Councils slash road budgets despite £165m increase in parking revenues
Councils’ net profit from parking has risen from £682m to £847m in five years while road budgets has fallen £400m in the same period
Local councils have seen a £165m rise in the net revenue generated by their parking operations over the last four years, yet have slashed spending on local roads by £400m over the same period.
Official figures show local authorities in England, Scotland and Wales made £847 million in net revenue from all forms of parking charges and fines in 2017/18, compared with £682 million in 2013/14. Adjusted for inflation, this represents a 10 per cent increase.
Yet the amount spent by councils on roads has decreased from £2.8 billion in 2013/14 to £2.4 billion in 2017/18. This equates to a 21 per cent decrease, again adjusted for inflation.
• Councils collect £42m from bus lane fines
The analysis, which comes from comparison website Confused.com, shows local authorities in 101 out of 176 areas have increased their net income from parking, 87 of which have simultaneously reduced their road spending.
Newport was the authority that increased its parking profits the most over four years – rising from £16,000 to £306,000 – followed by Leicester City and Havering.
| Authority | Net parking profit in 2013/14 | Net parking profit in 2017/18 | Percentage increase (adjusted for inflation) |
| Newport | £16,000 | £306,000 | 1,645.7 per cent |
| Leicester City | £631,000 | £3,658,000 | 429.2 per cent |
| Havering | £758,000 | £3,614,000 | 335.2 per cent |
| Wrexham | £-149,000 (cost of services exceeded revenue) | £301,000 | 284.4 per cent |
| Argyll & Bute | £69,000 | £274,000 | 262,5 per cent |
Another notable example is Westminster City Council, which made a £69 million net revenue from parking in 2017/18. Adjusted for inflation, this represents a 43 per cent increase from 2013/14’s figure of £44 million.
• Parking fees set to rocket as councils plug spending gaps
Some authorities did actually increase the amount they spent on road improvement over the last five years. Hackney Council did so the most, increasing its net roads spending from £7,422,000 in 2013/14 to £13,416,000 in 2017/18 – a 65 per cent increase, adjusted for inflation. However, this didn’t match the 83 per cent increase in its parking profits in the same period.
| Authority | Net roads spending in 2013/14 | Net roads spending in 2017/18 | Percentage increase (adjusted for inflation) |
| Hackney | £7,422,000 | £13,416,000 | 65.0 per cent |
| Hounslow | £10,049,000 | £17,342,000 | 57.5 per cent |
| Tower Hamlets | £2,753,000 | £4,559,000 | 51.2 per cent |
| East Renfrewshire | £7,051,000 | £9,925,000 | 28.5 per cent |
| North-East Lincolnshire | £6,481,000 | £8,315,000 | 17.1 per cent |
A separate poll of 2,000 motorists by Confused found 41 per cent of respondents had not noticed any improvements to the conditions of the roads in their area, with 37 per cent saying they are confused as to why more is not being done to improve road conditions.
Amanda Stretton, motoring editor at Confused.com, said: “While councils are justified in charging for parking and issuing fines for illegal parking, many motorists are confused about why this money isn’t being re-invested into our roads.”
Do you think more should be spent on our roads? Let us know your thoughts below...
Find a car with the experts
