Skip advert
Advertisement

Plug-in hybrid cars are essentially pointless and in 2025 it’s high time we all accepted that

Alex Ingram explains why he believes that PHEVs aren't all they're cracked up to be

Opinion - PHEVs

I’m a big advocate of electric cars, especially if they’re small and energy efficient. I am also a petrolhead, so I hope that the cars enthusiasts love can continue to live on through more sustainable fuels. 

But try as I might, whether I’m looking at them from a financial point of view or an environmental one, I can’t see the point of plug-in hybrids. Having driven almost all of the new options on sale today, I know that without religious battery charging, they just become overweight, thirsty internal combustion-enginged cars. 

Advertisement - Article continues below

We’ve found this out first-hand on many occasions; an Alfa Romeo Tonale PHEV we ran on our long-term fleet averaged just 35.3mpg over the course of roughly 4,500 miles, and we struggled to get 30mpg out of a Range Rover Evoque PHEV once its battery energy depleted.

In-depth research suggests that many plug-in drivers don’t charge up their cars as often as they could, either. A study by the European Commission on real-world fuel consumption and emissions data covering 623,861 post-2021 petrol, diesel and hybrid vehicles showed that petrol PHEVs’ CO2 emissions were a staggering 238 per cent higher in everyday driving than the official WLTP data. Diesel PHEVs were even worse, at 312 per cent over. 

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement - Article continues below

While petrol and diesel cars also didn’t live up to their WLTP numbers, they came significantly closer, being on average 21.2 per cent less efficient than the claimed figures. 

So not only are PHEVs creating more emissions than official figures state, but that also means that the customer is spending far more money on fuel if they forget to plug the car in regularly – or simply cover journeys that exceed the car’s electric range. The discrepancy in the numbers above is so bad that the European Commission intends to revise how PHEV emissions are assessed from 2025 onwards.

Advertisement - Article continues below

All of this shows that having a home charger is absolutely vital to get the most out of a PHEV. But if a home charger is readily available, then why not just get a fully electric car instead? And if home charging isn’t possible, then regular internal combustion-engined cars (and even mild and full hybrids) are much cheaper than PHEVs to buy up front, and it’s unlikely you’ll be able to recoup the difference in cost in fuel savings any time soon. 

I also want to make it clear that I’m not bashing mild and full hybrids here; they use far smaller and lighter battery packs to achieve figures that aren’t far shy of PHEVs in the real world. 

Of course there are one or two very special plug-in hybrid exceptions. The new Toyota Prius is stunningly efficient even when its battery charge has run its course, while the McLaren Artura Spider is a game-changing supercar. But even in the case of the latter, the Artura’s electrification enhances the car’s performance more than it tries to trim pennies from its fuel bills.

On the whole, I hope that those in power will soon see most PHEVs for the worst-of-both-worlds compromise that they are and remove any incentives as soon as possible. If they really saw sense, I’d like to see governments incentivise only small EVs and, to a lesser extent, compact petrol cars. But I fear that amount of common sense is wishful thinking.

Should PHEVs face the axe? Tell us your opinion in the comments section below...

Skip advert
Advertisement
Chief reviewer

Alex joined Auto Express as staff writer in early 2018, helping out with news, drives, features, and the occasional sports report. His current role of Chief reviewer sees him head up our road test team, which gives readers the full lowdown on our comparison tests.

Skip advert
Advertisement

Recommended

Annoying car safety tech is a big 'turn-off' that must be stopped, says Euro NCAP
Euro NCAP representative Matthew Avery standing in between a BMW iX3 and Tesla Model Y

Annoying car safety tech is a big 'turn-off' that must be stopped, says Euro NCAP

Advanced Driver Assistance is critical but flawed. Euro NCAP’s Matthew Avery vows to make it better
Features
21 Nov 2026
Future of car safety: smart seatbelts, robotaxis and bringing back buttons
BMW iX3 and Tesla Model Y

Future of car safety: smart seatbelts, robotaxis and bringing back buttons

Physical buttons and driverless taxis are on Euro NCAP’s to-do list, as Matthew Avery's crystal ball-gazes all the way to 2035
Features
20 Nov 2026
New Audi A3: posh hatch won’t go EV but will get stunning design
Audi A3 render (watermarked) - front

New Audi A3: posh hatch won’t go EV but will get stunning design

There’s a new Audi A3 on the way and our exclusive images preview how the hatchback could look
News
17 Nov 2026
All-new Porsche Macan-size SUV to get its own name and petrol power, maybe a V8
New Porsche V8 SUV frontquarter Avarvarii

All-new Porsche Macan-size SUV to get its own name and petrol power, maybe a V8

We reveal how Porsche is developing a new mid-size ICE SUV to sit alongside the electric Macan in the brand’s future line-up
News
16 Nov 2026

Most Popular

154 speed cameras deactivated after drivers are wrongly fined
HADECS3X cameras

154 speed cameras deactivated after drivers are wrongly fined

The Home Office has revoked type approval for HADECS3X cameras, in effect making them unusable for catching speeding drivers
News
18 Nov 2026
New Audi Q9 on sale with UK prices and specs revealed
Ellis Hyde with the Audi Q9

New Audi Q9 on sale with UK prices and specs revealed

Audi wanted its new luxury flagship to make a statement wherever it goes, and that it will
News
26 Aug 2026
New MG2 getting set to challenge VW ID. Polo in 2027
MG GO! - front 3/4 static

New MG2 getting set to challenge VW ID. Polo in 2027

New electric supermini previewed by the MG GO! concept in the summer will be revealed early in the New Year
News
20 Nov 2026

Find a car with the experts