Skip advert
Advertisement

'Buick is dependable in the US - so why can't Brits buy them?'

US reliability reports say Buick is the most reliable brand across the pond; Mike Rutherford asks why they aren't in the UK...

Here at Auto Express we’re healthily obsessed with car reliability. We know – because our latest Driver Power survey tells us – that Lexus, Toyota, Honda, Subaru and Mazda (in that order) are world-beaters.

In a similar but entirely separate survey just conducted by our friends at Consumer Reports (CR) in New York, drivers in America pretty much concur with their Brit counterparts. In 2015, they placed Lexus and Toyota at the top of the pile (as did you), followed by Audi, Mazda and Subaru, then Honda just outside the top five.

Advertisement - Article continues below

We already know these Japanese giants wipe the floor with their rivals in Britain. But now it can be unequivocally confirmed that Japanese brands rule the reliability roost across countries and continents. 

Driver Power: best cars to own in 2015

Intriguingly, Americans and Brits can’t agree on Audi, which is a reliability champ over there but, sadly, not here. Unfortunately, we do agree that Nissan is the worst of the big Japanese firms and more like a reliability chump than champ these days. Even more worrying is that its Infiniti brand languishes fifth from bottom of the CR reliability league table, just below the Chrysler and Dodge brands, but above Cadillac, Ram, Jeep and, in last place, Fiat.

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement - Article continues below

Seems Nissan owners in the States have been suffering transmission problems. Meanwhile, the Infiniti Q50 is reportedly plagued by an array of teething troubles with its new electronic gearing and computers. Other Infiniti models are said to be tormented by gearbox issues. Let’s hope such faults won’t blight Sunderland-built Nissans and Infinitis.

New Infiniti Q30 2015 review

CR also has damning evidence that says the BMW 5 Series and X5, Chevrolet Corvette, Hyundai Santa Fe, Kia Rio and Tesla Model S are all “models with declining reliability”. It’s scathing of some cheap Fords with “reliability headaches”, plus describes some expensive Mercedes models as “least-reliable” in class. Ouch!

On a more positive note, Buick is now the most dependable US brand by far, impressively sitting in seventh place in the CR reliability rankings. These cars are well priced and currently blessed with discounts of up to $6,000 (just under £4,000). They look good and, evidently, they are good. So why has America spent decades trying – and spectacularly failing – to flog iffy Cadillacs, Chevrolets and Chryslers in Britain when it could and should have been sending over and selling us far superior Buicks?

Do you agree with Mike? Should General Motors ship over their Buick range to the UK? Let us know below...

Skip advert
Advertisement
Chief columnist

Mike was one of the founding fathers of Auto Express in 1988. He's been motoring editor on four tabloid newspapers - London Evening News, The Sun, News of the World & Daily Mirror. He was also a weekly columnist on the Daily Telegraph, The Independent and The Sunday Times. 

Find a car with the experts

Skip advert
Advertisement

Recommended

New 615bhp Cadillac Lyriq-V electric SUV wants to show the BMW iX who’s boss
2026 Cadillac Lyriq-V - front 3/4 studio

New 615bhp Cadillac Lyriq-V electric SUV wants to show the BMW iX who’s boss

The Lyriq-V can sprint from 0-60mph in 3.3 seconds, making it the quickest Cadillac ever produced
News
23 Jan 2025
New Cadillac Lyriq UK pricing leaked online, and it’ll be more expensive than a BMW iX
Cadillac Lyriq - front tracking

New Cadillac Lyriq UK pricing leaked online, and it’ll be more expensive than a BMW iX

Prices for the luxury electric SUV will apparently start from £75,000, and it’ll offer 329 miles of range
News
11 Dec 2024
Monterey Car Week 2024: full show round-up and all the exclusive, luxury and performance cars
Pebble Beach Tour d'Elegance

Monterey Car Week 2024: full show round-up and all the exclusive, luxury and performance cars

Some of the most iconic car brands lined up to unveil new metal in Monterey
News
20 Aug 2024
Cadillac Sollei Concept harks back to glamorous ‘50s land yacht cabriolets
Cadillac Sollei concept - front static

Cadillac Sollei Concept harks back to glamorous ‘50s land yacht cabriolets

Large and luxurious four-seat convertibles were once at the heart of Cadillac’s eccentric image, something this new concept might just recreate
News
22 Jul 2024

Most Popular

Chinese cars can’t match their European rivals when it comes to engineering
Opinion - Shanghai Auto Show

Chinese cars can’t match their European rivals when it comes to engineering

This new brand of cars might have battery tech on their side, but European buyers want much more than that
Opinion
25 Apr 2025
New electric car MoT tests could be coming to the UK
Tesla Model X on two-post inspection ramp

New electric car MoT tests could be coming to the UK

New technology and driver assistance systems require changes to annual testing, says EC
News
25 Apr 2025
Buying a modern used car for under £10k is almost impossible
Opinion - £10k used cars

Buying a modern used car for under £10k is almost impossible

Phil McNamara discovers that it’s harder than ever to find a good-value car at the affordable end of the market
Opinion
24 Apr 2025