Corn-based ethanol biofuel is less eco-friendly than petrol

A study from the US suggests mixing corn-based ethanol into petrol to make biofuel may not be as environmentally friendly as previously thought

Biofuel corn-based

The familiar practice of mixing corn-based ethanol biofuel into petrol may not be as environmentally friendly as using straight petrol, a new study in the US has suggested.

Research published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences says that corn-based ethanol “is not a climate-friendly fuel”. In fact, the study suggests it’s 24 per cent more carbon-intensive than petrol as a result of the change in land use required to grow corn to make the ethanol, in addition to the processing and combustion involved.

The study contradicts previous research from the US Department of Agriculture. Geoff Cooper, president and CEO of the Renewable Fuels Association in the US, branded the research “completely fictional and erroneous”, claiming it cited “worst-case assumptions” and “cherry-picked data”, Autoblog reported.

American oil refiners have been required by law since 2005 to mix 15billion gallons (68billion litres) of corn-based ethanol into US petrol each year.

In the UK, E10 petrol - which contains 10 per cent ethanol - replaced E5 petrol (five per cent ethanol) as the standard form of unleaded in September 2021. This, the Government claimed, would reduce CO2 emissions by 750,000 tonnes per year - equivalent to taking 350,000 petrol-powered cars off the road.

Whereas in the US ethanol for petrol is derived from corn, in the UK it comes from materials such as low-grade grains, sugars and waste wood.

Now visit our sustainability hub page for more on environmentally friendly motoring... 

Recommended

GM could re-enter European market with EV-only models
GMC Hummer EV production line
News

GM could re-enter European market with EV-only models

Investment in EVs could mean a return to Europe for GM brands such as Cadillac and Chevrolet
16 May 2022
New Green NCAP emissions ratings cast doubt on electric cars’ green credentials
Ford Mustang Mach-E - front
News

New Green NCAP emissions ratings cast doubt on electric cars’ green credentials

New ratings comparing whole life car emissions show little difference between many electric and internal combustion engined cars
21 Apr 2022
What are non-exhaust emissions from cars?
Non-exhaust emissions tyre smoke
Sustainability

What are non-exhaust emissions from cars?

Why tyre dust, brake particles and road wear can be a significant source of pollution, and how you can reduce these non-exhaust emissions from your ca…
22 Mar 2022
What are alternative fuel vehicles?
Fuel pump
Sustainability

What are alternative fuel vehicles?

We explore the types of ‘alternative fuels’ used to power cars including hydrogen fuel cells, LPG, CNG, electricity and others
22 Mar 2022

Most Popular

New Toyota GR86 2022 review
Toyota GR86
Toyota GR86

New Toyota GR86 2022 review

The GT86 has evolved into the GR86, gaining a bigger engine, a stiffer shell and chassis tweaks. Is it now affordable sports car perfection?
26 May 2022
New Smart #1 ride review
Smart #1 - front
Smart

New Smart #1 ride review

We get an early taste of the new all-electric Smart #1 from the passenger seat ahead of it going on sale at the end of this year
27 May 2022
New Ora Funky Cat electric car is out of the bag in Britain from £30k
Ora Cat 01 - front
Electric cars

New Ora Funky Cat electric car is out of the bag in Britain from £30k

The high-spec Ora Funky Cat First Edition lands with plenty of kit, but cheaper versions and long-range model also planned
27 May 2022