Skip advert
Advertisement

"On the whole, Mercedes makes great cars, but there’s something lacking across its entire range"

It’s an A+ for the Mercedes-AMG GT and Maybach - but editor-in-chief Steve Fowler isn't convinced about other Mercs...

Mercedes AMG GT opinion

As my colleague Owen Mildenhall was testing the new Mercedes-AMG GT to its limits around the Laguna Seca circuit in California, I enjoyed a more relaxed time chatting with Mercedes’ sales and marketing boss Ola Källenius in the back of the new Mercedes-Maybach S600.

Until last year, Källenius was boss of what is now known (in the latest Mercedes speak) as Mercedes-AMG. So as much as we were in the back of the car that launched Mercedes’ latest sub-brand, Mercedes-Maybach, there was more than a passing interest in what was happening on the other side of the world with the first drives of what is the most beautiful Merc in a generation.

Advertisement - Article continues below

On both scores, Mercedes has come up trumps – its new poster boy is as good to drive as it is to look at, while the Maybach is proof of what Källenius described to me as “everything Mercedes knows about luxury in one car”.

So the ‘halo’ models are shining brightly, but what about the models that will sell in bigger numbers at more affordable prices? While the C-Class is one of the best looking saloons you can buy with an interior that sets new standards for style and quality, it’s left us a bit cold when it comes to how it drives. Then there’s the A-Class – a stylish hatchback for sure, but again it disappoints on the road and, more shockingly, on the quality of its interior.

On the whole, Mercedes makes great cars, but there’s something lacking across its entire range, something its rivals have more of – consistency. Let’s hope the AMG GT and Maybach are the start of great all-round Mercs across the entire range.

Are you a fan of Mercedes' current line-up, or are you an owner? Let us know your thoughts below, or on Twitter or Facebook.

Skip advert
Advertisement

Steve Fowler has previously edited Auto Express, Carbuyer, DrivingElectric, What Car?, Autocar and What Hi-Fi? and has been writing about cars for the best part of 30 years. 

Skip advert
Advertisement

Recommended

Most expensive cars ever sold at auction
Most expensive cars - header image

Most expensive cars ever sold at auction

The rarest and most desirable cars ever made fetch eye-watering sums when going under the hammer. These examples attracted the highest auction prices …
Best cars & vans
17 Feb 2026
Updated Mercedes Marco Polo aims to beat VW's California as the wheeled holiday home of choice
Mercedes Marco Polo - front

Updated Mercedes Marco Polo aims to beat VW's California as the wheeled holiday home of choice

Merc’s contract with Westfalia has come to an end, meaning the Marco Polo camper will be built on the same line as the V-Class MPV
News
3 Feb 2026
Stop teasing us Mercedes-AMG, just give us a CLE 63 with a big V8 already!
Jordan AMG CLE Opinion

Stop teasing us Mercedes-AMG, just give us a CLE 63 with a big V8 already!

Jordan Katsianis believes that the teaser of AMG’s new Mythos series CLE raises more questions than it answers
Opinion
28 Jan 2026
Upcoming Mercedes-AMG Mythos will be a CLK 63 Black Series for the 2020s
Mercedes-AMG Mythos series CLE - front 3/4

Upcoming Mercedes-AMG Mythos will be a CLK 63 Black Series for the 2020s

A new, ultra-limited run of wide-body CLE will be the next in AMG’s Mythos series
News
27 Jan 2026

Most Popular

New Land Rover Defender Sport: baby SUV will be boxy and electric
New baby Land Rover Defender render - watermarked

New Land Rover Defender Sport: baby SUV will be boxy and electric

The new Land Rover Defender Sport will sit below the existing Defender in both size and price, and our exclusive image previews how it could look
News
23 Feb 2026
Electric cars vs winter: Audi A6, Mercedes CLA, Tesla Model Y, Kia EV4 and MG IM5 megatest
Winter range test - header

Electric cars vs winter: Audi A6, Mercedes CLA, Tesla Model Y, Kia EV4 and MG IM5 megatest

What does winter do to the capabilities of five long-range EVs? Our brutal 370-mile trip reveals everything - but did they all make it?
Features
23 Feb 2026
Are EVs really cheaper to run? Exclusive electric vs petrol running costs analysis
Are EVs really cheaper to run?

Are EVs really cheaper to run? Exclusive electric vs petrol running costs analysis

EVs have been sold primarily on their low running costs; we do the maths to see if the benefits are genuine
Features
24 Feb 2026

Find a car with the experts