Chinese copycat cars

8 Jul, 2014 5:07pm Chris Ebbs

As China’s car market booms, we look at the shameless lookalikes Chinese car makers are selling - and see if they are legal

In 2013, China produced a whopping 18.7 million cars. That equates to 22.7 per cent of global car production. But while many of these models were from companies we’ve never heard of, some look very similar to those produced by their European counterparts.

From MINI lookalikes to an attempt at the grandeur of a Rolls-Royce, we’ve picked out some of the close imitations and put them side-by-side with their doppelgangers. Whether they’re blatant copies or not, we can’t really say, but there’s definitely more than a whiff of familiarity about a few of them.

China's copycat cars: are they legal?

We spoke to Oliver Tidman, a solicitor at intellectual property law firm BRIFFA, to find out what legal standing a car maker has if it thinks its design has been copied by another.

“There is no international copyright law,” he told us, “but there are international agreements such as the Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works. These require countries to recognise each other’s intellectual property laws.

“Copyright laws vary from one country to another, and while the rules may differ, the principles are similar.”

And it’s not simply a material object that would be the subject of breaking copyright law, but the original design itself. “In the UK, copyright law protects certain types of work, including artistic,” Tidman added. “In terms of car designs, it’s likely that copyright would subsist in any original 2D graphic – on a computer screen or a drawing.”

If a company does think a design has been copied, however, it’s not that easy to prove. “The company would have to prove that there has been copying by assessing the objective similarities and deciding whether those similarities are the result of independent creation, or whether the infringing design has been derived from the original design,” said our expert. “There must be a causal connection between the two works, which can be difficult to prove.”

In addition to copyright protection, it is possible to register designs. “If the design or prototype is deemed original, it is possible to obtain registered design protection for up to 25 years,” Tidman explained.

Do these look familiar?

Check-out the copycat cars below, alongside the models they seem to have drawn inspiration from...

JAC A6 and Audi A6

While some companies won’t let on just which car they might be imitating, it seems that JAC was quite happy to own up when it badged its latest release the A6. Yes, that’s right, the A6.

Not only does it have the exact same name as the Audi A6 saloon, but it looks very similar to the original model. It’s the grille and stepped headlights that really give the game away.

Copied: Audi A6

Audi A6

Copycat: JAC A6

JAC A6

BAIC X424 and Jeep Cherokee

Another model that looks more like a merging of two cars than just a single copy of one. The BAIC X424 has a hint of the Jeep Cherokee at the front with the large grille openings, while the side profile is clearly taken from the rugged Wrangler model. Perhaps the company felt that customers wouldn’t be happy with just one Jeep and instead wanted the best of both.

Copied: Jeep Cherokee

Jeep Cherokee

Copycat: BAIC X424

BAIC X424

BYD S7 and Lexus RX

While some imitations are fairly obvious at a glance, others are disguised a little better. The BYD S7 may not have the look of the Lexus RX from the front, but there’s no hiding the similarities towards the rear, with the same curved windows, small spoiler and tail-lights. BYD has done a decent job of keeping this quiet, but not good enough.

Copied: Lexus RX

Lexus RX

Copycat: BYD S7

BYD S7

Geely GE and Rolls-Royce Phantom

Fancy the luxury of a Rolls-Royce Phantom, but don’t quite have the £305,000 to cover the costs? Well the Geely GE might just be the thing for you. It’s got the big chrome grille and even an imitation Spirit of Ecstasy on the bonnet. Just make sure nobody gets too close to see what it actually is.

Copied: Rolls-Royce Phantom

Rolls-Royce Phantom

Copycat: Geely GE

Geely GE

Lifan 330 and MINI

The round headlights, that front grille and the cheeky hatchback shape... the Lifan 330 has more than a hint of the second-generation MINI Cooper about it. When it was launched at April’s Beijing Motor Show, even the press release hailed the car as fashionable, artistic and with ‘mini’ temperament. Lifan was just ahead of the British brand with the five-door bodystyle, however, but that’s no excuse.

Copied: MINI

Mini

Copycat: Lifan 330

Lifan 330

Chery Riich M1 and Toyota Yaris

The Chery Riich M1 is a small hatchback designed for inner city commuters. While the front end is ugly enough to not really resemble anything on UK roads, the curvaceous side profile and rear of the car look like a direct lift from the Toyota Yaris MkII. Fortunately for Toyota that’s where the similarities end, and it’s unlikely to ever be any real competition to the established – and far more attractive – hatchback.

Copied: Toyota Yaris

Toyota Yaris

Copycat: Chery Riich M1

Cherry Riich M1

Zotye T600 and Volkswagen Touareg

The large SUV, revealed at April’s Beijing Motor Show, is a doppelganger of two models from the VW Group. Take the Audi Q5 and VW Touareg, mix a few of the parts together and this is the result. On the show stand the Zotye T600 was even glistening in the same shade of brown as the VW. Surely more than a coincidence?

Copied: Volkswagen Touareg

VW Touareg

Copycat: Zotye T600

Zotye T600

Brilliance V5 and BMW X1

Brilliance is the partner of BMW in China, and the X1 compact crossover went on sale in the country through the partnership. So, it’s interesting to see that Brilliance launched its very own rival to the X1, dubbed the V5. It’s probably one of the closest copies we’ve ever seen. Of course, this version is cheaper than the BMW model, but is only sold in China.

Copied: BMW X1

BMW X1

Copycat: Brilliance V5

Brilliance V5

Disqus - noscript

Clearly they are copied, but if anything, they devalue the Chinese brand- it makes both the manufacturer and buyer look like a cheap-skate, unimaginative fool. And conversely, the real car more desirable.

Then there's the new Landwind Evoque clone. The most notorious is possibly the Chery QQ Daewoo Matiz clone where they allegedly used Matiz's with revised outer panelsin the crash testing. It doesn't help when there is Western investment in companies that clone cars, eg BYD's Aygo's. Some of the guilty parties have subsequently formed JV's with Western manufacturers - I bet BMW are a bit sore about Brilliance... There are even cases of clones of clones, eg Isuzu/Opel/Vauxhall pickup trucks

The Chery Riich M1 has a hint of Perodua Myvi (1st gen) at the front!!! Whilst the Brilliance V5 has a hint of Skoda Roomster in its front end!!!

Quite entertaining really, and I am confident that the copy versions of Audis are better than the real thing.

No wonder, the new VW Passat for 2015 is based on a Chinese Car named YLB Longlife!

The question is, how are people in China able to afford cars like these? The last time I was there there was barely a car on the road.

But strangely VW are copying Chinese cars with the new Passat so works both ways.

When you see how these Chinese cars perform in crash tests, you'll want to buy the real thing.

You must be a living fossil

Google is paying 80$ per hour! Work for few hours and have more time with

friends & family! On tuesday I got a great new Land Rover Range Rover from

having earned $4151 this last four weeks. Its the most-financialy rewarding I've

had. It sounds unbelievable but you wont forgive yourself if you don’t check it

-----------------------------------------------------
Here ­­­­­­­­­is ­­­­­­­­­I ­­­­­­­­­started,----- J­o­b­H­u­g­o.C­o­­­m

----------------------------------------------------

GO TO THE SITE -->>>CLICK NEXT TAB FOR MORE INFO AND HELP

Can you please provide an example of the Chinese car that the Passat is copying? To me the new Passat looks like the old Passat and this is a model that VW have been selling in China for 30 years. Last time I was in China, most taxis were passats.

AEX 1334
For more breaking car news and reviews, subscribe to Auto Express - available as a weekly magazine and on your iPad. We'll give you 6 issues for £1 and a free gift!

Sponsored Links