"There are countless lies surrounding the real-world capabilities of diesel, petrol and electric cars"

Mike Rutherford calls for the UK to set up its own independent testing agency to give consumers real-world mpg and emissions figures

Opinion: real world mpg testing

I always have, and probably always will, like Volkswagens. As a 17-year-old, my first car was an air-cooled Beetle. Over the past three decades I’ve driven over 100 VW-badged production cars and prototypes. Today, my modest car collection includes three VWs – one new, one old, one ancient. 

Despite my fondness for the brand, in Auto Express magazine in March 2014 I warned of serious problems with the MPG/emissions/range claims of some Volkswagen vehicles – particularly diesels. I reported that on a gentle, traffic-free, daytime run to Geneva in perfect conditions and in one hit (i.e. no cold engine drawbacks), the Golf 1.6 I was driving drank 30 per cent more derv than it should have, according to official figures. 

For obvious reasons I blamed the manufacturer. But I also pointed the finger of accusation at lazy legislators. It’s these couldn’t-give-a-toss politicians and idle prosecutors who’ve turned a blind eye and enabled Volkswagen, plus other manufacturers, to short-change consumers. 

Advertisement - Article continues below

• VW emissions scandal: latest news on the 'dieselgate' recalls

Advertisement - Article continues below

With this in mind, my question was: “Shouldn’t there be a law against this sort of thing?” After all, fictitious fuel consumption figures inevitably result in greater-than-predicted expenditure on fuel, higher-than-promised levels of emissions and lower-than-claimed driving distances per tank of diesel... or petrol. 

What we’re talking about here is not just a VW problem. It is, on a global scale, an industry problem. There are countless fiddles and lies surrounding the real-world capabilities of diesel, petrol and 100 per cent-electric cars... plus taxis, vans, trucks, coaches, buses, motorcycles.  

Most economical cars

With all this in mind, let’s tear up the current, tired, flawed and discredited ‘system’ of testing vehicle MPG/emissions/range. And let’s replace it with one that allows UK PLC to recruit trained, accredited, wholly independent senior engineers who’d carry out daily spot checks at new car dealerships. They’ll require cop-like powers to temporarily seize new vehicles – which would then be subjected to 60-minute, cold-start, real-world road tests that’d be fiddle-free. Such tests would result in a new breed of no-nonsense official figures. 

Tell us what you think about the system for testing car mpg and emissions in the comments section below...




‘JLR’s very British approach: keep calm and carry on’

Editor-in-chief Steve Fowler praises Jaguar Land Rover on both its ability to handle a crisis
26 Mar 2020

'Car exhibitions are going through the most dramatic period of change in a generation'

With the changing car market, the government's petrol & diesel ban plus the unprecedented Coronavirus, the car exhibition industry is going through a …
22 Mar 2020

'We’ll always be here to bring you the best in car news'

In this extraordinary period of unprecedented action, fear not as Auto Express will always be here to deliver you the very best in car news
19 Mar 2020

Most Popular


MoT tests: six-month extension granted in wake of coronavirus

Transport Secretary announces six-month MoT extension for drivers whose cars are due MoT from 30 March, though vehicles must be kept “in roadworthy co…
25 Mar 2020
Speed limit to be cut to 60mph on M1
Tips & advice

Can I drive my car during the UK’s coronavirus lockdown?

The UK has been put on lockdown to help combat the spread of COVID-19, but does this mean you can’t drive your car anymore?
24 Mar 2020
Bentley Continental GT

Bentley’s built a horse-themed Continental GT Convertible

The bespoke Continental GT Convertible Equestrian Edition features tweed door panels, a walnut dash and gold “horse and rider” emblems
9 Mar 2020