Skip advert
Advertisement

It’s time for the VW Golf to die! The Polo already does its job and more

Mike Rutherford has been a big fan of the Volkswagen Golf in the past, but he questions the need for an all-new generation

Opinion - Volkswagen Golf

The Volkswagen Golf, Rubik’s Cube, New York’s Blondie and Francis Ford Coppola’s The Godfather Part II may seem like they have nothing in common. In fact, the opposite is true.

They were either launched, invented, formed or screened for the first time in the same momentous year: 1974. All rapidly earned and deserved ‘global gold standard’ status in their respective fields – the automotive, games, music and movie industries.

As of today and for not much cash (if seeking an old Golf or Cube) or zero money (in the case of Blondie on YouTube or Godfather II on Channel 4), you can still drive, play with, listen to or watch these historically significant, cream of the crop, product offerings.

Advertisement - Article continues below

But should brilliant, best-of-the-best gems born in ’74 continue to be reborn several times over in the subsequent 50-plus years? The first and second Godfather films in the early seventies were such iconic cinematic masterpieces that they could never be bettered, so that’s why the plug was pulled on the series after the underwhelming Godfather Part III.

With the Golf, things are very different. The game-changing, radical but raw Mk1 started at £1,294 when in UK showrooms in 1974. It’s been reborn and improved upon as a mid-sized (currently 4.2 metres-plus) hatchback so often since, that we’re now on the Mk8, priced from £29,430. Should there be another one within the next couple of years or so, as VW’s top brass have hinted? I don’t think so.

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement - Article continues below

For starters, Wolfsburg has lately lumbered itself with money, manpower and other major problems, including a needlessly bloated model range that rapidly needs fixing. Also, on a more positive note, this autumn it has launched a brilliant, state-of-the-art, pure-electric, just about mid-sized (4.0m-plus) five-seat hatchback. It’s badged and being formally sold from £23,945 as the ID. Polo.

As far as I’m concerned it is, in effect, the next Golf – complete with subtle exterior design, classy interior, impressive electric motor, great overall driving experience, surprisingly good people/load-lugging capabilities and much more. And it’s already won the ‘Best Car Under 25k Euros’ prize at Germany’s Golden Steering Wheel awards.   

As a serial buyer of Mk1 and other Golfs as my main car in the eighties and nineties, then Polos as second cars in the noughties and 2010s, I’ve often thought that our increasingly slow and congested road conditions mean the cheaper, slightly smaller Polo makes more sense than the modern-day Golf.

With all this in mind, VW has, accidentally or otherwise, already blessed itself with and started selling its ‘new Golf’ – which just happens to be called the ID. Polo. It’s all the car you’ll ever need. Just like old Golfs used to be.

Did you know you can sell your car through Auto Express? We’ll help you get a great price and find a great deal on a new car, too.

Skip advert
Advertisement
Chief columnist

Mike was one of the founding fathers of Auto Express in 1988. He's been motoring editor on four tabloid newspapers - London Evening News, The Sun, News of the World & Daily Mirror. He was also a weekly columnist on the Daily Telegraph, The Independent and The Sunday Times. 

Skip advert
Advertisement

Recommended

New VW ID. Polo GTI Clubsport Concept: wild EV previews future hot hatch
Volkswagen ID.Polo GTI Clubsport Concept - front

New VW ID. Polo GTI Clubsport Concept: wild EV previews future hot hatch

New concept provides big clue as to where VW might take its electric hot hatchback in the not-too-distant future
News
20 Nov 2026
Volkswagen ID. Polo review
Volkswagen ID. Polo - front tracking

Volkswagen ID. Polo review

Practical, well built and with decent driving dynamics, the ID. Polo feels like an electric equivalent to the ICE Polo in all the best ways
In-depth reviews
11 Nov 2026
Volkswagen Golf review
Volkswagen Golf - front tracking

Volkswagen Golf review

The Volkswagen Golf remains a solid choice in the compact hatchback market
In-depth reviews
11 Nov 2026
Best used hatchbacks to buy 2026
Best used hatchbacks - header image

Best used hatchbacks to buy 2026

Hatchbacks offer great practicality, low running costs and comfort, and these are the best used buys
Best cars & vans
6 Nov 2026

Most Popular

154 speed cameras deactivated after drivers are wrongly fined
HADECS3X cameras

154 speed cameras deactivated after drivers are wrongly fined

The Home Office has revoked type approval for HADECS3X cameras, in effect making them unusable for catching speeding drivers
News
18 Nov 2026
New Audi Q9 on sale with UK prices and specs revealed
Ellis Hyde with the Audi Q9

New Audi Q9 on sale with UK prices and specs revealed

Audi wanted its new luxury flagship to make a statement wherever it goes, and that it will
News
26 Aug 2026
New MG2 getting set to challenge VW ID. Polo in 2027
MG GO! - front 3/4 static

New MG2 getting set to challenge VW ID. Polo in 2027

New electric supermini previewed by the MG GO! concept in the summer will be revealed early in the New Year
News
20 Nov 2026

Find a car with the experts