Councils plan “unfair” yellow box junction enforcement fines

An RAC investigation finds that 90 per cent of proposed box junction enforcement sites have issues

Box junction

Councils applying for new powers to enforce traffic offences at yellow box junctions risk fining drivers unfairly, with more than half of the proposed enforcement sites directly contravening government guidelines.

That’s the finding of the RAC motoring organisation, which commissioned chartered engineer Sam Wright to review all 111 of the current proposals from 27 councils. Wright, an expert formerly employed to manage yellow box design and approvals for Transport for London, found problems with 91 per cent of the yellow box sites proposed, while a shocking 61 per cent “directly contravene” existing government guidelines.

As a result of Wright’s research, the RAC is calling on the Department for Transport to carry out an urgent review of its guidelines to clarify “what is and what isn’t enforceable”.

“Enforcing yellow boxes means that the driver of a vehicle overhanging a box by any amount for just a moment can get a ticket,” said RAC spokesman Simon Williams. “Yet many drivers end up stopped or trapped in these junctions through no fault of their own. It is not only imperative, but a moral duty to ensure that fines are fair, justified and that the appeals’ process is consistent across the country.”

According to the organisation’s review of the 111 yellow boxes where councils have so far applied for powers to fine drivers, 40 have visibility issues, 16 are on the side of the road opposite T- junctions which the DFT says “serve no useful purpose”, 18 extend so far beyond junctions they are non-compliant, and 9 are in non-permitted locations.

Tellingly, Wright’s assessment of the visibility issues at many sites does not factor-in the poor condition of many yellow boxes, with painted lines worn away by years of traffic use.

 “While many boxes are barely visible at the moment due to a lack of maintenance, I chose to ignore this on the assumption that lines will be refreshed prior to enforcement,” the engineer said. “There are many changes needed to improve yellow box law and enforcement. However, as a minimum it is not unreasonable to expect that authorities should undertake comprehensive audits of boxes prior to enforcement to assess all issues.

According to Wright and the RAC, there’s no evidence that such audits are being carried out.

Click here for our guide on box junctions, including the rules and the penalties for breaking them...

Current affairs and features editor

Chris covers all aspects of motoring life for Auto Express. Over a long career he has contributed news and car reviews to brands such as Autocar, WhatCar?, PistonHeads, Goodwood and The Motor Trader.

Recommended

UK firm fitting ‘pop bang’ aftermarket exhausts fined in landmark court case
MINI Hatch exhaust
News

UK firm fitting ‘pop bang’ aftermarket exhausts fined in landmark court case

A successful court action against a workshop advertising and fitting non-standard exhaust parts is ‘a lesson for businesses’ from the DVSA
23 Nov 2023
Why is electric car insurance so expensive? EV vs ICE cost analysis
BMW iX3
News

Why is electric car insurance so expensive? EV vs ICE cost analysis

We look into claims that electric cars face higher insurance premiums than ICE equivalents
22 Nov 2023
No help for electric car buyers in Autumn budget statement
Parliament
News

No help for electric car buyers in Autumn budget statement

Chancellor resists calls from industry to fund EV purchase grants or reduce VAT on public charging
22 Nov 2023
What’s in the 2023 Autumn Statement for drivers? EV incentives, fuel duty or VAT on charging?
News

What’s in the 2023 Autumn Statement for drivers? EV incentives, fuel duty or VAT on charging?

We look at some of the options for chancellor Jeremy Hunt when he announces his plans on 22 November
21 Nov 2023

Most Popular

New Renault 5: price, specs, launch and on sale dates
Renault 5 EV concept at 2022 Goodwood Festival of Speed
News

New Renault 5: price, specs, launch and on sale dates

Renault’s reborn Renault 5 will start from €25,000 in Europe, suggesting a circa-£30k price in the UK. It's due on sale in the summer of 2024. Here's …
1 Dec 2023
New BMW X3 replacement to grow in size and feature a minimalist dash
BMW Neue Klasse SUV exclusive image - front
News

New BMW X3 replacement to grow in size and feature a minimalist dash

BMW’s first Neue Klasse electric SUV could carry the iX3 nameplate and our exclusive images preview how it might look
30 Nov 2023
New 2024 Dacia Duster: third generation of Europe’s best-selling SUV revealed
Dacia Duster - front
News

New 2024 Dacia Duster: third generation of Europe’s best-selling SUV revealed

Dacia has taken the wraps off the latest Duster, which arrives with a new look and fresh technology
29 Nov 2023