Skip advert
Advertisement

Stricter plug-in hybrid emissions tests are the answer to a question no-one asked

Editor Paul Barker takes a closer look at plug-in hybrids and wonders if the new stricter tests will actually work

Opinion - PHEVs

Plug-in hybrid technology has always been something of an outlier. It’s not a powertrain anyone gets passionately worked up about – but everything about PHEVs seems to pull in opposite directions.

The tech is seen by some as a great bridge to going full electric, getting used to charging and understanding how frequently you do longer trips, but with a petrol engine removing any of the anxiety some attach to public top-ups.

But for others it’s the answer to a question no-one asked. If the majority of your journeys are short enough to run largely on a battery, then a full electric car is perfectly usable. And if you’re doing a lot of long journeys, then lugging the heavy batteries around may result in worse economy than you could get with a modern petrol engine. What is sure is that PHEVs only make real sense if you can charge at home, or cheaply at work.

Advertisement - Article continues below

The news that new PHEVs launched this year will face stricter tests that will significantly bump up their emissions ratings is interesting, in part because it doesn’t really solve anything. There have been lots of complaints about 200mpg-plus official figures on plug-ins, but ever since the first PHEVs arrived, there’s not been a type of car where its economy is so affected by usage.

Depending how you drive a petrol car, there may be a variance of 10mpg. Likewise, 0.5 miles per kWh on an EV. But with the best plug-ins now doing well over 60 miles on a charge, it’s easy to see drivers fuelling every two months despite covering large distances. When I’ve run PHEVs, in some months I’ve achieved more than 150mpg, and in others the figure has fallen below 40mpg if I regularly went beyond the battery’s range and ignited the petrol engine.

These new tests, in which PHEVs complete a 1,367-mile cycle rather than the previous 497-mile assessment, mean the battery will contribute a lesser amount, naturally cutting the efficiency and increasing emissions. This may be more realistic for some, but it will also create short-term uncertainty, bump up VED bills and dissuade company car drivers in particular from moving to this halfway-house tech on the road to a full EV – while still not revealing what an individual driver can expect to achieve, because everyone uses their car in a different way.

Do you agree with Paul? Let us know your thoughts in the comments section...

Skip advert
Advertisement

As Editor, Paul’s job is to steer the talented group of people that work across Auto Express and Driving Electric, and steer the titles to even bigger and better things by bringing the latest important stories to our readers. Paul has been writing about cars and the car industry since 2000, working for consumer and business magazines as well as freelancing for national newspapers, industry titles and a host of major publications.

Find a car with the experts

Skip advert
Advertisement

Recommended

Hot new car products: the latest and greatest kit for your car
Osram Night Breaker 220

Hot new car products: the latest and greatest kit for your car

The latest additions to the world of automotive products from floor mats to dash cams...
Product reviews
12 May 2025
Diesel isn’t always a dirty word
Opinion - diesel

Diesel isn’t always a dirty word

Jordan Katsianis explains why he thinks we don’t all have to buy petrol cars or EVs. There is another way that makes real sense for some buyers
Opinion
8 May 2025
Citroen Ami Buggy sales on ice because of the UK’s weather
Citroen Ami Buggy - front static

Citroen Ami Buggy sales on ice because of the UK’s weather

French firm’s UK boss explains why funkiest version of electric quadricycle isn’t coming here… yet
News
2 May 2025
Car wheels are simply getting too big
Opinion - wheel sizes

Car wheels are simply getting too big

Tom Jervis gives his expert insight on why big wheels aren’t always a big deal
Opinion
1 May 2025

Most Popular

Car Deal of the Day: Sacre bleu! The Renault 5 keeps getting cheaper
Renault 5 - front full width

Car Deal of the Day: Sacre bleu! The Renault 5 keeps getting cheaper

The modern-day Super Cinq comes with a super price. It’s our Deal of the Day for 14 May
News
14 May 2025
Want a new small car? You probably can’t afford one and car bosses blame the EU
Luca de Meo - Renault 5

Want a new small car? You probably can’t afford one and car bosses blame the EU

Renault and Stellantis bosses demand changes to the emissions rules driving up new car prices
News
15 May 2025
Best electric cars 2025: the top 10 best EVs you can buy
Best electric cars header

Best electric cars 2025: the top 10 best EVs you can buy

Thinking about making the switch to an electric vehicle? Here are the EVs that should be on your shortlist, and why…
Best cars & vans
14 May 2025