Audi A3 review

Our Rating: 
2012 model
By Auto Express Test TeamComments

The Audi A3 takes fight to the BMW 1 Series and Mercedes A-Class with good looks, impressive economy and a decent drive

Fantastic interior quality, range of efficient engines, comfortable ride
Expensive, cramped rear seats, not as fun to drive as a BMW 1 Series

Sponsored Links

The Audi A3 is a premium family hatchback that sits above the A1 supermini, but below the larger A4 compact executive in the Audi model range. Designed specifically to take the fight to the BMW 1 Series, Mercedes A-Class and Volvo V40, the A3 remains a shining sales success for the firm.

With a classy, elegant exterior, a well crafted interior and the latest safety and efficiency technology, the A3 is far from the poor relation in Audi’s range. 

Maintaining a premium look and feel inside and out has never been an issue for the A3. The latest model has undoubtedly the best interior in the class, with superb fit and finish and an attractive design. 

The A3 is based on the MQB platform, like most of the VW Group’s newer models, including the VW Golf and SEAT Leon which compete against the A3 but at lower price points.

Audi has tuned the A3’s chassis specifically for a sportier feel than any other hatchback in the VW Group. However, it still lacks the composed drive and level of intimacy on the road that the best in the class can offer, namely the sharp and involving BMW 1 Series. But the engine range is strong and extensive, and increasingly more fuel-efficient.

Best hatches to buy now 

For petrol fans, there are turbocharged 1.2, 1.4 and 1.8-litre TFSI engines, which range from 109bhp to 178bhp. The 1.4 TFSI comes in 123bhp and 148bhp guises, the latter featuring Audi's Cylinder On Demand engine technology, which shuts down cylinders to deliver better claimed economy than the less powerful 1.4. Audi plans to introduce fuel-sipping three-cylinder petrols to the A3 for the first time later this year.

On the diesel side, a 1.6 TDI with 109bhp is offered alongside two versions of the VW Group's 2.0-litre TDI unit - coming in 148bhp and 182bhp outputs. The latter boasts impressive claimed economy figures of 68.9mpg and CO2 emissions of just 108g/km. Despite this, the 1.6-litre diesel and 1.4-litre petrol units are the pick of the bunch for combining economy and performance.

The Audi A3 comes in a range of trim levels - consisting of SE, Sport, S Line and performance S3 versions. Audi's quattro four-wheel-drive system is available from mid-range Sport models and up, with six-speed manual or six-speed S tronic automatic gearboxes available across the range.

A3 SE and Sport models look fairly restrained on the outside, but range-topping A3 S Line models get 18-inch alloys and a sporty body kit.

The A3 comes in various body styles, including a three-door hatch, five-door Sportback, Cabriolet and a four-door saloon. In addition, all four body styles are available in sporty S3 guise, which features quattro four-wheel drive and a 296bhp 2.0 TFSI turbo petrol engine. At the very top of the range is the RS3, which features a 362bhp 2.5-litre turbocharged five-cylinder engine and quattro four-wheel drive, but is only offered in the five-door Sportback body style. At the other extreme of the range, the A3 e-tron plug-in hybrid returns claimed economy of 176mpg, using technology developed from Audi's Le Mans 24 Hours-winning R18 sportscar. 

The impressive e-tron model is supposed to challenge the BMW i3, but doesn't feel quite as revolutionary as its fully electric (or range-extending) rival from Munich. However, the Audi is more conventional and easier to live with. Considering the amount of choice in the A3 range, there should be a model that will suit almost every buyer. 

Our choice: A3 1.6 TDI S line

Engines, performance and drive


Unlike the previous generation A3, the new model bucks the Ingolstadt-based company's trend of using hard suspension to improve the handling - which ultimately compromised ride comfort. The suspension on the new A3 is a vast improvement over the old car, with only a dab of firmness present. Despite being a decent general drive, though, the handling on the A3 is still a somewhat un-involving experience.

Audi A3 rear action

All models of Audi A3 get a standard suspension setting, but on Sport and S Line models, buyers can opt for a sportier, stiffer suspension at no extra cost - however, be aware that the ride is significantly firmer with this set up.

In terms of engine, we'd choose either the 1.6-litre TDi or 1.4-litre TFSI petrol engine for a good mix of economy and performance - the more powerful version of the petrol model can turn off cylinders when they're not needed to save fuel. Go for the 1.8-litre petrol if you need speed at the expense of economy, or the 2.0-litre TDI for great power and efficiency at the cost of refinement.

MPG, CO2 and running costs


Choosing an A3 diesel is the most sensible option if economy is your main priority. The 148bhp 2.0-litre TDI returns a combined cycle of 68.9 mpg and has CO2 emissions of only 106g/km. The smaller 1.6-litre TDI returns CO2 emissions of 99g/km and economy of 74.3mpg.

Petrol engines are usually a lot less economical, but the Audi A3 with 1.8 TFSI power and S tronic auto actually gets 50.4mpg and CO2 emissions of 129g/km - not bad considering the performance on offer. Plus, the clever 148bhp 1.4 TFSI petrol features cylinder deactivation to return 60.1mpg and emit only 109g/km of CO2, so while it's faster than the less powerful 1.4 TFSI, it's claimed to be more economical.

However, not all running costs are low, and an equivalent 1 Series or Golf will be cheaper to insure, as the A3 falls into insurance group 16. It's also quite a bit more expensive to buy than a Ford Focus or VW Golf, but decent standard equipment and strong residual values help to counter the higher initial outlay.

The service schedule ranges from 9,000 miles for minor checks to 19,000 miles for a full service. Audi offers a range of fixed-price deals, though, so maintenance shouldn’t prove too costly.

