Advertisement

Zero stars all round in Indian car crash tests

Latest bout of crash tests from Global NCAP shows Indian cars severely lacking in safety, with five new cars tested

Global NCAP has released a set of crash tests for Indian market cars, and the results don’t make for pretty viewing. The Hyundai Eon, Mahindra Scorpio, Suzuki Maruti Eeco and Celerio, and three versions of the Renault KWID were tested, and none of them achieved even a single star in Global NCAP’s crash tests.

Advertisement - Article continues below

India has one of the highest rates of road deaths in the world, with over 230,000 recorded deaths in 2013 alone and the results are especially shocking given the popularity of these vehicles in India. The Renault Kwid alone is responsible for nearly 10,000 vehicle sales a month, and all the other cars tested post similar sales figures.

Safest cars on sale

Zero stars for GM cars in South America

These crash test results are the second round of safety checks on Indian cars. During the first round of tests in 2014, eight cars were tested, and only the Volkswagen Polo and Toyota Etios (when fitted with optional airbags) achieved more than zero stars. The latest set of Indian cars were expected to perform much better, but it’s clear from these tests that little-to-no progress has been made.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

Crash tests were conducted at 64kph – around 39mph, as in most NCAP tests. Most of the cars tested suffered badly with deformation to the bodyshell, with the structure completely collapsing in some cases. Global NCAP believes that a crash in any of these vehicles is likely to result in life-changing injury.

Advertisement - Article continues below

During these tests, the Renault KWID was featured three times. The first model suffered with a collapsing structure and lack of airbags, but Renault proposed that Global NCAP test an updated, safer KWID, with changes implemented from April 2016. The updated KWID was tested with and without the optional airbag and still scored zero stars. In fact, while it was possible to see extra strengthening had been added for the new model, this was shockingly only fitted onto the driver’s side of the car – the passenger side was untouched.

• What is Euro NCAP? 

The Suzuki Maruti Celerio was also tested, a car that achieves three stars in the Euro NCAP test when fitted with airbags. The Global NCAP results go to show what a vast impact airbags and other safety tech have in the event of a crash. UK buyers will be happy to know that the vehicle’s bodyshell and structure remained stable through the impact, though.

Advertisement - Article continues below
Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

Suzuki’s other offering, the Eeco (based on the old Super Carry van) didn’t fare as well, with Global NCAP noting that even airbags would be unlikely to aid safety given the structural collapse of the vehicle.

The Mahindra Scorpio was the largest vehicle featured, and also achieved zero stars. Global NCAP notes that adult occupants would face a high probability of life-threatening injuries in the event of a crash.

• Quadricycle crash tests show lack of safety

The final vehicle tested was the Hyundai Eon, a sub-i10 model created for the Indian market. As with other vehicles tested, it suffered from an unstable structure and lack of airbags.

Of the manufacturers featured, only Renault has responded so far, noting its disappointment at the result and reassuring buyers that it will continue to improve the safety of its KWID model. David Ward, Secretary General of Global NCAP said: ‘Renault has a strong record of achievement in safety in Europe and it should offer the same commitment to its customers in India.

Global NCAP also highlighted the important role the Indian government has to play, as it plans to mandate crash tests for all new cars from October 2017 to ensure they adhere to the minimum levels of occupant protection set forth by the United Nations.

Do you think Indian cars should adhere to the same safety standards as European ones? Let us know in the comments below...

Advertisement
Advertisement

Most Popular

Skoda Octavia Estate vs Toyota Corolla Touring Sports
Estates

Skoda Octavia Estate vs Toyota Corolla Touring Sports

Skoda’s new Octavia Estate has moved upmarket. We find out if it’s a better wagon than the Toyota Corolla Touring Sports
4 Jul 2020
New Skoda Octavia vRS line-up completed as petrol and diesel models arrive
Skoda Octavia vRS Hatchback

New Skoda Octavia vRS line-up completed as petrol and diesel models arrive

Skoda has unwrapped the complete Octavia line-up, which now offers a choice of petrol, diesel or plug-in hybrid powertrains
3 Jul 2020
New Ineos Grenadier 4x4: prices, specs and video of the Land Rover Defender rival
Ineos Grenadier

New Ineos Grenadier 4x4: prices, specs and video of the Land Rover Defender rival

The Ineos Grenadier will be built in Wales and will use BMW engines, but fuel-cell electrification is also likely in the future
7 Jul 2020