Skip advert
Advertisement

The Government just made EVs and plug-in hybrids far less attractive

Mike Rutherford wonders why anybody would now buy a pure-EV or PHEV after the Government announced plans for a pay-per-mile scheme

Opinion - Kia EV4

The desperate, deranged and deeply depressing final week of November will go down as one of the worst and most controversial ever for Britain’s 42 million bruised and abused drivers, who are being messed around something rotten by the state.

Months (not years) ago, in Labour’s election manifesto, there was no mention, or even a subtle hint that – if elected – it would change the course of motoring history by dumping upon us a pay-per-mile road-toll regime.

Yet that’s what it’s just announced. Worse still, the British Government’s pay-per-mile (PPM) racket will apply everywhere: country lanes; village, town and city streets; A-roads; motorways; private land… you name it.

Advertisement - Article continues below

True, for the time being at least, the official word from our shaky, clueless leaders is that only drivers of electric cars and plug-in hybrids will have to pay per mile.

So the negatively game-changing offer to existing and future buyers or users of such cars today goes like this: First, be financially punished by paying comparatively high prices for your hi-tech EVs or PHEVs which, in turn, provide the Government with higher VAT receipts.

Second, pay through the nose again when using some public charging points where the prices are obscenely high (as are the profits enjoyed by HM Treasury after its greedy VAT fees are added to those extortionate basic prices that should be outlawed).

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement - Article continues below

Third, remember that by sticking with the EV or plug-in hybrid you already have, or by buying one in future, you will be entering the administrative and financial nightmare of Britain’s new, ill-thought-out PPM system. Normally, a major plus point when buying a new car and keeping it for only two or three years is that MoT centres can be avoided. But not for much longer, because new or nearly new EVs and plug-in hybrids will, as part of Labour’s PPM venture, need to be booked in so staff can verify mileages. How’s that for progress?

The Government couldn’t have done a better job of disincentivising pure EVs and plug-in hybrids if it tried. Plus the Chancellor has also hinted that regular, non-plug-in hybrids could be the next victims in her PPM shenanigans. If and when they are, only combustion-engined cars will be exempt from the curse of the PPM racket that nobody asked or voted for.

And at that point, countless consumers will understandably ask: “Why would we buy EVs or hybrids, suffering the hassle and expense of PPM charges, when we can drive cheaper-to-buy and cheaper-to-insure petrols or diesels that exempt us from all this PPM nonsense?”

It’s a fair question that the Chancellor needs to answer. And at the same time, she might like to explain why, when seeking election months ago, she forgot to mention she’d dump punitive road-toll fees on all EV and at least some hybrid drivers.

Shouldn’t there be a law against this sort of iffy, less-than-honest behaviour from out-of-their-depth politicians who don’t understand cars... or car people?

Did you know you can sell your car through Auto Express? We’ll help you get a great price and find a great deal on a new car, too.

Skip advert
Advertisement
Chief columnist

Mike was one of the founding fathers of Auto Express in 1988. He's been motoring editor on four tabloid newspapers - London Evening News, The Sun, News of the World & Daily Mirror. He was also a weekly columnist on the Daily Telegraph, The Independent and The Sunday Times. 

Find a car with the experts

Skip advert
Advertisement

Most Popular

BMW iX3 review
BMW iX3 50 xDrive - front

BMW iX3 review

A true quantum leap in car design and electric vehicle engineering, the iX3 really is that good
In-depth reviews
4 Dec 2025
New Nissan X-Trail to bring tough new look and e-Power tech in 2027
Nissan X-Trail - 'X-Trail' tailgate badge

New Nissan X-Trail to bring tough new look and e-Power tech in 2027

Critical new SUV will form the backbone of Nissan’s global renaissance, and it can’t come soon enough
News
5 Dec 2025
Electric car demand slows as Government grant fails to woo buyers
Ford Puma Gen-E - front action

Electric car demand slows as Government grant fails to woo buyers

EV sales rose only marginally in the run-up to the November Budget, compared with the same period last year
News
4 Dec 2025