Interior, design and technology


The A3 carries the familiar trademarks of a car from Audi’s range, with the same style lights and large grille found on everything from the A1 to the A8. However, it's an attractive design with a quality look, so while it may be conservative when compared to the likes of the Mercedes A-Class, it's certainly a handsome car.

What the A3 lacks in exterior excitement, it makes up for on the interior, with a stylish and simple dashboard design and high-quality materials throughout.

Entry-level SE spec cars get 16-inch alloy wheels, stop-start technology, air-conditioning and Bluetooth tech as standard. What's more, every A3 gets a slick, 5.8-inch screen that pops out from the top of the dash. This is controlled by a rotary wheel on the centre console - which is an excellent feature to find on entry level models.

Practicality, comfort and boot space


The latest Audi A3 is the same length as the previous-generation car. However, thanks to a stretched wheelbase, the interior is more accommodating for passengers than before. The wider track in the new model also gives occupants more elbow room.

In terms of practicality, one downside of the Audi A3 is that the rear can be a bit cramped for taller adults, but getting in and out of the three-door shouldn't be much trouble, thanks to the long doors.

Audi A3 interior

Thanks to its improved dimensions, the Audi A3 gets more room in the boot and space is now extended to 365 litres with the rear seats in place - when folded, this grows to 1,100 litres. However, the BMW 1 Series is bigger as it offers 360 litres and 1,200 litres, while the Volkswagen Golf offers 380 litres and 1,270 litres of boot space.

If you need the extra room, opting for the five-door Sportback for an extra £620 makes sense. Boot space increases to 380-litres and 1,220-litres with the seats folded flat.

Reliability and Safety


The A3 is an impressively safe car, having scored the maximum five stars in Euro NCAP's crash tests. Of particular note is its score of 95 per cent in the adult occupant protection category.

Audi has stocked the A3 with impressive levels of big-car safety kit, too. These include optional radar-controlled cruise control that maintains a set distance to the car in front, lane-keep assist, hill-hold assist and a pre-sense system to prepare the car in the event of an accident. Another optional safety feature is a self-park system that will help you get into a tight parking space.

The A3 also put in an impressive performance in 2014's Driver Power survey - coming in 16th place out of 150 cars. 

Disqus - noscript

Hang on a minute. Average if slightly below avg. reliability reports and 4.5 stars for reliability titled section. Is it just me. AE please change or at least explain/revise....

How can it be very spacious as a "for" and tight rear seats as a "against"

I dont understand why this is only a 4 star car yet the new golf is a 5 star car?

surely one problem that Audi should be aware of is the image? Remember years ago they had an ad where a "typical" BMW driver, loud,arrogant,mobile phone had a test drive in an audi and said something like - Good car but not for me?
Well, its obvious that BMW drivers have now bought in to the Audi brand- white ones abound around Crewe/knutsford driven by complete c**** who cannot see further than their bonnets

Could not possibly comment about the character of Audi drivers! However Audis share something in common with most VW Group products namely a complete lack of stylistic imagination. (I was going to say "terminal lack of stylistic imagination" but this is obviously very popular with potential customers).
True it takes a bit of judgement to hit the spot between "dull" and "vulgar" but it would be nice if VW Group tried a bit harder. Apart from the Scirocco they don't seem to have tried in the slightest recently.

Just been told I have to wait 7 months for my new sportback.

This is another aged posting which has been "recycled" but having looked at some BMW interiors lately, the more modest ones do have a surprisingly "low rent" air. In this respect the Audi has some advantages.

When you look at a 5 door A3 theres something fundamentally very wrong about the styling. It looks cheap too and apart from the snazzy lights isn't any improvement over the old A3. If I had to buy a VW group car from this platform then the Golf looks a better prospect especially since Audi's these days are all driven by yobs. The fact that you don't see a lot of them about on the roads and by comparison loads of new 1 series BMWs should give Audi cause for concern .

Non-anoraks can only really tell the difference between the former A3 and the present one by reference to the registration number! If you really buy into the VW Group ethos then SEAT would seem to be the obvious choice,

Get over your selfs. Audi don't sell so well for no reason. And the reference to VW like its a bad thing, but seat over Audi? Audi has its own division same as Lamborghini Porsche etc.

The propaganda is superb. As Belloc put it "the Press was squared, the middle class prepared". More seems to hinge upon which individual assembly line your vehicle travels down than the label it bears, when it comes to dependability. SEAT tends to have a bit more stylistic imagination than the rest but if this is of no import to you then just buy the cheapest equivalent.

Haters will say vw seat blah blah blah. Yet audi remains to be the most popular of the big three (bmw, merc, audi).
Fans would say lamborghini, Porsche, Bentley, Bugatti.
And why would you pay £10k/£20k/£30k more for an audi over the vw, it's alot for most. Or buy one over the merc or bmw. Proof is in the pudding and people spending that much aren't going to just part with their hard earned cash for the fun of it.

What the heck are you talking about? What point are you trying to make? For a second there I thought you were saying that A3s and A4s have more in common with a Bugatti or a Bentley than a Golf or Passat!!! Hate to break it to you, but there's no difference in price or quality between equivalent engined/spec'd VWs & Audis, they run on the same platforms and share components, so how did you come up with your... quote.... "£10k/£20k/£30k more for an Audi over a VW" from???????? Audis and VWs are very similarily priced for cars with the same engines & spec. You just choose which you prefer. Some people prefer Golfs over A3s & vice versa!! Which ever you choose, you end up paying the same price for what is effectively the same car with different badges. I like both Audi and VW, and both marques are a cut above BMW/Merc today.

Pretentious nonesense

Last updated: 1 Apr, 2015