Skip advert
Advertisement

Insurers fined for complaint tampering

FSA issues huge fines for Direct Line and Churchill after they are found to have doctored customer complaint files

Customer complaint forms have been tampered with

Insurance firms Direct Line and Churchill have been fined £2.17m by the Financial Services Authority (FSA) for tampering with customer complaint files.

More than half of the 50 cases that were submitted for inspection by the FSA were doctored, according to the financial body, including forged staff signatures on seven documents.

Advertisement - Article continues below

The two insurers were asked to submit the paperwork in 2009, as part of the regulator’s drive to improve complaints handling. 

The BBC claims that staff were threatened with disciplinary action if there were shortcomings in their complaints procedures, before the tampering occurred. 

The FSA says the changes to the documents were “purely clerical” and “minor in nature”, but that the firms had still made a “serious breach of the rules”. 

The British taxpayer will effectively be footing the bill for the multi-million pound FSA fine, however, as it now owns the insurers’ parent company, the Royal Bank of Scotland.

Have you received poor customer service at the hands of Direct Line or Churchill? If so, tell us all about it below.

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement

Most Popular

It’s time to be clear and honest about battery health on used electric cars
Opinion - used EV battery health

It’s time to be clear and honest about battery health on used electric cars

Paul Barker explains why sellers need to be clearer about battery degradation in order to give used EV buyers a confidence boost
Opinion
15 Feb 2026
New Toyota Yaris in-line for major rethink to try and please hybrid and EV buyers
Toyota Yaris - front (watermarked)

New Toyota Yaris in-line for major rethink to try and please hybrid and EV buyers

The Mk5 Toyota Yaris will be offered with internal-combustion, hybrid and electric powertrains to suit buyers’ needs, and our exclusive images preview…
News
16 Feb 2026
Electric cars are more expensive to buy and insure, and will depreciate faster
Opinion - EVs

Electric cars are more expensive to buy and insure, and will depreciate faster

Mike Rutherford is not surprised to see the electric car market slowing down in the UK
Opinion
15 Feb 2026

Find a car with the experts