Advertisement

'Why doesn’t the Government issue guidance on the cars that it recommends?'

Mike Rutherford questions why the Government is so vague on the future of diesel cars

It’s official. You, dear private motorist, have been warned by Transport Minister Chris Grayling to think “long and hard” about the type of car you opt for. Yet again it is relatively clean, green, low-mileage, state-of-the-art cars – plus their drivers – that are in the firing line. 

Knackered dirty diesel buses, coaches, taxis, trains, lorries and agricultural vehicles are barely acknowledged as the gross polluters they are. Nobody’s denying there are issues with emissions from some diesel cars, but too many politicians and others conveniently forget other heavy-duty diesel vehicles (plus boats, ships, planes etc) cause far greater pollution nightmares.

Advertisement - Article continues below

• Your guide to UK road tax

Grayling infers his Government will help kill off diesel personal mobility machines. Yet there’s absolutely no instruction you should stop driving the one you’ve got. And they have no objections to you spending, say, £40,000 on a new diesel family car tomorrow, as this would earn their Treasury an additional £8,000 in VAT receipts, plus thousands more in other taxes/duties/levies.

At the same time, the same Government is not advising you to buy a petrol or petrol-electric vehicle. Or one that runs on LPG. There’s a bit of encouragement to buy 100 per cent electric cars which tend to be even more VAT-lucrative than petrols or diesels for the Treasury. But, again, there’s no solid advice from the politicians that 100 per cent EVs are your best bet. 

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

Government is brave enough to say buying a house is usually wiser than renting one; that gas is a preferable and more affordable central heating source than electric or coal; that certain countries are safe to visit while others aren’t. So if it can offer clear guidance on these and other important topics, why not issue equally straightforward guidance to motorists about the cars it recommends, not forces, us to run?

The best electric cars on sale

If it intends to wage war on diesels (via financial penalties, premature scrappage etc.), say so. On the other hand, if our leaders want a near-future switch to 100 per cent EVs (with greater incentives to buy and run), tell us. But for what it’s worth, I don’t think diesel cars can or will die. Or that pure-electrics will take over. They’ll both be on our roads for many years. More importantly, in between those two extremes sit increasingly attractive, efficient petrol-electrics – and the sooner the Government accepts these are the cars of the short-to-medium-term future, the better.

Do you think the Government should offer more advice on which cars to buy? Let us know in the comments section below...

Advertisement
Advertisement

Recommended

'Sorry Jeep, but Kia now makes the best all-American SUV'
Kia

'Sorry Jeep, but Kia now makes the best all-American SUV'

With Kia winning the World Car of the Year 2020 award with the American-built Telluride, Mike Rutherford believes Kia has beaten Jeep at their own gam…
18 Apr 2020
'Costs may drop, but buyers’ expectations don’t'
News

'Costs may drop, but buyers’ expectations don’t'

Just because premium brands can offer cheap finance deals, it doesn't mean that they can fob buyers off with poor customer service, says Deputy editor…
15 Apr 2020
“UK motor industry – your country and its people need you”
News

“UK motor industry – your country and its people need you”

Mike Rutherford thinks the motor industry can still do more to help provide life-saving medical kit
12 Apr 2020
‘What better than a thumbs-up from an existing owner?’
News

‘What better than a thumbs-up from an existing owner?’

Editor-in-chief Steve Fowler gives his view on our 2020 Driver Power survey, and is especially pleased by Kia's success
8 Apr 2020

Most Popular

New Cupra el-Born electric hot hatch offers 310-mile range
Cupra el-Born

New Cupra el-Born electric hot hatch offers 310-mile range

The sporty Cupra el-Born is the Spanish brand’s first all-electric vehicle – and it has a maximum claimed range of 310 miles
8 Jul 2020
New Polestar 2 2020 review
Polestar 2 Hatchback

New Polestar 2 2020 review

We get behind the wheel of the new Polestar 2 to see if it can rival the Tesla Model 3
7 Jul 2020
New Ineos Grenadier 4x4: prices, specs and video of the Land Rover Defender rival
Ineos Grenadier

New Ineos Grenadier 4x4: prices, specs and video of the Land Rover Defender rival

The Ineos Grenadier will be built in Wales and will use BMW engines, but fuel-cell electrification is also likely in the future
7 Jul 2020