Skip advert
Advertisement

It’s essential to keep an open mind about EV vs ICE

Mike Rutherford believes that it's crucial to separate fact from fiction when it comes to motoring’s biggest debate

Opinion - EV vs ICE

I’m wary – sometimes deeply suspicious – of holier-than-thou ‘mythbuster’ articles and public information campaigns. Not least because they can, and quite frequently do, pose as many questions as they try to answer.   

Regardless of what side of the fence you’re on when it comes to emotionally charged matters such as bicycles vs motorised vehicles, Labour vs Tory, or meat-eating vs vegetarianism, please proceed, look, listen and learn with caution – while chucking a large dollop of cynicism and a sprinkling of humour into the mix. For example, my years of listening and learning have convinced me that meat is murder, but vegetables are justifiable homicide. Fair enough?   

Advertisement - Article continues below

But when it comes to motoring’s biggest debate – EV vs ICE – it’s essential to keep an open mind about what, exactly, is myth, truth or half-truth, come to that. 

Yes, it’s true (because the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders formally says so) that in winter 2024, the average range of a new electric car is 236 miles. But it’s even more truthful (and helpful) to point out – as I’m doing now – that this is a hypothetical figure. 

In real-world conditions, you’re unlikely to achieve those 236 miles on one charge – especially right now, in the coldest season. This isn’t me being anti-EV. It’s me as a tester of countless electric vans, cars and other models since the eighties, and a genuine fan of EVs today, telling you the following: if you plan to drive from, say, central Birmingham to central London, roughly 118 miles each way, in a typical new electric car that happens to be blessed with the average EV range figure this holiday season, then you must work on the assumption that you’ll need to find a charging point en route. And a friendly warning from someone who has, in the past, been badly bitten by EVs that fell well short of their expected mileage promises has to be a good thing, right? 

Better still is an extensive, brutally honest and surprisingly well balanced list of EV pros and cons from a huge, multi-brand manufacturer of pure-electric cars. I’m talking about the Volkswagen Group, which has just had the corporate balls to tell it like it is in respect of buying, leasing, charging, driving and all aspects of life with pure EVs – be they Audis, Cupras, Porsches, SEATs, Skodas, VWs or brands beyond its vast stable.

This, it has done via its in-house, free-of-charge, easily accessible and proudly independent Enter Electric! consumer guide, which tells it exactly like it is, to help customers decide. 

Sure, the Volkswagen Group is all about selling more EVs. But it’s also keen to inform and educate better. You might expect the guide to be biased but, thankfully, it’s not. A bit like Auto Express, I can’t recommend Enter Electric! highly enough.

Moving over to the world of EVs? These are the best electric cars...

Skip advert
Advertisement
Chief columnist

Mike was one of the founding fathers of Auto Express in 1988. He's been motoring editor on four tabloid newspapers - London Evening News, The Sun, News of the World & Daily Mirror. He was also a weekly columnist on the Daily Telegraph, The Independent and The Sunday Times. 

Find a car with the experts

Skip advert
Advertisement

Most Popular

Chinese cars can’t match their European rivals when it comes to engineering
Opinion - Shanghai Auto Show

Chinese cars can’t match their European rivals when it comes to engineering

This new brand of cars might have battery tech on their side, but European buyers want much more than that
Opinion
25 Apr 2025
Leapmotor B05 family hatch on route to the UK with sub-£30k price and 400-mile range
Leapmotor badge

Leapmotor B05 family hatch on route to the UK with sub-£30k price and 400-mile range

The Stellantis-backed brand will launch a Volkswagen ID.3-rivalling small car with almost 20 per cent more range
News
23 Apr 2025
Buying a modern used car for under £10k is almost impossible
Opinion - £10k used cars

Buying a modern used car for under £10k is almost impossible

Phil McNamara discovers that it’s harder than ever to find a good-value car at the affordable end of the market
Opinion
24 Apr 2025