Pay-monthly insurance costs drivers £100s

Exclusive statistics show that motorists are overpaying by up to 19 per cent on monthly payment car insurance vs a one-off annual premium

Insurance premium calendar

Over half of UK drivers are overpaying for their insurance by signing up to monthly instalments rather than making a single annual payment, an exclusive Auto Express investigation has revealed. 

Comparing premiums from various insurers, Auto Express found motorists who opt to pay for their policy on a monthly basis are charged 10 per cent more on average for the same cover, because insurers charge up to 19 per cent interest on monthly fees.

Car insurance: how to cut costs and get a great deal

Comparison site Gocompare.com claims 52 per cent of motorists opt to buy policies with payments split over 12 months. Buyers choosing even the cheapest policies can end up spending £50 more when paying this way, while those who select pricier premiums that bring perks like breakdown cover and courtesy car options were found to pay hundreds more over 12 months.

The findings come after the Association of British Insurers (ABI) said motor premiums have reached record high levels, with an average comprehensive policy costing £462. A spokeswoman for the ABI explained: “Customers paying for their car insurance in monthly instalments are effectively taking out a loan for the cost of the cover and paying it back over 12 months, which means they incur interest and generally pay a higher total bill.”

New VED road tax rules: the 2017 rules you need to know

But these interest rates can be as high as 19.2 per cent for some lenders, such as Endsleigh. And even the cheapest quote we received for our 42-year-old, 16-plate Ford Focus owner in Banbury, Oxon, included high interest fees. Aviva quoted us a 15.9 per cent variable interest rate, with 31.9 per cent APR. A spokeswoman from Aviva told us its APR charges range from 10.9 per cent to 39.9 per cent.

Matt Oliver, car insurance expert at Gocompare.com, advised motorists to consider other ways to pay for insurance rather than opting for monthly payments, including “paying for your insurance on a zero-per-cent purchase credit card”.

Why paying monthly doesn't add up

Insurer Annual quote Monthly totalDifference APR
Aviva£449£498.58£49.5831.90%
esure £513.93£563.11£49.1827.90%
Quotemehappy.com£548.68£600.88£52.2026.90%
Privilege£594£653.40£59.4028.20%
Direct Line£606£656£5022.50%
Churchill£608.30£669.20£60.9028.20%
LV=£645.55£703.63£58.0824.90%
More Than£673.91£725.60£51.6926.30%
Tesco Bank £1,139£1,258.03£119.0327.10%
AA£1,267£1,435£16826.90%
Endsleigh£1,397£1,643£24644.10%

Quotes for a 42-year old in Banbury, Oxon, driving a 16-reg Ford Focus

What do you think of our findings? Have you been charged a huge amount for your premium? Let us know below...

Recommended

Delayed trailer test law changes come into force
Mitsubishi L200 - tow
News

Delayed trailer test law changes come into force

You no longer need to take an extra test to tow a trailer, irrespective of when you passed your driving test
17 Dec 2021
Gridserve announces raft of new motorway electric car charging hubs
Gridserve Electric Forecourt 3
News

Gridserve announces raft of new motorway electric car charging hubs

Gridserve planning a total of 20 Electric Hubs and six Electric Forecourts, with 13 sites already under construction
9 Dec 2021
Stellantis plans huge revenues with new software-driven cars
Fiat 500 dash
News

Stellantis plans huge revenues with new software-driven cars

Stellantis says it’ll rake in more than €20 billion in annual revenues by 2030 thanks to its new technology and subscription services
7 Dec 2021
Company car tax guide 2021/2022: everything you need to know
Executive saloons make popular company cars
Consumer news

Company car tax guide 2021/2022: everything you need to know

Company car tax is bound up in a complex net of emissions, salaries and a car's value; we explain how the system looks for the 2021/22 Financial Year
26 Nov 2021

Most Popular

What are 4D number plates and are they legal?
Ross Hollis at perfectlyprintedplates.com
Tips & advice

What are 4D number plates and are they legal?

Everything you need to know about so-called ‘4D’ number plates, including whether you’re allowed to have them on your car
25 Jan 2022
Best electric cars to buy 2022
Best electric cars
Electric cars

Best electric cars to buy 2022

There are more electric cars than ever to choose from, so we've picked some of the best you can buy in the UK now
10 Jan 2022
New 2022 Lamborghini Countach LPI 800-4 hits the road for the first time
Lamborghini Countach - front
Lamborghini Countach

New 2022 Lamborghini Countach LPI 800-4 hits the road for the first time

Lamborghini’s reborn Countach pictured on the move ahead of it arriving with customers
25 Jan 2022