UK speeding fine appeals are a postcode lottery

We exclusively reveal regional variations in the chances of a speeding ticket U-turn

Worst speeders in England and Wales revealed

Drivers caught by speed cameras in London or Northamptonshire are more than twice as likely to have their fine overturned than the UK average, according to exclusive Auto Express research.

More than 7.6 million tickets have been issued by forces since 2011, with 8.4 per cent of drivers successfully cancelling the fine.

Careless cops do £400k of damage misfuelling police cars

Our Freedom of Information request revealed 1.6 million tickets were issued in 2015 – the highest in the last five years. But it was also the least successful for appeals, with just 7.6 per cent overturned. In 2014, drivers had a success rate of 9.2 per cent.

Motorists caught by the Metropolitan Police are most likely to dodge points and a fine, with nearly one in five tickets cancelled.

Yet those flashed by Sussex Police stand just a 0.4 per cent chance of escaping a penalty. Neil Greig, director of policy and research at IAM RoadSmart, said: “We’d like to see no speeding tickets overturned, as it can send the message exceeding the limit is something that you can get away with. 

Half of hit and run drivers claim ignorance after fleeing the scene

“However, there will always be a small number of exceptions, where registration numbers are misidentified, ownership is in question, drivers can prove they were elsewhere or foreign vehicles are involved.

“Variations between forces are a matter of concern and we’d welcome more transparency. No safety camera partnership should want a reputation as an area where a speeding ticket is worth challenging.”

Areas with highest and lowest rates for overturning fines from 2011-2015

Top 5Bottom 5
Met Police 17.4%  Sussex 0.4%  
Northants 16.8%Cleveland 1.3%
Gtr Manchester 13.6%Durham 2.1%
Merseyside 11.0%Cumbria 3.9%
Leicestershire 9.9%Norfolk 4.8%

What do you think about the research? Have you had a successful speeding fine appeal? Let us know in the comments!

Recommended

Coroner calls for smart motorway review following M1 deaths
smart motorway
News

Coroner calls for smart motorway review following M1 deaths

The deaths of two men in a smart motorway collision could have been avoided if there had been a hard shoulder, coroner rules
19 Jan 2021
Councils to get new powers to issue fines for traffic offences
Box junction
Consumer news

Councils to get new powers to issue fines for traffic offences

Local authorities will be able to fine drivers who commit moving traffic contraventions under legislation being drawn up
18 Jan 2021
UK drivers to escape EU speed camera fines due to Brexit
Citroen DS Eiffel Tower
Consumer news

UK drivers to escape EU speed camera fines due to Brexit

UK’s departure from the European Union puts an end to cross-border directive, leaving EU countries unable to enforce speeding penalties for drivers ca…
13 Jan 2021
Driverless car users may not be liable in accidents
Jaguar Land Rover autonomous testing - static
Consumer news

Driverless car users may not be liable in accidents

Law Commission proposes motorists in driverless cars should be renamed “users in charge” as part of “no-blame culture”
18 Dec 2020

Most Popular

UK’s most stolen cars revealed
Most stolen car
Ford Fiesta

UK’s most stolen cars revealed

DVLA data reveals which cars were most commonly stolen in 2020, with the Ford Fiesta topping the list
26 Jan 2021
Revised Mazda CX-5 crossover launched for 2021
Mazda CX-5 2021
Mazda CX-5

Revised Mazda CX-5 crossover launched for 2021

The updated Mazda CX-5 gets a larger displacement version of the brand’s SkyActiv-G petrol engine and a fresh infotainment system
26 Jan 2021
New MINI facelift revealed with updated look and added tech
MINI 3-door hatch facelift - front
MINI MINI

New MINI facelift revealed with updated look and added tech

The MINI range has been revised for 2021, with the hatch, Convertible and Electric models all getting a range of styling tweaks
26 Jan 2021