Motor industry hits back at “false” Greenpeace emissions allegations

Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders says accusations by environmental charity are inaccurate and misleading

Emissions

The UK’s motor industry body, the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders (SMMT), has rejected claims that new cars sold in the country are breaching emissions standards.

A new report from Greenpeace alleges that 48 cars currently on sale fail to meet the latest Real Driving Emissions (RDE) emissions standards for nitrogen oxide (NOx). However, while the cars were found to pollute above the current 168g/km NOx limit, they were all tested before the new real driving emissions (RDE) standards were introduced on 1 September 2017. 

Diesel ban: What next for diesel in the UK?

Greenpeace says it obtained all the results from manufacturers’ own tests or those overseen by independent authorities. The charity cites the Fiat Tipo as the worst offender, producing 3.3 times more NOx than would be permissible under new guidelines, while the Renault Scenic dCi 95 produced 2.4 times more NOx than is allowed under RDE rules, and the Vauxhall Crossland X was 2.3 times over the limit.

Mike Hawes, chief executive of SMMT, called Greenpeace’s statement “false and inaccurate”, and accused the charity of “deliberately trying to mislead consumers”. Hawes said the authors of Greenpeace’s report: “fail to understand the new robust emissions tests and the timing of regulatory standards.” 

Hawes went on to add that the data obtained by Greenpeace was generated during the development of the new RDE standards:

“The results published thus far have been part of the testing of this new methodology and equipment but were never intended to be used to demonstrate compliance with a test that was not yet in force.”

'Real-world' emissions tests explained

Hawes reassured consumers that: “new cars on sale today are the cleanest in history and fully compliant with EU emissions standards.” He added:

“Thanks to ongoing investment into R&D and new technologies, every new generation of vehicle is more advanced than the last, with significantly lower pollutant emissions. The new official on-road tests, which came into force in September, will demonstrate that fact, as no new car model will be allowed to be sold unless it passes them.” 

Greenpeace’s own report, meanwhile, admits that the least-polluting models were fitted with a selective catalytic reduction, or AdBlue, system. This technology, now commonplace on new diesel cars, squirts small quantities of a urea-based liquid into a car’s exhaust fumes, bringing about a significant reduction in NOx emissions in the process. 

Writing in the charity’s report, Paul Morozzo, Greenpeace’s clean air campaigner, conceded that: “some manufacturers are managing to improve emissions in terms of NOx”.

What do you think of the Greenpeace report? Let us know in the comments...

Recommended

Road Safety Investigations Branch announced by Department for Transport
Traffic officer Volvo XC90
News

Road Safety Investigations Branch announced by Department for Transport

A new independent body modelled on the Air, Marine and Rail Investigation Branches aims to cut UK road casualties
30 Jun 2022
Rising electricity prices to cost car brands £90m in 2022
Wind turbines
News

Rising electricity prices to cost car brands £90m in 2022

High energy prices are hurting car brands at a time when other costs are growing as a result of the switch to electric cars
28 Jun 2022
Dangerous drivers who cause death could face life in prison
Speed camera accident
News

Dangerous drivers who cause death could face life in prison

A new law makes causing death by careless driving equivalent to manslaughter, with tougher potential sentencing
27 Jun 2022
Laws for remote control driving under scrutiny
Remote controlled car
News

Laws for remote control driving under scrutiny

UK Law Commission consults on legal options as public trials of remote control driving tech loom
23 Jun 2022

Most Popular

New MG 4 electric hatch arrives with 280 miles of range
New MG 4 2023
News

New MG 4 electric hatch arrives with 280 miles of range

The all-electric MG 4 hatchback rivals the Volkswagen ID.3 and introduces MG’s new MSP electric platform
28 Jun 2022
New Honda Civic 2022 review
Honda Civic - front
Road tests

New Honda Civic 2022 review

The all-new hybrid Honda Civic has finally arrived, but what’s like from behind the wheel? We find out…
28 Jun 2022
New 2022 Hyundai Ioniq 6 enters as sleek all-electric saloon
Hyundai Ioniq 6 - front
News

New 2022 Hyundai Ioniq 6 enters as sleek all-electric saloon

The Hyundai Ioniq 6 is the follow-up to the game-changing Ioniq 5 and packages the same EV technology into a streamlined shape
28 Jun 2022