VW Polo GTI vs SEAT Ibiza Cupra and Skoda Fabia vRS

They’re effectively the same car but with different looks and price tags. But which is best; the VW, SEAT or Skoda?

VW Polo GTI vs SEAT Ibiza Cupra and Skoda Fabia vRS

The Volkswagen Polo GTI is a very impressive car. It can do fast and furious but will also do comfy and relaxing if you like. Really, it’s just like a Golf GTI in miniature.  However, for a supermini hot hatch it does feel a little bit too sensible. As a driver’s machine it’s not as playful or as fun as a MINI Cooper S or Renaultsport Clio Cup. Plus, being priced over £18,000 makes it rather expensive. 

However, there are some cheaper alternatives, which on paper at least are almost identical. 

The SEAT IBIZA Cupra is a grand less than the Polo, while the Skoda Fabia vRS is a further fifteen hundred quid cheaper still. Yet all three cars share the same engine, gearbox and chassis. Effectively underneath their skins they are the same car apart from a few mechanical tweaks here and there.

So then, how do they compare. Let’s start with the Ibiza. 

While not as upmarket inside as the Volkswagen, the Cupra’s cabin is still well screwed together with a definite sporty air to the proceedings.

Design wise – it’s the most flamboyant of the trio, and this, plus the fact it’s only available as a three door, suggests the Cupra is aimed at a younger audience than the Polo GTI. 

You get the same impression from the driving experience. The SEAT’s suspension is slightly firmer, which makes you think it can go to go round corners quicker. In reality though, there’s no discernable improvement in handling, certainly not enough to warrant the loss in comfort anyway. What’s more the Ibiza Cupra seems to have less front-end grip than its Volkswagen brethren.

As for the Skoda Fabia vRS? There’s more roll through corners, the steering is the most vague of the lot and it fidgets about a bit on rough surfaces. But all this makes it seem the least serious of the three, and ultimately the more fun.

Sadly, for a hot hatch, it’s not particularly exciting to look at. And the only alternative to the boxy five-door model is an even more sensible estate. 

Inside, the Fabia is a bit unadventurous too. Only the vRS sports seats really hint at the potential. 

For some people, though, the stealth effect is half of the appeal. The other half, of course, is good old-fashioned value for money.  

So then what have we learned? Well, the VW is all about desirability while the SEAT focuses on emotion. The Skoda, on the other hand is all about delivering the best ratio of performance per pound spent.

And, after all, isn’t that what hot hatches are supposed to be all about.

Recommended

Used Volkswagen Polo (Mk6, 2018-date) review
Volkswagen Polo Mk6
Volkswagen Polo Hatchback

Used Volkswagen Polo (Mk6, 2018-date) review

A used buyer's guide focusing on the Volkswagen Polo Mk6 (2018-date)
28 Dec 2021
Used Volkswagen Polo (Mk5, 2009-2017) review
Used Volkswagen Polo Mk5 - front
Volkswagen Polo Hatchback

Used Volkswagen Polo (Mk5, 2009-2017) review

The ageing Volkswagen Polo is still a front-runner in the supermini class, but rivals are cheaper
25 Nov 2021
Volkswagen Polo review
Volkswagen Polo - front
Volkswagen Polo

Volkswagen Polo review

The Volkswagen Polo is an impressively capable supermini that offers big-car features, although it is a little pricey compared to rivals
23 Nov 2021
New Volkswagen Polo 2021 review
Volkswagen Polo - front
Volkswagen Polo Hatchback

New Volkswagen Polo 2021 review

The facelifted Volkswagen Polo supermini channels even more Golf DNA
5 Nov 2021

Most Popular

Top 10 best hybrid cars to buy 2022
Best hybrid cars - header image
Hybrid cars

Top 10 best hybrid cars to buy 2022

Hybrid power is the way forward if the car industry is to be believed so we've found the top 10 best hybrid cars to buy now...
2 Jan 2022
Volkswagen teases upcoming high performance Golf
Volkswagen Golf GTI 2022
News

Volkswagen teases upcoming high performance Golf

A more sporting Volkswagen Golf is in the works, and could sit above the GTI Clubsport and R as a hardcore special
17 Jan 2022
New 2022 Citroen C5 X: UK prices and specs revealed
Citroen C5 X - front
Citroen C5

New 2022 Citroen C5 X: UK prices and specs revealed

Petrol and plug-in hybrid power offered with new Citroen C5 X, and a premium-brand-beating price
17 Jan 2022