantastic raised seating position and a first-class cabin. The dashboard has a luxurious mix of leather, wood and soft-touch plastics, plus big chunky air vents. There's lots of room for driver and passengers while hi-tech gizmos like the dual-view centre console screen are desirable. Other options include a set of five cameras that can help you negotiate tight spaces, whether you're in the middle of nowhere or a multi-storey car park.

The two-part tailgate opens to reveal a 543-litre boot, while the lower section doubles up as a handy seat. It also creates a flat boot lip to help loading. The Discovery’s split tailgate is a nice touch, and provides somewhere to sit on family days out, but it’s also quite tall, so you’ll have to lift luggage high to load the boot up. Also, with it down it’s hard to reach in from the outside to put the back seats up. 

The manual seat-folding mechanism is clearly labelled and simple to use, although the rearmost seats are a bit heavy. Once up there’s lots of room, despite tight shoulder space, and two adults could easily sit in the back for a long journey.

Passenger space in all three rows is superb, with lots of headroom and storage, while the large glass area and three sunroofs give an airy feel. Getting in and out is easy, thanks to the Access suspension mode, which lowers the car by 5cm from normal driving height.

Running Costs

2.4

With a kerbweight of around 2,500kg and permanent four-wheel drive, there is only so much a diesel engine can do. Land Rover claims 32.1mpg, and even with gentle motorway runs we reckon most drivers could manage that.

It posts emissions of 213g/km, which when compared with the likes of the BMW X5 3.0d, is quite disappointing. The BMW manages much better figures - 38mpg and just 195g/km of CO2. Tyres will be expensive to replace and servicing will also be pricey.

For private buyers, depreciation of 58.3 per cent is excellent for such an expensive car, although this is offset by higher servicing costs than for the Toyota Land Cruiser.

Disqus - noscript

The Landrover Discovery4 with 19.5 Stars out of 25 attracts a 5 Star rating, yet the Volvo XC60 with 19.5 Stars out of 25 only attracts a 3 Star rating. Coincidently the Landrover Freelander 2 with 15 Stars attracts a 3 Star rating on the main 'in depth' review and 4 Stars in this weeks Auto Express. Am I missing something?

Yes, you're seeing stars. If you want to know how good a car is, go for a test drive yourself.

Last updated: 27 May, 2015