"British brands are way behind in the race for an affordable, desirable electric car"

When it comes to making popular small electric cars, Mike Rutherford thinks the likes of Jaguar Land Rover need to step up

Opinion British EVs

That's it, end of Round 1; electric vehicles have just been through their first full, proper, revolutionary decade on sale to a still-cautious public. The positives from 2010-2020? State-of-the-art EV tech, advances and surprises have been phenomenal; many pure-electric cars became more fun to drive than their combustion-engined counterparts; the EV-inspired reduction in air and noise pollution helped the planet and its peoples, particularly those in urban areas.

Negatives? Too many retail prices for pure-electrics remain prohibitively high; claimed mileage/range figures published by over-optimistic manufacturers are a disappointment; and we must concede that the UK’s flawed charging infrastructure must be scaring off some potential EV buyers. 

Another colossal issue for a motor industry that’s still new to this EV lark is finding the correct balance; the sweet spot that encompasses crucial consumer demands. They include (in alphabetical order): affordability of vehicles/insurance; desirability/image; levels of on-board tech/ power; range; size and type of vehicle. 

With internal combustion-engined cars, it was comparatively easy to strike the right balance, to give the customer exactly what he or she wanted, and at appropriate prices. Volkswagen was the master of this art from the 1970s to 2010s thanks to its car for the people, the Golf. In petrol or diesel guise, prices were sensible (from £20k-ish in today’s money), the design understated, with reasonable spec, power and space for occupants, all securely wrapped in a classy mid-sized hatchback body.

But now, with the EV game being a newer, harder, more complicated and expensive battleground, it’s not enough for VW to plonk an electric motor under the skin of a Golf as an afterthought. The purpose-built ID.3 is tasked with inheriting the ‘car for the people’ crown from the Golf, now in the late autumn of life. But outside and inside, the ID.3 lacks the class and near-premium look/feel of its old-school brother. As for the real-world range of well under 200 miles for the ID.3 I recently drove, that was desperately disappointing.

But if committed, paying electric-car customers in Britain, mainland Europe and Scandinavia are anything to go by, the ID.3 is already one of the more desirable EVs on sale in these parts of the world. In 2020 the long-established Renault Zoe and Tesla 3 were, respectively, first and second in this EV sales league table. But the just-launched ID.3 was third. Meanwhile, the Hyundai Kona Electric, Peugeot e-208 and Kia e-Niro were some of the other rising stars that made it into the Top 10. 

It’s therefore clear that small or small-to-medium pure EVs are the ones that represent the right balance for the vast majority of paying customers in and around Europe. Equally clear is that the Germans, Koreans and French are the current champs in terms of generating EV desirability and sales in the western world. The Americans, Chinese, Japanese and Italians are in the chasing pack. Meanwhile, we Brits are some way behind all of the above. Baby, entry-level Jag and Land Rover EVs can’t come a day too soon.

Do you agree with Mike? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below...

Recommended

Best electric cars to buy 2022
Best electric cars
Electric cars

Best electric cars to buy 2022

There are more electric cars than ever to choose from, so we've picked some of the best you can buy in the UK now
28 Apr 2022
Best fast family cars 2022
Best fast family cars header
Family cars

Best fast family cars 2022

Having a family shouldn't limit you to a boring estate or people carrier - here's our top 10 fast family cars
14 Apr 2022
Kia Soul EV review
Kia Soul EV - front
Kia Soul EV

Kia Soul EV review

The Kia Soul EV is more interesting than the e-Niro, with bold styling, clever technology and a decent range
13 Apr 2022
Mercedes Vision EQXX concept completes 626-mile journey on one charge
Mercedes Vision EQXX concept
Mercedes

Mercedes Vision EQXX concept completes 626-mile journey on one charge

Mercedes Vision EQXX concept travelled from Germany to the south coast of France without charging - and still had 87 miles of range left
13 Apr 2022

Most Popular

“Mid-sized electric cars are way beyond the financial reach of most mums and dads”
Opinion - electric car prices
Opinion

“Mid-sized electric cars are way beyond the financial reach of most mums and dads”

Mike Rutherford thinks the industry needs to face the fact that a lot of people can’t afford a brand new factory-fresh car
16 May 2022
Best electric cars to buy 2022
Best electric cars
Electric cars

Best electric cars to buy 2022

There are more electric cars than ever to choose from, so we've picked some of the best you can buy in the UK now
28 Apr 2022
Shell and ABB team up to deliver world’s fastest electric car charger
Shell charger
News

Shell and ABB team up to deliver world’s fastest electric car charger

New Shell and ABB-developed Terra 360 EV charger can add 62 miles of range in less than three minutes
16 May 2022