Skip advert
Advertisement

Car hire firms ripping off drivers with overpriced insurance excess waivers

Rental companies’ theft and damage excess prices add as much as 90 per cent to the total cost of hiring a car, research shows

Car hire 1

Car hire companies are ripping off drivers with overpriced excess waivers, research has shown.

Taking out an excess waiver for damage and theft when you hire a car can add as much as 90 per cent to the total rental cost, according to a study by TravelSupermarket. For example, an eight-day car hire at Paphos airport with Avis from 27 July would cost £195.16, while the excess waiver would add an extra £174.68.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Holiday car hire: scams, tips and how to get a cheap deal

The study shows that some excess waivers are up to 579 per cent more expensive than they should be. An excess waiver for an eight-day hire with Hertz from Barcelona El Prat airport from 27 July would cost £189.93 – seven times more than the £27.96 fee for taking out an equivalent, standalone policy.

Excess waivers are not compulsory, but if you don’t take one out when you rent a car and the vehicle is then damaged or stolen while in your possession, you could be charged an excess fee by the rental company, probably somewhere between £500 and £2,000.

One way around the car hire companies’ expensive excess waivers is to take out a standalone one from a specialist company instead. These cost from as little as £3.49 a day and often cover a wider range of damages, such as tyres and windscreens.

Looking at its list of the top 10 most searched for summer holiday destinations for UK tourists, TravelSupermarket found that Budget’s desk at Palma airport in Mallorca had the most overpriced excess waivers, charging 544 per cent more than an independent specialist company.

In addition, Avis’ desks at Alicante airport in Spain and Paphos airport in Cyprus overcharge 529 per cent and 525 per cent respectively.

• Car hire industry faces investigation over fraudulent repair bills

Emma Coulthurst, consumer advocate at TravelSupermarket, criticised car hire companies for selling policies for “extortionate amounts” to a “captive audience”, accusing them of trying to discourage drivers from comparing excess waiver prices by not listing prices online.

A spokesperson for Avis Budget UK said customer service and transparency fees are of “paramount importance” to the company, adding that customers are allowed to use their own providers and are encouraged to review any charges in the rental contract.

Have you ever paid out for an expensive excess waiver on a hire car? Tell us about it in the comments...

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement

Most Popular

Mercedes says ‘no thank you’ to EQ: EV brand to be axed
Mercedes-AMG EQS 53 - EQS badge
News

Mercedes says ‘no thank you’ to EQ: EV brand to be axed

Mercedes will roll back EQ branding for its electric cars as the first generation of EV models reaches the end of its lifecycle.
15 May 2024
UK faces “epidemic” of young uninsured drivers
Car crash
News

UK faces “epidemic” of young uninsured drivers

The number of young people convicted of driving without insurance has tripled since 2021, due to sky-rocketing premiums
17 May 2024
Car Deal of the Day: SEAT Leon is an ideal family hatchback for £165 a month
SEAT Leon TSI EVO - front tracking
News

Car Deal of the Day: SEAT Leon is an ideal family hatchback for £165 a month

Excellent interior quality and efficiency make the SEAT Leon our Deal of the Day for 17 May
17 May 2024