Skip advert
Advertisement

What car should you buy? The answer is generally whichever Skoda best suits your needs

Paul Barker explains the perils facing any petrolhead this Xmas. Do your friends and family want advice – or your approval?

Opinion - Skoda Enyaq

This time of year, it’s an occupational hazard for the Auto Express team to be cornered by friends, colleagues or family asking for advice about buying a new car.

It’s the second most dreaded question after “What’s your favourite car?”. That one is tricky because the answer changes with your mood – like your favourite song.

The pitfalls of the “What Car Should I Buy?” question are slightly different – partly because you know you’ll cross paths with that person again once they’ve bought their new car. But the problem is mainly that, in many cases, they’ve already got an idea of what they want – or may even have decided – and are looking for an expert to validate their choice, rather than advise.

Advertisement - Article continues below

It’s a mistake you only make once. A few years back, my father-in-law asked what I thought of the Chrysler 300C. And it was only after a minute or so of listening to my honest and not massively complimentary opinion that he dangled a shiny Chrysler key fob under my nose. There’s no digging yourself out of that hole. Believe me, I tried.

With time, it gets easier to spot the people who want you to endorse the choice they’ve already made. In which case you find positive things to say, unless they’re making a stinker of a decision. There aren’t many really bad choices these days, so it’s not worth telling someone they’re wrong

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement - Article continues below

if their heart and mind are set. And if they feel good about a car and it makes them happy, then they’ve made the right move.

But for the ones who are truly unsure about, and in many cases baffled by, the options, you switch on your work brain.

There is a stock answer. A brief poll in the Auto Express office concluded that it’s generally whichever Skoda best suits their needs. In other words, a practical, sensibly priced car that generally ranks well in the Driver Power customer satisfaction survey.

You end up asking people questions they hadn’t considered about how they use their car – whether they need something as big as they think they do, and increasingly if an EV might fit their lifestyle, especially with the way prices for used examples have fallen within reach. The elephant in the room is always how much they will spend, but if they’re flexible and patient, the right car will normally emerge in the end.

It’s always fun shopping with someone else’s money, and especially satisfying when you can guide them into a smarter choice. Just don’t mention the 300C round the Barker Christmas dinner table.

Thinking of buying a new car? Click here to get a great deal with the help of the Auto Express experts...

Skip advert
Advertisement

As Editor, Paul’s job is to steer the talented group of people that work across Auto Express and Driving Electric, and steer the titles to even bigger and better things by bringing the latest important stories to our readers. Paul has been writing about cars and the car industry since 2000, working for consumer and business magazines as well as freelancing for national newspapers, industry titles and a host of major publications.

Find a car with the experts

Skip advert
Advertisement

Recommended

New Polestar 7 to take the fight to Tesla, Audi and BMW with cutting-edge tech
Polestar 7 render (watermarked) - front

New Polestar 7 to take the fight to Tesla, Audi and BMW with cutting-edge tech

The new Polestar 7 is set to arrive in 2028 and our exclusive images preview how it could look
News
13 Aug 2025
New Audi TT: everything we know about the electric sports car
Audi TT design render (watermarked)

New Audi TT: everything we know about the electric sports car

The Audi TT looks set for a sensational return in electric form, and our exclusive image previews how it might look
News
10 Aug 2025
New Smart #2 could be the ForTwo’s spiritual successor, balancing price and quality
Smart ForTwo exclusive image - front 3/4

New Smart #2 could be the ForTwo’s spiritual successor, balancing price and quality

Despite the brand’s transition away from small cars, a successor to the Smart ForTwo is very much on the cards
News
6 Aug 2025
Buyers would rather have a cheap car than a safe car
Opinion - cheap or safe cars

Buyers would rather have a cheap car than a safe car

Steve Walker gives his expert insight on why safety doesn’t sell, but you’re paying for it regardless
Opinion
31 Jul 2025

Most Popular

At last! Ford Puma Gen-E is first electric car to get full EV Grant discount
Ford Puma Gen-E - front

At last! Ford Puma Gen-E is first electric car to get full EV Grant discount

The electric Ford Puma probably gets the higher-level grant because it is partly made in the UK
News
27 Aug 2025
DVLA classic car rules are outdated, a recipe for disaster, and I think I've broken them
Classic car Opinion header

DVLA classic car rules are outdated, a recipe for disaster, and I think I've broken them

Our man reckons he may have unwittingly flouted DVLA regulations when doing up his beloved BMW…
Opinion
26 Aug 2025
New BMW i1 will cram big EV tech into a small package
BMW 1 Series render - front

New BMW i1 will cram big EV tech into a small package

The all-new BMW i1 will rival the all-electric Audi A3 and new Mercedes CLA when it arrives in 2027
News
28 Aug 2025