Skip advert
Advertisement

Will politicians never learn? Subsidised trains are for the few, while unsubsidised cars are for the many

Mike Rutherford wonders why those in control of the UK continue to punish the motorist

Opinion - Rachel Reeves

So how well, or badly, have the car industry’s main players performed over the past 15 years?

The car-manufacturing business has undoubtedly raised its game, survived and thrived, but brands must acknowledge that their inflation-busting retail price hikes are a huge mistake. The design, quality, safety, diversity and desirability of the product has been beyond expectations. As for car users: they’ve more than done their bit as they’ve bought and insured their vehicles before coughing up additional billions in taxes, fines and fees like never before. 

The other big beasts in the car game are clueless politicians, shamelessly deriving higher profits – for starters, 20 per cent VAT – from the car industry than manufacturers or dealers. They’re cynically discriminating against and picking the pockets of easy-target, defenceless motorists. What happened to zero tolerance on bullying? 

Advertisement - Article continues below

All those worthy sentiments about fairness, being kind, freedom of movement, opportunity, mobility and equality are flushed down the toilet if blokes and women, boys and girls happen to use cars to get to work, school, shops, church, charity events or holiday destinations. How dare they work hard, then pay what’s left of their taxed wages or pensions to purchase cars that bring 24/7 self-reliance to themselves and their loved ones while at the same time bringing the Government lovely-jubbly, money-for-nothing tax revenue. Apart from VAT, there’s fuel, insurance, parking and other punishing taxes; road, bridge and tunnel tolls; the congestion (even if there is none) charge; ‘ultra-low-emission’ swindles and countless other creative, state-sponsored charges, fees, fines, costs and legalised cons, schemes and scams mainly for profit-making purposes.

By driving their personal mobility machines on, through or over roads, tunnels or bridges they effectively own (because their car-related taxes have already paid for them several times over), motorists are propping up the UK economy. They’re refusing to burden it and the state’s heavily subsidised public transport ‘system’, which can barely cope with the passengers it currently has, never mind millions more if and when we’re bludgeoned/priced off the road and on to rail. At that point, not only does the economy collapse, but the railways also buckle. The country grinds to a halt.

By the time you read this, you’ll have just heard the new Chancellor’s Budget speech. I’m ready to stand corrected, but I’m predicting she’ll be anti-car/car user and pro-public transport. 

Will they (Labour), like the two governments before it (Conservative and Con-Lib Coalition), never learn? Trains are for the few who demand to be steered by others. Cars are for the many who prefer to steer themselves.

Mike's column was written before the Budget was announced...

Skip advert
Advertisement
Chief columnist

Mike was one of the founding fathers of Auto Express in 1988. He's been motoring editor on four tabloid newspapers - London Evening News, The Sun, News of the World & Daily Mirror. He was also a weekly columnist on the Daily Telegraph, The Independent and The Sunday Times. 

Skip advert
Advertisement

Recommended

The VW Group needs SEAT, so killing it would be madness!
Rutherford on SEAT

The VW Group needs SEAT, so killing it would be madness!

Mike Rutherford believes that SEAT should become the group’s budget brand while Skoda and Cupra move further upmarket
Opinion
27 Sep 2026
Best all-season tyres 2026: top tyres tested and reviewed
All Season tyre test - Volkswagen Golf front cornering

Best all-season tyres 2026: top tyres tested and reviewed

Only after visiting two test facilities and using lots of hi-tech kit could our team name the winning tyre from our eight contenders
Product group tests
25 Sep 2026
Fancy a cheap used EV? The data says you'd better be quick
Opinion - cheap used EVs

Fancy a cheap used EV? The data says you'd better be quick

A used EV has never had more appeal as the cost of petrol and diesel heads for £2 per litre, says our news editor. But prices are rising, so you’ll ne…
Opinion
24 Sep 2026
Best new cars coming soon: all the big new car launches due in 2026, 2027 and beyond
Best new cars coming soon 30/06/26

Best new cars coming soon: all the big new car launches due in 2026, 2027 and beyond

Here are the most important new cars from Alfa Romeo, Audi, BMW, Dacia, Ferrari, Ford, Skoda and more
Best cars & vans
21 Sep 2026

Most Popular

Radical new Citroen C4 Picasso to make MPVs cool again
Citroen C4 Picasso - exclusive image

Radical new Citroen C4 Picasso to make MPVs cool again

Citroen is going back to what it does best: new ELO-inspired MPV could spawn family of family-friendly models
News
28 Sep 2026
New BMW iX3 40 M Sport 2026 review: entry-level SUV isn't a compromise
New BMW iX3 40 M Sport - front tracking

New BMW iX3 40 M Sport 2026 review: entry-level SUV isn't a compromise

Practical, efficient and much cheaper than the xDrive50, we think the base-level BMW iX3 40 is the pick-of-the-range.
Road tests
24 Sep 2026
Rarest cars in the UK - one-off unicorns you’ll never see on the road… probably
Rarest cars in the UK

Rarest cars in the UK - one-off unicorns you’ll never see on the road… probably

With only one example of each of these cars registered for road use in the UK, it doesn’t get any rarer than this
Best cars & vans
26 Sep 2026

Find a car with the experts