All-Season Tyre Test: verdict and results by category

Tables show which all-season tyres performed well where, and how they compare

Verdict

Unusual conditions – with the snow testing much warmer than in previous years, and a wet track close to freezing – no doubt played a role in our scores, which saw tyres jumping up and down the results tables, with no one brand dominating.

Uniroyal brought up the rear, but still managed a couple of wins. Overall it is showing its age and needs updating. The Kleber was the tyre to have on snow, but couldn’t repeat that on other surfaces, as its CrossClimate stablemate does.

The next four tyres were very closely matched and a small change in weighting would likely see their positions swapped. 

Good progress has been made with the All Season SF 2 after a disappointing debut, and, although Hankook failed to deliver the snow performance we’ve seen before in this year’s conditions, it remains a sound choice. Firestone shone in key tests and is the one for high-mileage drivers.

There was another podium performance from the CrossClimate 2, which just needs a bit more wet grip, and Vredestein showed again its Quatrac is a real all-round choice.

Winner: Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen-3

The Gen-3 finally follows its predecessor with a test win and a performance ideally suited to the British climate, where snow is a rarity and the temperatures are relatively high. 

Results by category

Overall

1stGoodyear100%
2ndVredestein99.9%
3rdMichelin99.3%
4thFirestone99.2%
=5thHankook99%
=5thPirelli99%
7thKleber98.2%
8thUniroyal97.35

Price

1stFirestone£96.99
2ndVredestein£101.03
3rdUniroyal£101.26
4thKleber£102.64
5thHankook£104.59
6thGoodyear£119.54
7thPirelli£128.99
8thMichelin£128.99

Snow braking

1stVredestein100%
2ndKleber98.7%
3rdPirelli98.5%
=4thUniroyal97.4%
=4thGoodyear97.4%
6thMichelin97.1%
=7thFirestone95.6%
=7thHankook95.6%

Snow traction

1stMichelin100%
2ndPirelli99.7%
3rdKleber99.1%
4thGoodyear97.3%
5thFirestone95.5%
6thVredestein95.1%
7thHankook94.9%
8thUniroyal89.8%

Snow handling

1stKleber100%
2ndMichelin99.8%
3rdPirelli99.7%
4thGoodyear99.2%
5thHankook98.3%
6thVredestein98.2%
7thFirestone97.9%
8thUniroyal96.4%

Straight aquaplaning

1stPirelli100%
2ndKleber99.8%
3rdHankook99.4%
4thVredestein98.6%
5thMichelin98.5%
6thUniroyal97.8%
7thGoodyear97.3%
8thFirestone91.7%

Curved aquaplaning

1stUniroyal100%
2ndHankook99.1%
=3rdPirelli95.5%
=3rdVredestein99.5%
5thGoodyear92.1%
6thKleber91.6%
7thMichelin83.5%
8thFirestone71.6%

Wet braking

1stVredestein100%
2ndFirestone98.0%
3rdGoodyear97.2%
4thMichelin96.3%
5thUniroyal92.9%
6thHankook92.6%
7thPirelli90.5%
8thKleber88.2%

Wet handling

1stGoodyear100%
2ndHankook99.3%
3rdPirelli98.9%
3rdVredestein98.9%
5thFirestone98.8%
6thMichelin97.5%
7thUniroyal96.6%
8thKleber96.1%

Wet circle

1stGoodyear100%
2ndPirelli99.6%
3rdHankook99.1%
4thVredestein99.0%
5thFirestone98.0%
6thMichelin97.1%
7thKleber97.0%
8thUniroyal96.7%

Dry braking

1stMichelin100%
2ndKleber97.4%
3rdPirelli96.6%
4thHankook93.9%
5thVredestein93.1%
6thGoodyear89.5%
7thFirestone89.2%
8thUniroyal80.4%

Dry handling

1stGoodyear100%
2ndVredestein99.8%
=3rdHankook99.4%
=3rdPirelli99.4%
5thFirestone99.3%
6thMichelin99.1%
7thKleber99.0%
8thUniroyal97.4%

Rolling resistance

1stFirestone100%
2ndKleber97.4%
3rdMichelin97.1%
4thGoodyear93.7%
5thUniroyal91.7%
6thVredestein89.0%
7thPirelli88.7%
8thHankook87.8%

Cabin noise

1stUniroyal100%
2ndPirelli99.4%
3rdVredestein99.1%
4thGoodyear99.0%
5thMichelin98.8%
6thHankook98.5%
7thKleber98.3%
8thFirestone97.2%
Products editor

Kim has worked for Auto Express for more than three decades and all but a year of that time in the Products section. His current role as products editor involves managing the section’s content and team of testers plus doing some of the tests himself. 

Most Popular

New MG3 hopes to disrupt the Renault Clio and Vauxhall Corsa’s supermini dominance
MG3 on Geneva Motor Show stand - front
News

New MG3 hopes to disrupt the Renault Clio and Vauxhall Corsa’s supermini dominance

New MG3 features the company’s first full-hybrid powertrain; pricing to be announced in March
26 Feb 2024
New Renault 5 leaked: pictures surface online ahead of Monday's Geneva Motor Show reveal
renault 5 teaser
News

New Renault 5 leaked: pictures surface online ahead of Monday's Geneva Motor Show reveal

The long-awaited all-electric reboot of the iconic Renault 5 will be fully unveiled on 26 February 2024
24 Feb 2024
'Cheap SUVs are where the smart money's going in today's car market'
Opinion - Volkswagen T-Roc
Opinion

'Cheap SUVs are where the smart money's going in today's car market'

Mike Rutherford thinks sensibly priced SUVs are the natural successor to less spacious family hatchbacks
25 Feb 2024